13 ms·
Are Index Funds Eating the World?
- tedmiston 10y ago> That’s largely because index funds trade so much less often than active managers. On a typical day, only 5% to 10% of total trading volume comes from index funds, says a Vanguard spokesman. I'm surprised the author omitted it, but can anyone comment whether this is different for robo investors (Wealthfront, Betterment) vs a traditional index fund like Vanguard?
- atestu 10y agoRobo-investors offer you a portfolio of funds (could be a mix of mutual and index) run by companies like Vanguard.
- Spooky23 10y agoRobo advisors are like meta index funds. They give you the canned advice that your local Financial advisor gives you, minus the quarterly meeting and phone therapy when the market goes down, and plus some automated intelligent handling of capital gains to reduce your tax exposure.
- Animats 10y agoFrom the article: "Funds run by Vanguard hold roughly 6% of total U.S. stock-market value." So index funds are not eating the world. Most Wall Street traders underperform the market. Even the hedge fund crowd mostly underperforms the market. "A Random Walk Down Wall Street" is real.
- Retric 10y agoPeople own a lot appreciated stock they don't really want to sell and take the tax hit on. EX: CEO/Founders etc. So, the real question is what percentage of funds are index funds.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 10y agoI think the argument is a little more complicated than that. It might not be enough to observe that active traders aren't outperforming the indexes, because, as the argument goes, passive indexing creates its own market forces that tend to favor incumbents and work against aspirants.
- czinck 10y agoOwning a few percent of a Fortune 500 company will probably get you a board seat, and a 10% stake probably makes you the single largest holder (especially ignoring companies still held by the founders/family like Wal-Mart or Google). Vanguard's current holdings makes them the single largest owner of Apple, Microsoft, and Exxon (the 3 largest companies in the S&P 500, I didn't check further). And that's just one of the firms offering index tracking ETFs. Vanguard owning 6% of the entire US stock market value is huge. You could reasonably re-title this "Is Vanguard Eating the World" and be right if it wasn't for Blackrock and other ETF firms being close behind them. Sources: https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/AAPL/holders?p=AAPL https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/AAPL/holders?p=AAPL and similar pages.
- tanderson92 10y agoBut "Vanguard" is simply the sum total of all fund investors, since it has an inverted corporate structure.
- czinck 10y agoTrue, I got a little carried away with "Vanguard eating the world". I was just trying to get across the scale of 6% of the entire US stock market.
- tcoppi 10y agoIn terms of using equity to exercise voting rights, you complete give up those rights when you buy into an index fund. So to a large extent, the voting policies of Vanguard and other index fund managers can matter a lot, especially if they are easily persuaded by activist investors.
- qaq 10y agoThat inverted structure is BS you can only vote for people proposed by the management company for funds and in turn those people will vote for management company appointments. Whoever started this whole thing is still controlling it you just have an illusion of control. "Own nothing, but control everything."
- gnaritas 10y ago> "A Random Walk Down Wall Street" is real. reply It's a real book, but it doesn't prove the market is random, nothing does as the efficient market hypothesis is just that, an unproven hypothesis lacking even enough evidence to become a working theory. That certain funds consistently beat the market year in and year out for decades is enough to disprove the notion that markets are random; they're not.
- drjesusphd 10y agoThat doesn't prove a damn thing. When so many people are playing, there's bound to be some that consistently win, just by chance alone. The book discusses this.
- trentmb 10y agohttp://dilbert.com/strip/2001-10-25 http://dilbert.com/strip/2001-10-25
- tcoppi 10y agoAnd there are statistics tests one can use to determine if one's performance meets those statistical parameters to be random. Many funds and managers beat it over the long term, such as Warren Buffet, but the vast majority indeed do not.
- refurb 10y agoWarren Buffet usually invests to the extent that he has the power to change how the company is run. He usually uses that power.
