4 ms·
The iPad needs its Hypercard
- aresant 17y agoBuilding a Hypercard-like tool specifically for iPad would be a great idea for a start-up.
- orangecat 17y agoExcept that Apple specifically prohibits interpreted code. You'd have to do a web-based Javascript version which could be interesting, but performance would be much worse than a native app.
- aaronblohowiak 17y agohypercard was never about performance
- mcav 17y agoJavascript performance could easily exceed the performance of HyperCard back in the day, in absolute speed.
- stcredzero 17y agoCould? Javascript is one of the better VMs. It's easily faster than hypercard from back in the day.
- jcromartie 17y agoThere are a few ways around this: First is to say "screw it" and interpret code anyway. Many apps do this. If the language was stripped down enough (say, like HyperCard) it might not be an issue at all. The second is to run the code somewhere else (on a server) and return the result to the UI on the iPad.
- rufo 17y agoYou mean like http://tilestack.com/ http://tilestack.com/?
- wallflower 17y agoCheckout what RhoMobile is doing - basically a scaled-down version of Ruby and web server serving up content in native app container. The drawbacks are that there is zero access to native UIKit controls (e.g. the flick, gravity feel) http://rhomobile.com http://rhomobile.com
- gte910h 17y agoActually, apple tends to reject apps built on app generating toolkits. You have to compile all the way down to code before you are passing that issue. Appcelerator's titanium is looking to be a good choice for some people. It's a little light on video playback abilities for my taste, but it's showing promise (I'm primary using it for android but it's iPhone capabile too).
- wallflower 17y agoAnd they have started to reject cookie-cutter RSS apps, as well. By raising the bar of "quality", they will get more "quality" in the AppStore. http://techcrunch.com/2010/03/07/apple-cookie-cutter-apps/ http://techcrunch.com/2010/03/07/apple-cookie-cutter-apps/
- wallflower 17y agoA Hypercard-like tool for Android that hides its ghastly Java underpinnings might be able to level the playing field more.
- sketerpot 17y agoApp Inventor sounds like it was designed to do that: http://sites.google.com/site/appinventorhelp/ http://sites.google.com/site/appinventorhelp/ (Fun fact: Hal Abelson is now working with Google on App Inventor. That would explain why it has some Scheme code underneath.)
- arethuza 17y agoDo you think that content would have to be available as a native app or would a web based solution be good enough?
- Terretta 17y ago> The web has made producers of us all. Not even close, and the imbalance between creators of content and consumers of content on the web is growing every day. > If the iPad is just another consumer platform for consuming and not creating content, then it will just be another way to watch TV or listen to music or download information. Convenient, yes, but just another device. The iPad is not a TV or an iPod. It's already a two way device. > To be something different, the iPad must not be just a delivery platform but a creative one, offering professionals and amateurs an opportunity to create a unique experience with interactive media. The device isn't creative. A piano isn't creative. An iPad isn't creative. The iPhone has Ocarina, or Layers, or Everyday Looper, and so on. There's no reason to think the iPad won't run such apps, and better. More importantly, most people don't think of themselves as "creatives", but there is content they do want to create and share such as email and photos or Facebook statuses. The iPad makes that easier than ever. iPad lets anyone easily express themselves to their social circle. PS. Speaking as a former Hypercard programmer, seems to me something as simple as iWeb can meet casual "info app" creator needs, while HTML5 + Canvas feels like today's Hypercard on steroids: http://www.canvasdemos.com/ http://www.canvasdemos.com/
- wallflower 17y ago> Not even close, and the imbalance between creators of content and consumers of content on the web is growing every day. It used to be a pain to publish content on the web. Then came along Blogger. It used to be near impossible to share or embed a video in a webpage. Then came along Youtube (who solved the hard problem of converting uploaded video quickly to a shareable format - which turns out to be Flash video) It used to be unthinkable/difficult to broadcast little bits and share it with people you know or don't know (Facebook, Twitter). I argue that we are all becoming content creators - the content isn't groundbreaking - it's just that some of us aren't reaching an audience because we're just saying "Hello, World". And I think the network effects of Reddit/Slashdot/even News.YC allows some previously undiscovered voices to gain a bigger audience, albeit temporarily. Also, the power of the Internet is in ability to connect. Niche sites (check out iboats.com formums). Witness savvy teenagers like Blair Fowler creating an audience in the hundreds of thousands on YouTube and (more importantly) generating thousands of comments on their videos (even the ones where they promote the product that they've been paid to do so). And, if you doubt the power of discovery mixed with random luck: http://twitter.com/lovelybutton http://twitter.com/lovelybutton http://www.timesnews.net/article.php?id=9015331 http://www.timesnews.net/article.php?id=9015331
- sp332 17y agoIf you want to see the Beethoven Hypercard thing mentioned in the article, there are some "action shots" in Douglas Adams and Tom Bakers' "Hyperland" video, about 18 minutes in. The whole video is really good, though - you should watch it if you have the time. http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=7190175107515525470&ei=6Ca2S-XLCoTWqgKpmq2TDg&q=hyperland http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=7190175107515525470&...
- gfodor 17y agoThink bigger. What is needed is a new way to construct software altogether, that works as fluidly with a touch interface as with a keyboard. Why are engineers so shortsighted? "Build an app creator for the plebes, but us serious engineers will never build software with an iPad!" On the contrary. Your keyboard is going to be slowly ripped away from you over the next decade. And you'll be happy about it. BTW: Starting this weekend, I am working on this very problem. Check back in 6-9 months :)
- pchristensen 17y agoCheck back in 6-9 months :) I'm excited to hear about it.
- Qz 17y agoI've been working on something like that for a while now -- maybe we could share some ideas?
- Legion 17y agoI never used Hypercard, though I am aware of it. I've noticed a couple of things, though: * Many people howl for the return of Hypercard * There are dozens of Hypercard clones/reimaginations/etc out there that no one seems to be using. What is it that the implementations out there are missing that make them undesirable to the people demanding Hypercard? Is it just lack of ubiquity, or something else?
- pchristensen 17y agoI believe every Mac came with Hypercard. It was one of those thing that you didn't really need and wouldn't seek out, but was awesome once you found it. It's like MS Paint + the web. Flash dev is probably the closest to it and Flash is so ubiquitous that it would be hard justify using another toolset for something like that.
- ziadbc 17y agoI think the biggest reason you don't see a hypercard clone take off is that html/javascript was inspired by hypercard in the first place, and the barrier to learning basic web development isn't much higher than hypercard-like tools. A beginner friendly IDE that inspires creativity could be neat though.