4 ms·
A good old friend of mine just linked me directly to this comment, and with good reason. Somewhere around the years 2005-7 I was involved in a light edit war wi
by seliopou 10y ago
A good old friend of mine just linked me directly to this comment, and with good reason. Somewhere around the years 2005-7 I was involved in a light edit war with a Dutch gentleman that rewrote this page to wipe away all reference to the Western Hemisphere as a geopolitical term. Rather than taking into account its historical usage, and _current_ usage in various fields, he instead approached the term on purely etymological, and consequently mathematical, basis. Western? Surely the part to the left. Hemisphere? That can only mean exactly half. I spent a good amount of time in the library researching this. Old books with old maps from rare collections, simple google searches, and more casual physical references. None really really backed up the etymological definition. I made a few attempts to edit, but eventually gave up. Mostly, because it seemed so pointless. The information out there (as opposed to online) was so apparently and plentiful, it felt like I was to argue that the sky is blue. So I let it be.
A decade later, and the results still stand. A bland, technical page with with a tabulation of the countries Within, Without and Somewhere In Between the two Sets dominating the page.
- nol13 10y agoWell he is technically correct, the best kind of correct!
- Nimitz14 10y agoTIL Germany is not part of the Western Hemisphere.
- Ericson2314 10y agoThat's a great story! I'd be curious what the page looked like before. I actually really look at the tables, but saw https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Hemisphere#/media/File:Western_Hemisphere_LamAz.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Hemisphere#/media/File... and then came to comment here. To the best of my knowledge I had never thought of this before, but it occurred to me while I was reading the opinion piece.
- yongjik 10y agoThe story of (almost) every Wikipedia page related to any kind of international politics, ever.