- AstroJetson 10y agoBut maybe. Vanguard has 6%, Blackrock and Fidelity at 5% each, some of the other investment firms also offer index. I'll peg that all up, 45-50% of the investments are in some kind of index fund. Lots of money and market push there as indexes. Bogle said that there could be issues at the 90% level, so we are still pretty far away. My issue is funds that are Index 500 or DJI average are set by someone else. Hence the huge number of funds that own Apple and can push on them. When they rebalances those indexes, it can be a traumatic event. On the other hand, index funds are a way of playing par golf with your money every day.
- alaaibrahim 10y agono -- Betteridge's law
- Eerie 10y agoIs Betteridge's law of headlines always correct? Click here to find out!
- drewbug 10y agoEven better: "Does this Headline Conform to Betteridge's Law?"
- paulddraper 10y agoIt's 99% correct. If something sensational were substantively true, it would be stated, not asked.
- tedmiston 10y ago> If businesses are to be able to raise capital by selling shares to outsiders, “you need a deep market of active investors willing to take a view on the valuation of the company,” Inigo Fraser-Jenkins, head of quantitative strategy at Bernstein in London and lead author of the “Worse than Marxism” report, told me this week. And that's a terrible investment strategy to ask of the average layman, the people who are concentrating on index investing.
- drauh 10y agoFrom the article: A report this past week from investment firm Sanford C. Bernstein, titled “The Silent Road to Serfdom: Why Passive Investing Is Worse than Marxism,” "serfdom", "Marxism"... Let me guess: Libertarian Party propagandist.
- twblalock 10y ago> Let me guess: Libertarian Party propagandist. Or just someone who is well-read and likes to throw in literary references.
- 0xCMP 10y ago> > Let me guess: Libertarian Party propagandist. > Or just someone who is well-read and likes to throw in literary references. ~libertarian here: don't know him, but I'd bet he is what op thinks
- bloatisgood 10y agoIsn't active investing a zero sum game? Imagine a market with only two people and an average ROI of 7%. If then somebody has a 10% ROI through active investing then it follows that other one who also invests actively only gets a 4% ROI%. With passive investing you invest in a stock because you think the company's value will grow in the future. They are building a new factory or entering a new market, etc... The added value will be represented by a higher stock price which you can sell to obtain your investment returns. >The social function of active management, in a capitalist society, is that it seeks to direct capital to its most productive end, facilitating sustainable job creation and a rise in the aggregate standard of living. What if an actively managed fund gives me a 10% return but a 4% fee and a passively managed fund gives me a 8% return but only a 1% fee? Wouldn't the passively managed fund be the most productive from the investors point of view?
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoTo me, it's more saying "Paying us money is the way to freedom!"
- nikcheerla 10y ago
- cesarbs 10y agoOne thing I like to point out whenever this kind of discussion comes up, is that there is no single index. Articles like this always seem to assume that everyone will buy the same index, namely the S&P 500 or total US market. But that's not what a lot of index investors do. Indexers enjoy adding tilts to their portfolios. So some people will buy value funds, others will buy small cap funds, and yet others will buy small value funds. There are people who overweight certain sectors, like REITs or utilities. There are those who invest in international index funds (with all their variations) and those who don't. So there's a huge number of combinations you can think of when it comes to indexing. Now, with people indexing like that, there would still be market liquidity. Maybe not as much as when there are single stocks being actively traded, but on any given day there will be people buying into different indexes, selling shares, or rebalancing. Valuation would become troublesome though, but at least people would still get some return from dividends.
- tedmiston 10y ago> S&P 500 Plus everyone knows the S&P is a terrible benchmark because it excludes mid- and small-cap cos. After watching mine from a far for ~7 years, I've come to accept that one really needs to invest in multiple index funds to get global diversification as well.
- jonknee 10y ago> Plus everyone knows the S&P is a terrible benchmark because it excludes mid- and small-cap cos. Such a terrible fund that it is what almost everyone bases their performance off of.
