7 ms·
Establishments want to project an image of class. It used to be class was associated with flair. The more intricate and multi-colored flower patterns you had, t
by rdtsc 10y ago
Establishments want to project an image of class. It used to be class was associated with flair. The more intricate and multi-colored flower patterns you had, the more wealthy you were. The more gold foil and ornate columns the better.
Then at some point tables have flipped (furniture pun intended) and mid-century modern, minimalist design became a sign of wealth. Which, funny enough had started with "let's make things functional and simple", stuff regular folk can use. So it got inverted a bit, the poor people like kitsch and flair, but the rich to differentiate themselves, end up with blank white walls and dining room furniture made from unfinished birch.
This in part accounts for why IKEA is so popular today. Now everyone can look like they live in Palm Springs, CA, but it is also cheap.
> The biggest trend right now is industrial design, which creates the feeling of being in a warehouse or unfinished building—and that requires hunting down turn-of-the-century factory
At some point someone decided that unfinished walls, exposed wiring and air conditioning pipes in the ceiling means "youthful" and "cool". Probably because those warehouse-like places in abandoned industrial parts of town were places artists would congregate, sometimes to have shows or performances.
Wonder if people will get tired of that eventually, and it will become the epitome of what office open spaces are with associated implications: hard to focus, noisy, ugly decor, loud. At some point we made fun of cubicles, and now we'll make fun of industrial-looking open spaces.
- Grishnakh 10y ago>At some point we made fun of cubicles, and now we'll make fun of industrial-looking open spaces. Yep, I remember making fun of cubicles, and pining for a walled office when I had one. Now, I pine for the days when I had a cubicle. It wasn't great, but it was a whole lot better than this open-plan crap. I guess it's a lot like a prisoner stuck in "the pit" or similar inhumane cage pining for going back to living with the general inmate population where he had to worry about getting shanked.
- ashark 10y ago> Establishments want to project an image of class. It used to be class was associated with flair. The more intricate and multi-colored flower patterns you had, the more wealthy you were. The more gold foil and ornate columns the better. In the specific case of chain restaurants, I thought flair was an attempt to replicate the cluttered-junk aesthetic that certain local joints acquired organically over time, not to signal wealth.
- rhizome 10y agoThe chains they're talking about were the original local joints. Read the article, it's really good and detailed.
- rdtsc 10y agoI was thinking in general more about ornamentation and flair used in architecture and industrial design, not just for the restaurants. But even in the context of some of those chains. I noticed those places which explicitly do the cluttered junk old-time whimsy are fine. Cracker Barrel for example, has been doing great over the years. Its stock in the last 10 years went from $30 to $160. The interesting thing about it, it doesn't aspire to be cool in a fancy way. TGI Friday wants to be a bit classy-cool. But it can't keep up with the times. Ruby Tuesday same thing. For example, in 10 years its stock went from $30 to $6.
- mturmon 10y agoYou're playing fast and loose with a lot of concepts here, and I think what you've written does not do justice to the actual complexity of the history. For instance, in your paragraph starting "Establishments want...", you're conflating the flair in the article (buttons on suspenders, walls decked with antique signs and implements) with rococo design elements like intricate patterns, gold foil, and ornate columns. This is not at all where the "flair" is coming from. The "flair" is about cozy, old, familiar things. Not rococo. And there are a lot of kinds of "mid-century modern, minimalist design" -- some of it was intended to be affordable (e.g., Eames designs like the bent plywood furniture), as you say. But affordability in itself is not a defining characteristic of modernism -- consider Mies and much of Corbu's work, e.g. the Farnsworth house. Or Wright's houses, some of which were affordable (the Usonians), but most not (e.g., the ones with bespoke furniture). Modernism responded to different imperatives -- e.g., form follows function, and stripping extraneous decoration in the name of pure design.
- paavokoya 10y ago>You're playing fast and loose with a lot of concepts here I mean, we're talking about global social constructs.. Of course you have to generalize a bit
- imgabe 10y ago"Poor people want to look like rich people. Rich people want to not look like poor people" - fashion in a nutshell.
- alva 10y agoDiffers based on location. In Western Europe, the truth is that truly rich people do not care about looking like poor people. The moneyed class are far more likely to look poor to the average person. It is the moderately wealthy who do not want to look like poor people, thus strongly broadcasting they are only moderately wealthy. Very expensive restaurant / retailer / auction room staff have to be taught this. What most people associate with super high wealth (brands, flashy jewellery, watches ), are not good signals of large wealth (high multi-millions). Hell, walk around the richest parts of London. The Saudis, apart from their gold plated Bugattis, spend hundreds of thousands in Harrods in Adidas tracksuits.
- EliRivers 10y agoI see rich people walking around with expensive carefully sliced jeans, simulating being unable to afford clothes in a good state of repair. Although of course nowadays everyone knows they're rich posers. I wonder how they feel when they see someone wearing old jeans that really have been damaged accidentally. Here they are having paid a fortune for damaged jeans, and this poor person here has the same visual effect. Maybe even appearing more authentic.
- alva 10y ago"Wonder if people will get tired of that eventually, and it will become the epitome..." 100%. Trends come and go. How we feel (guilty here) about the minimal aesthetic, was how those in the 70's felt about Avocado bathrooms and hexagonal print wallpaper. I can't help being extremely judgemental of that style, but I realise that I too would have probably found it attractive and in at the time. Our children will look back at Scandi-style with the same feeling.
- theoh 10y ago0%. Scandinavian style (pure forms, "clean lines", simple geometry) will last forever. Sigurd Lewerentz will never go out of style. My concern would be that we're not making more architects/designers who can produce timeless quality.
- alva 10y ago"..will last forever.." Architecture and design may last a long time, however that does not mean they are looked upon favourably by the zeitgeist. History proves this time and time again. I think it is a mistake to think "we have got it right this time", as if we are immune to these trends. We are very susceptible to thinking in this way. edit: Unless you think design is going down the path of constant refinement, eventually leading to some fundamental perfect design. I do not believe this exists.
- bluedino 10y ago>> At some point we made fun of cubicles, and now we'll make fun of industrial-looking open spaces. We have been for years. Exposed brick walls reflect sound, as do concrete or hardwood floors. Open ceilings where you can see the rafters and vents don't absorb any sound either. In my old office you can hear a lone customer support rep typing all the way on the other side of the building. Fill that space up with 30 employees and it's almost deafening. Sure, it 'looks cool' but it's a loud, interruption-filled work environment.
- scott_s 10y agoThere's a difference between criticizing and making fun of. We're criticizing industrial-looking open spaces. But the fact that you said it "looks cool" means we're not quite at the point of making fun of them.