4 ms·
Its one thing to reduce vibration and fatigue. But increasing stability is a two-edged sword. If the plasma actuator fails, suddenly at 500MPH you're less stabl
by JoeAltmaier 10y ago
Its one thing to reduce vibration and fatigue. But increasing stability is a two-edged sword. If the plasma actuator fails, suddenly at 500MPH you're less stable. And no device is foolproof, especially one that requires high voltage. A lightening strike, an engine failure and the plane won't fly?
- hx87 10y agoPresumably the plane's stability without plasma wings would the same as on previous designs--with the exception of military fighter craft, who face a stability vs maneuverability trade-off, there are no benefits to making a civilian craft less stable.
- Noseshine 10y ago> there are no benefits to making a civilian craft less stable (Slightly) less fuel consumption? That's for longitudinal stability influenced by center of gravity. [0][1][2] > Most airplanes are designed so that the wing's center of lift (CL) is to the rear > of the center of gravity. This makes the airplane "nose heavy" and requires that > there be a slight downward force on the horizontal stabilizer in order to balance > the airplane and keep the nose from continually pitching downward. So moving CG aft decreases stability but also decreases induced drag (drag produced by producing lift) because the downward force required to keep the nose up is reduced, which in turn requires less total lift and a lower angle of attack. [0] http://www.airliners.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=761755 http://www.airliners.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=761755 [1] http://avstop.com/ac/flighttrainghandbook/longitudinalstability.html http://avstop.com/ac/flighttrainghandbook/longitudinalstabil... [2] http://www.pprune.org/tech-log/357859-cofg-induced-drag.html http://www.pprune.org/tech-log/357859-cofg-induced-drag.html
- j-pb 10y ago> A lightening strike, an engine failure and the plane won't fly? How is this different from every other fly by wire system? And it's not only electronics, when the hydraulics fail on a plane you also lose all control surfaces. I rather have a solid state system that merely requires voltage to operate than the complex system of moving parts, linear actuators, hydraulic actuators, and fly by wire electronics that is currently required.
- digler999 10y ago> How is this different from every other fly by wire system? In a fly-by-wire system, low-voltage electricity is used to carry information. Batteries and redundant lines can handle almost any conceivable fault. In a plasma wing, high-voltage electricity is used to alter the airfoil. Battery backups may be infeasible (or too heavy) for the voltages required. Or the ion generator itself may fail. > I rather have a solid state system that merely requires voltage to operate than the complex system of moving parts, linear actuators, hydraulic actuators, and fly by wire electronics that is currently required. The current systems also have millions/billions of hours of proven flight time, as well as the knowledge gleaned from thousands of crash investigations. I'd rather fly on a current system. Also, a plasma aircraft could certainly have a fly-by-wire control also.
- doikor 10y ago> The current systems also have millions/billions of hours of proven flight time, as well as the knowledge gleaned from thousands of crash investigations. I'd rather fly on a current system. Also, a plasma aircraft could certainly have a fly-by-wire control also. That same reasoning could have been (was?) used against fly-by-wire systems. Why add this additional complexity of a system that does not have the millions of flight hours of the old system. Just like most aviation tech it probably will first be used by the military for something crazy and then slowly come down to civilian usage. (I imagine the air force commanders would like to have their tanker/radar/non stealth planes have 25% longer flight time/range)
- stcredzero 10y agoPerhaps the system could be used to enable the manufacture of very agile but very cheap weaponized drones. Then future battlefields might look like an arcade game, with purple plasma streaks zooming in crazy paths towards their targets.
- digler999 10y agoJust guessing, but the industry likely migrated to fly-by-wire because of some quantifiable benefit, either from software-aided stability correction, or reduced risk of a mechanical failure. Maybe they proved that its less likely for FBW to fail than it is for a cable to snap ? I'm not against using plasma, btw. I'm just saying if one were built today, I'd prefer to trust existing designs until they have a decade or more of testing done.
- smsm42 10y agoYes, I also thought about this danger too when reading it. Also, assuming the savings are real, that means the aircraft would take on less fuel. Then, if the actuator fails and the craft is reduced to flying the old, less-efficient, way, it may be in trouble - e.g. in trans-atlantic flight or in conditions where there's no easy landing nearby, since your fuel consumption rises dramatically.
- lallysingh 10y agoYou can mitigate that by keeping enough fuel on board for a non-ionic flight. You'll use it in the next couple of flights, but will pay for the additional fuel used to move the fuel. That should still leave you out ahead.