- fmp 10y agoPossibly because it's relatively easy to beat.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoYet most investors can't beat it.
- twblalock 10y agoThere will always be active investors. People will always think they know a way to succeed in the market that nobody else does. It's human nature. Plus, there will always be VCs, hedge funds, and other high-risk, high-reward investment vehicles used by the wealthy to add some spice to their otherwise conservative portfolios. There may be fewer active investors than before, but that doesn't mean the market won't function.
- empath75 10y agoDoesn't it seem self-limiting? At some point, if prices become totally irrational, wouldn't active investors profit by taking advantage of predictable index fund transactions?
- bbayles 10y agoThis is an under-appreciated point... if 99 people leave money on the table, and the 100th person picks it up, we're back to efficiency in the aggregate.
- oli5679 10y agoWhat your saying sounds like the Grossman-Stiglitz paradox. http://www.wilmottwiki.com/wiki/index.php?title=Grossman-Stiglitz_paradox http://www.wilmottwiki.com/wiki/index.php?title=Grossman-Sti...
- Terr_ 10y agoYeah, it's a bit like saying: "But what if all the animals in the ecosystem became helpless herbivores?"
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ergest 10y agoThis article incorrectly assumes that smart investors would sit around and do nothing if most people invest in index funds.
- kldaace 10y ago"Yet Mr. Fraser-Jenkins has a point. Index funds don’t set prices; they only accept the prices that active investors have already set. If everyone owned index funds, he says, “no one would be doing” the job of figuring out what securities are worth." The situation described is clearly not a Nash equilibrium. If you have special, accurate information on the price of a security, then you're going to act on it. Why would no one be doing the work of pricing something if it's profitable? Sounds like actively managed mutual funds are getting antsy because people are starting to realize that they're getting screwed not going with index funds.
- logfromblammo 10y agoIf everyone invested exclusively in index funds, and no one works to establish a market price for each individual component, the obvious thing to do would be to adjust indices to manage the portfolio based upon actual dividends. All companies converge on the same P/E ratio, and the ratio of the index depends on how much investor money is chasing the overall productive activity of every [investable] company in the economy. It wouldn't be the end of the world, by far. But it is doubtful this will ever get even close to happening, because some investors will always be gamblers at heart, and if they learn that Coca-Cola is releasing a new beverage flavor, they will use the financial markets to make bets on whether it will be insanely popular or a colossal failure.
- DennisP 10y agoIf one company's earnings are growing quickly, and another's is slowly shrinking, and they have the same P/E ratio, I'm likely to skip the index and buy the high-growth company directly. If a company can reinvest earnings at a high rate of return, it's to the advantage of stockholders if it doesn't pay dividends. How much should the index weight it?
- logfromblammo 10y ago...illustrating why the price system will always be available to value things. If there is no market trade price for a stock, the only way investors can realize value from owning shares is through dividends. Increasing the value of the company does nothing for the owners individually if shares for a specific company have no individually identifiable price. Everybody is buying and selling through the automated index funds, remember? The only way to get higher capitalization in the opinion of the fund robots is to issue better dividends. There's no one to sell to at a higher price, except the other robots, who all have similar valuation algorithms, and will need to sell the same amount as your fund robot in order to realize any gains. But that is all absurd and moot, because there will always be a price, as long as two individuals are willing to move differently from the herd. As we are mostly humans in our market, that behavior is practically guaranteed. The outlier who thinks the stock is outperforming the whole market will buy from the outlier who thinks that the stock is underperforming. And their combined beliefs and opinions will create a price for it. Ergo, index funds are not eating the world. The fewer people there are that are willing to try to beat the funds or game their algorithms, the easier it will be for any one of them to succeed. So there will always be at least one.
- Analemma_ 10y agoAs always when articles like this come up, I want to issue the usual reminder to HN to beware of what pg called "submarine stories" (http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html). There are a lot of people who stand to lose a lot of money in fees if "just park it in index funds" becomes more popular advice than it is already. Not to say the analysis above is wrong, but just keep in mind (especially at the WSJ) that it may not be coming from sources with your best interest in mind.
