4 ms·
I read an article the other day where police placed a bicycle unlocked in a public place, then watched it. Once someone took off with it, they arrested him. Sin
by Clubber 10y ago
I read an article the other day where police placed a bicycle unlocked in a public place, then watched it. Once someone took off with it, they arrested him. Since he didn't plea bargain, the judge gave him 3 years.
A couple things:
1. I would think either a fine or a 30 day sentence is more than enough.
2. I think it's bad for society in general for police to actively bait people into committing crimes.
3. That's about $150,000 of taxpayer dollars for a $100 bicycle.
4. Unrelated but important. In the US, it's legal for police to lie to you about your rights, what evidence they have, or anything really. I believe that is bad for society as well.
- koenigdavidmj 10y agoBike thieves have no fear in most cities, even when it's a $500+ bike (that is, any bike not purchased at Walmart). That's not easy to replace for most people, even engineers. Locking up bike thieves is plenty productive.
- Clubber 10y agoIf it was, why are there so many bike thieves?
- Pica_soO 10y agoWe should simply lock everyone up, who could become a bike thief. If you have hands and legs, i personally find that very suspicious. The problem is, that there is a strong retalitation instinct in humanity, to enforce group norms.That worked well in villages, but if allowed to be lived out produces ridiculous amounts of locked up people. Whats even more disturbing is, how those locked up people are not allowed to be a productive part in society. They get hamster-wheelian-jobs in the prison industry, instead of continuing with there real jobs. Everybody looses to the brain bug.
- gozur88 10y agoIt's possible if we didn't lock them up there would be more. Probable, IMO.
- gajjanag 10y ago> 1. I would think either a fine or a 30 day sentence is more than enough. What makes you think this will deter them from repeating the crime in the future? For a drug addict in search of a fix, bicycles have high liquidity on the market, are easily stolen, and usually not caught. Drug habits are not easy to kick away. Note that I am not saying that long prison sentences are an answer for this, just pointing out that a fine/30 day sentence will likely not work.
- jchendy 10y agoWhat does a 3 year prison sentence accomplish that 30 days wouldn't?
- gajjanag 10y agoAs I pointed out above, I don't think 3 year prison sentences are an answer. Just saying that the proposed solution of a fine/30 days sentence will likely not decrease the rate of bike theft.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Clubber 10y agoI think a prison sentence on someone's record will make them more likely to repeat the crime. With the criminal record, minimum wage, or close to, are the only options available. Also, it's human nature to believe you won't get caught. If someone thought they were likely to get caught, they wouldn't do it. Thirdly, what makes you think a 3 year sentence would deter someone from doing it any more than a 30 day sentence would? I'm sure the person didn't even realize stealing a bicycle carried a 3 year sentence. For deterrence to work, a person must know the punishment for the crime. Also, the 3 year sentence doesn't fit the crime. At some point, it becomes cruel and unusual. I think locking a person up for 3 years for stealing an unlocked bicycle that the police planted trying to bait someone into stealing it is cruel and certainly unusual. It's also pretty darn close to entrapment. What if police left a penny on the sidewalk and arrested anyone who picked it up and locked them away for 3 years? How much different is that from the scenario I described? How about a quarter? How about a $20? What denomination would make 3 years and arguable entrapment acceptable? Finally, we have a deterrence paradox. If the US houses the largest prison population in the world, why are there people still stealing bicycles? On the other hand, if crime is at an all time low, why are we still locking people up at an increasing rate every year?
- Evolved 10y agoI agree that leaving a bike unattended to bait someone to steal it isn't fair since there might be a non-insignificant number of people who wouldn't normally steal the bike but perhaps would rather ride than walk and would then feel guilty and ditch the bike a few blocks later. However, there are also professional bike thieves who break into alcoves, garages, etc.; They also cut locks and/or beat up or knock down riders if they can't get the bike by waiting. My point is, not all bike thieves are the same and if someone didn't fit the profile of a typical bike thief then instead of arresting them, cite them. I'm sure most people who are not thieves but who stole a bike as a crime of opportunity would not do it again if it cost them as much as running a red light does.
- tomjen3 10y agoBicycles theft is basically a "free crime", almost nobody ever gets caught. This also causes serious issues to those who depend on the bikes to get to work (or even as their work). As such the penalties have to be absolutely draconian when they do get caught - in fact 3 years sounds lenient, we used to hang horse thieves.