4 ms·
I think the op overstates the power of these statements. Take the south park intro. It doesn't provide absolute cover for libel. If they make statements abou
by sandworm101 10y ago
I think the op overstates the power of these statements. Take the south park intro. It doesn't provide absolute cover for libel. If they make statements about people that to a normal person's understanding are not clear parody, they can still be sued. If it looks like Tom Cruise, and talks like Tom Cruise, and you tell the audience with a strait face that it rapes people, expect lawyers.
- dalke 10y agoIt's parody, not libel. Here's a summary of what the court considers in a libel case - https://popehat.com/2015/09/02/satire-vs-potentially-defamatory-factual-statements-an-illustration/ https://popehat.com/2015/09/02/satire-vs-potentially-defamat... . > Finally, the court will look at the statement from the perspective of the audience to which it was directed, taking that audience's knowledge and understanding into account. (Seelig v. Infinity Broadcasting Corp. (2002) 97 Cal.App.4th 798, 809-10.) > That's why satire and parody are protected even when directed at a fairly narrow audience. For instance, when the proprietors of WorldNetDaily sued Esquire for a parody suggesting they were withdrawing one of their birther tomes, Esquire won because the piece was viewed from the perspective of someone familiar with Esquire's history of satire and WorldNetDaily's history of nuttery, not from the perspective of a person encountering all these figures for the first time. Similarly, my post about the case is protected satire even though I made up excerpts from the D.C. Circuit opinion suggesting that WorldNetDaily staff routinely molests walruses. Most watchers of South Park know it has a history of satire, including last year's "Where My Country Gone?" depicting Trump being raped to death, or years ago "The China Probrem" portraying Spielberg and Lucas raping Indiana Jones and a stormtrooper. Comedy Central's own lawyers have a solid defense against the libel case you describe.
- sandworm101 10y ago> Comedy Central's own lawyers have a solid defense against the libel case you describe. They do indeed. But those defences do not begin and end with a title card calling everything fiction, as the OP would suggest.
- oldmanjay 10y agoAre you a lawyer who specializes in libel or just an assertive internet denizen?
- sandworm101 10y agoA lawyer with background enough to know that parody and libel are not opposites. I mostly deal with security and IP issues, but I do teach slander/libel in some of my classes. SouthPark's reliance on parody and the assertion of fiction aren't absolute defences, especially since much of their comedy isn't meant as parody nor fiction (See the episodes on Scientology and Mormonism which while parodic also rely on other defences.)
- dalke 10y agoMy apologies. I used the wrong term. It's not "parody" but "satire". No, satire isn't an "absolute defense." I never claimed it was. Nor did I say they were opposites. I was making a comment about a satire defense specific to the Tom Cruise and rape scenario you presented. You wrote: "If they make statements about people that to a normal person's understanding are not clear parody, they can still be sued" That is not the criterion. It isn't a "normal person's understanding", but a viewership who is aware of South Park's history of satire, including straight-faced satire. Yes, Comedy Central/South Park could still be sued, but to win it would need to be a scenario where it's not understood as satire even to South Park's audience.
- sandworm101 10y agoThat really depends on the jurisdiction. The UK famously has very different libel rules, and judges that are much less willing to tolerate satire, hence the "I'll sue you in England" line in SouthPark's Scientology episode. Satire/parody-related defences can fall apart when saying something that is allegedly true (ie "Tom Cruise is gay"). Truth is a defence in the US, but not in England and other jurisdictions that place privacy above "the public's right to know". SouthPark has in the past run some serious risks in this regard, but they seem more restrained lately.