- wldcordeiro 10y agoGreat point, I never had a word for it (thanks for the link) but I've felt this whenever reading the high-level economic stories about things like interest rates and the market slowing, etc. The cynic in me just assumes that whatever the author is saying will fail or whatever they're likely shorting.
- mc32 10y agoYes, but then what's that law of headlines ending with a question mark? The implied answer is typically "no".
- whacker 10y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headli...
- goodmachine 10y agoRelated: the hashtag #qtwain (Questions To Which the Answer Is No) can make for an amusing/ time-saving Twitter search https://twitter.com/search?q=%23qtwain https://twitter.com/search?q=%23qtwain
- sparky_z 10y agoThe implied answer is typically "yes". It's the _correct_ answer that's typically "no".
- nabla9 10y ago>warned that index funds might grow to the point at which new investments could be massively mispriced. This situation will be easy to spot from indicators like P/E ratio. P/E limited index funds will be new hotness and active investors should get better returns. There is bigger problem than index funds and it's closet indexing. Many portfolio managers that claim to be active investors secretly follow their benchmark index without exactly replicating it. This is fraudulent behavior.
- jpetso 10y ago> There is bigger problem than index funds and it's closet indexing. Many portfolio managers that claim to be active investors secretly follow their benchmark index without exactly replicating it. This is fraudulent behavior. As long as they can also provide competitive maintenance fees and tracking errors don't play against them, I don't see much of a problem. If they consitently do worse than the ETFs based on the same indexes with a similar risk profile, the market will eventually punish them for under-delivering. If they only make a few picks that end up doing well, keeping the rest of the benchmark for a balanced risk profile seems sensible to me. Please explain where the problem lies exactly?
- nabla9 10y ago>If they consitently do worse than the ETFs based on the same indexes with a similar risk profile, the market will eventually punish them for under-delivering. The problem is with consistency and eventually. Definition of closet indexing is active share below 60%. These funds are not consistently worse if the observed period is just few years. Since actively-managed funds usually perform worse than index funds in long term, closet indexing should be able to keep up with actively managed fund with same costs. Selling funds is mostly marketing. Asset management firms have several funds and they sell the one that randomly performs better than it's benchmark in some short period of time (1-3 years). Very badly performing funds are merged into other funds and new funds are created. Research shows that 15-20% of European large-cap funds could be labeled as closet indexers and 15% of the net assets in equity mutual funds sold in the United States are closet indexers.
- BlickSilly 10y agoNot an expert but seeing the quick rise in popularity in anything makes me nervous. eg. Index funds and ETFs. When Apple is the Number 1 holding of all index funds, and investors are blindly driving up aapl stock becuase they continue to want 'index' funds.. how do we protect ourselves and our economy from a major reset/correction?
- ttcbj 10y agoWhen people wonder what would happen if index funds become too popular, I usually refer them to Warren Buffet's 2005 essay, 'How to minimize investment returns': http://www.mymoneyblog.com/how-to-minimize-investment-returns-by-warren-buffett.html http://www.mymoneyblog.com/how-to-minimize-investment-return... It is essentially a thought experiment about what would happen if everyone switched to one big index fund. But, it glosses over the issue of individual security pricing and corporate management, which would become issues in a 100% pure index environment. Of course, we won't ever get a 100% pure index environment, because the closer you approach it, the more incentive there is for active managers to exist. I think what is really happening is that as more people use indexing, the less talented active managers are driven out of business. A small number of very talented active managers may eventually find themselves in a highly competitive market to exploit pricing inefficiencies, and they will end up incidentally providing management oversight and marginal pricing services to the indexers. These active managers will probably look more and more like private equity firms (taking an active hand in management), and less and less like traditional arms-length traders. As long as this small number of talented firms isn't allowed to collude with each other, or self-deal unethically by controlling management, everything should be fine. In fact, having met some less talented active traders in person, I suspect that the quality of marginal pricing and managerial oversight may go _up_ as the number of active managers decreases, and the less informed and talented among them are eliminated.
