3 ms·
Besides the issue of corporate ownership / concentration, index funds are also increasing the risk of a market crash. One of the selling points for index funds
by lazyevaluate 10y ago
Besides the issue of corporate ownership / concentration, index funds are also increasing the risk of a market crash. One of the selling points for index funds is that they supposedly offer great diversification and this might be true in normal times but in a financial panic people will pull out of index funds and drive correlations to 1. E.g. if there's a crash in health care, panicked investors won't just be pulling out of health care they'll be pulling out of the market as a whole.
- ceejayoz 10y agoPulling out of large managed funds would have similar effects.
- toennisforst 10y agoYes, but this does not diminish the value of the companies in the long term. Remember that index funds are an investment vehicle for decades, not months.
- taurath 10y agoOnly if enough people stick with the long term. If everyone tries to hop off the boat for the short term, it can be a self fulfilling prophecy that growth will slow for a decade or more as the market hit effects real business returns.
- uiri 10y agoI'm not sure that a market crash is a prima facie bad thing. Market crashes often precede or accompany economic recessions but I'm inclined to believe that they are a symptom or result rather than a cause. An economic recession is a bad thing due to increased unemployment, among other reasons. If there is a real contraction in the health care sector and people react by pulling out of the market entirely then that is a good thing for people looking to put money into the market; the rest of the market is on sale (relative to its "real" value). Even if the market is made up entirely of indices, the market as a whole will end up appropriately priced. Those who panic sell will lose money but the index will bounce back assuming non-health care assets truly were undervalued.