- smallnamespace 10y ago> As long as this small number of talented firms isn't allowed to collude with each other, or self-deal unethically by controlling management ... and I've got a bridge to sell you. More seriously though, the smaller the number of players, the more likely (and easy) collusion becomes. Successful cartels always have relatively few players.
- hkmurakami 10y agoThis is very true. So many active managers are AUM businesses rather than alpha businesses. Long only funds which use bulge bracket banks as sales channel partners are particularly egregious.
- cloudjacker 10y ago"warned that index funds might grow to the point at which new investments could be massively mispriced" Could, he says. lol.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- blazespin 10y agoNot a big deal. As Index funds trade more, than more opportunity for traders. It'll balance itself out.
- lazyevaluate 10y agoBesides the issue of corporate ownership / concentration, index funds are also increasing the risk of a market crash. One of the selling points for index funds is that they supposedly offer great diversification and this might be true in normal times but in a financial panic people will pull out of index funds and drive correlations to 1. E.g. if there's a crash in health care, panicked investors won't just be pulling out of health care they'll be pulling out of the market as a whole.
- ceejayoz 10y agoPulling out of large managed funds would have similar effects.
- toennisforst 10y agoYes, but this does not diminish the value of the companies in the long term. Remember that index funds are an investment vehicle for decades, not months.
- taurath 10y agoOnly if enough people stick with the long term. If everyone tries to hop off the boat for the short term, it can be a self fulfilling prophecy that growth will slow for a decade or more as the market hit effects real business returns.
- uiri 10y agoI'm not sure that a market crash is a prima facie bad thing. Market crashes often precede or accompany economic recessions but I'm inclined to believe that they are a symptom or result rather than a cause. An economic recession is a bad thing due to increased unemployment, among other reasons. If there is a real contraction in the health care sector and people react by pulling out of the market entirely then that is a good thing for people looking to put money into the market; the rest of the market is on sale (relative to its "real" value). Even if the market is made up entirely of indices, the market as a whole will end up appropriately priced. Those who panic sell will lose money but the index will bounce back assuming non-health care assets truly were undervalued.
- davidgerard 10y ago“The Silent Road to Serfdom: Why Passive Investing Is Worse than Marxism” good Lord
- ceejayoz 10y ago> Because corporations know that, says Prof. Heemskerk, coziness and complacency may arise. “If you have only long-term investors, how do you keep management on their toes?” We've a ways to go before the pendulum has swung enough in that direction. I'm more concerned about the tendency to seek short-term profits at the expensive of long-term investment in today's Wall Street CEOs.
- BjoernKW 10y ago> But, he adds, that would require indexing to grow immensely from today’s levels. Probably not until passive funds are at least 90% of the market could such chaos arise, he argues. That's a pretty hypothetical scenario, isn't it? Index funds, ETFs in particular, are a brilliant idea that allows ordinary people to participate in the success of market trailblazers. If it wasn't for index funds most people wouldn't be able to make reasonable investment decisions because they're not investment bankers who deal with that sort of business on a daily basis. Even investment bankers fail with their investments most of the time. It's usually just the few successful investments or things like arbitrage that balance out the odds. Ordinary people usually neither have the knowledge nor the resources to do investments this way, so index funds probably are the best option for accumulating wealth over a period of time.
- turc1656 10y agoFULL DISCLOSURE up front - I work in the index/ETF business. I help maintain ~75 indices, many of which have ETFs linked directly to them. That being said, I fully believe there will always be active investors. As others have mentioned, if there is an opportunity to make money in the market due to something like passive index funds being slower on the uptake, it will be made. If I had to interpret the core argument being made here, it is basically that there is a fear of a positive feedback type scenario where money keeps getting dumped into companies simply because it always has. But it can be highly profitable to beat out the slow, passive money by doing your due diligence. For this reason, active management will always exist. Also, I am fortunate enough to work on some of the more complex and interesting products in the industry (at least I believe so, haha). I can tell you that there are definitely sanity checks put in place for this kind of scenario. Most of it revolves around fundamental ratios built into these product methodologies (i.e. P/E ratio must be within a rational range, company must produce stable income for the past 5 years, etc.). More importantly, securities in these portfolios are frequently weighted (at least in part) upon those fundamental ratios. So if a company starts to deteriorate, the size of the position in the fund will be decreased. Much of what the article talks about seems to be negated by this and becomes a non-issue. I think those arguments would apply more to benchmark products which don't have those kinds of requirements. Then again, many benchmarks are used for exactly that - benchmarking - and aren't directly invested in. There are, of course, indices like the S&P 500 that have significant sums of money attached to them, but they are the exception, not the rule. Most index products deemed "investment-grade" are STRATEGY based, not benchmark based. Basically, there is room in the market for both. I think we are simply seeing the progression towards a new equilibrium, nothing more. That equilibrium is where the new balance of those willing to take a higher risk meet those that want the less risky, low cost products that we provide. There is simply a much smaller portion of the population willing to pay higher fees and have a larger risk (but with possibly greater reward). And that is due in part to the fact that many money managers don't have the returns to keep people coming back. It's also due in part to people's mistrust of the market (and financial industry in general). They are simply allocating their money in accordance with their risk appetite.
- hulahoof 10y agoThis comment greatly improved my understanding thanks
- joncp 10y agoWhen a headline is a question the answer is almost always no. This is no exception.
- bendbro 10y agoSo people won't be able to make money selling their stocks to other people. Maybe corporations will simply adapt and provide dividends that appropriately compensate for the price of the stock?
- ramblenode 10y ago> A report this past week from investment firm Sanford C. Bernstein, titled “The Silent Road to Serfdom: Why Passive Investing Is Worse than Marxism,” warned that index funds might grow to the point at which new investments could be massively mispriced. In which case the actively managed funds which identify the mispriced assets would start making money and attract investors again. You know there's trouble brewing in the industry when mutual funds are trying to sell investors on "it's good for the economy!"
- princetontiger 10y agoActive investing serves a valuable purpose. 10 years ago, everyone wanted to be in the hedge fund industry. Today, it's tech startups. Having worked in both fields, you encounter the same folks running from funds to startups. Hedge fund fees probably move to 1 and 10 over the coming decade, but active investing and price discovery are very valuable. For those willing to do the work, small and midcaps still can generate alpha. However, it will require spending many hours traveling and meeting with management and being engaged in the sector virtually nonstop (trade shows, conferences, reading articles/news). I think generalist active investing will go away, but sector focused active investing will remain.
- pbreit 10y agoIs it accurate to say that the difference between index and non-index funds is that a) index funds don't trade as much and b) index funds publish their components? Is there any reason an "active" manager cannot behave like a passive manager? Is index investing just outsourcing the stock picking?
- csandstedt 10y agoThis is probably the best article ever written about the efficient market theory and passive investing. It was written by Warren Buffett in 1984. http://www8.gsb.columbia.edu/rtfiles/cbs/hermes/Buffett1984.pdf http://www8.gsb.columbia.edu/rtfiles/cbs/hermes/Buffett1984....
- phamilton 10y agoIsn't the answer an index of hedge funds?
- gersh 10y agoCan high-frequency traders replace active investors in an ideal world. Ideally, the price should be the best estimate of the value of the company based on all publicly available information. When new information is released, high frequency traders should rush to profit from the discrepancy. Further, they can market make based off their knowledge of the stock's true value. However, this business should face increasing competition until it becomes a low-margin business. I don't see any inherent reason, active investing should be super profitable. In the end, it is just another business like any other.