14 ms·
Plasma wings could change the way airplanes are designed and flown
- Feneric 10y agoIt's surprising that even with the energy it takes to generate a plasma strong enough and in enough quantity to achieve the desired effects, it can still result in an estimated 25% energy savings. It goes to show how much energy just deals with drag in the current system.
- phkahler 10y ago>> It's surprising that even with the energy it takes to generate a plasma strong enough and in enough quantity to achieve the desired effects, it can still result in an estimated 25% energy savings. It goes to show how much energy just deals with drag in the current system. You've made an assumption that they are taking the energy required to create the plasma into account in their aerodynamic efficiency calculations. I didn't see any indication of the power required to produce the plasma, much less that number of power already required to fly. I did see the suggestion of using it on electric planes or wind turbines where larger amounts of electric power are readily available - one can interpret that availability as a convenience (high voltages and power are already there meaning less complexity) or an oversight (we're just neglecting the energy required). Nowhere in the article is this directly addressed. It would not surprise me if the truth were somewhere in between - it takes a lot of power, but saves even more. I've seen a similar situation in the hybrid car world when making certain comparisons.
- Justsignedup 10y agoDo we know if there's a lot or a little lost electricity that is generated as a result of the main engines running? I know cars waste a bunch of electricity (which is how hybrid batteries charge themselves when driving).
- hx87 10y agoCars and planes don't "lose" electricity when their engines are running; otherwise their batteries would be constantly overcharged. Hybrid cars just have more powerful alternators.
- JonathonW 10y agoHybrid cars don't necessarily have an alternator in the sense that an all gasoline car does-- for example, Toyota's hybrid system uses a pair of motor/generators (electric motors which can be configured to generate power too) connected to each other and to the gasoline engine through a planetary gearset.
- jacquesm 10y agoElectric motors and alternators are mostly equivalent, the difference is that the diode assembly on a car alternator would stop you from using one as a motor. Otherwise, they are roughly identical. That you don't find a 'traditional' alternator in an electric or hybrid car is simply because the electric motor doubles in that role when required. Almost all electric motors when spun will generate power, you'd have to do some work to get one not to generate power when driven.
- m4x 10y agoAC induction motors are the most common type of motor for anything other than small electronics and turning one by hand will not generate any output power. They are definitely not identical to an alternator. The armature of an induction motor doesn't have an associated magnetic field so turning it won't generate any power in the windings. Permanent magnet motors are the only motor that will generate power if you just pick one up and turn it by hand, and they are quite rare (and expensive) at scales larger than a RC toy motor
- jacquesm 10y agoSorry, but you're wrong there. Remanent magnetism will allow you to use an AC induction motor as a generator just fine. Absent any remaining magnetism you can 'flash' the motor core with a short DC pulse and then start rotating it with your chosen driver afterwards. Just one sample (of many) of people using this trick for all kinds of interesting small RE applications: http://www.smallhydropower.com/induction.htm http://www.smallhydropower.com/induction.htm
- Retric 10y agoThere is a huge gap between ~600mph vs much lower speeds of electric planes or windmills. As to energy requirements, it's likely fairly low in large part due to the expected altitude of 30,000+ feet. But also because the goal is stabilizing the airflow. PS: Drag force is velocity ^2; energy lost to drag Drag force * Distance or v^3.
- aardvark291 10y ago> It goes to show how much energy just deals with drag in the current system. All of the energy used during cruise flight (straight and level, accelerated) goes to drag.
- abakker 10y agoI am not a physicist, but, doesn't fighting gravity by way of lift mean that at cruise altitude the plane is still fighting gravitational acceleration constantly? Drag is friction, right?
- solidsnack9000 10y agoIt's true that at least some energy must be expanded to lift the plan, even were there no drag; otherwise planes would lift themselves. Drag is more like vacuum than friction.
- kd5bjo 10y agoKeeping an object at a constant altitude requires force, but it doesn't necessarily cost any energy. For example, there's no energy being expended keeping my coffee cup elevated, just a table exerting a force. From my admittedly limited understanding of aerodynamics, a plane's engines are only fighting against drag to keep the airspeed up, and it's the airspeed passing by the wings that generates lift -- if engines are necessary to generate lift, gliders and kites wouldn't be able to work at all.
- jasonwatkinspdx 10y agoThere's more too it than that. The airfoil causes a net downwash, and via newton we know the acceleration of that mass of air will cause an upward force. The finer details of this are something a lot of textbooks get wrong. Wikipedia's article about it is pretty good. With a kite the wind is the engine, the string allows the kite to use it. Or you can run on a windless day. With a glider the tow plane or ground tow rope provides the initial energy to get to altitude, giving the glider potential energy. As it glides that potential energy is converted to kinetic energy. The pilot uses their knowledge and skill to glide to places where they can gather more energy from updrafts of various sorts. I think it's really amazing how after that initial injection of energy, it's just all just skill and ambient energy.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoIts one thing to reduce vibration and fatigue. But increasing stability is a two-edged sword. If the plasma actuator fails, suddenly at 500MPH you're less stable. And no device is foolproof, especially one that requires high voltage. A lightening strike, an engine failure and the plane won't fly?
- hx87 10y agoPresumably the plane's stability without plasma wings would the same as on previous designs--with the exception of military fighter craft, who face a stability vs maneuverability trade-off, there are no benefits to making a civilian craft less stable.
- Noseshine 10y ago> there are no benefits to making a civilian craft less stable (Slightly) less fuel consumption? That's for longitudinal stability influenced by center of gravity. [0][1][2] > Most airplanes are designed so that the wing's center of lift (CL) is to the rear > of the center of gravity. This makes the airplane "nose heavy" and requires that > there be a slight downward force on the horizontal stabilizer in order to balance > the airplane and keep the nose from continually pitching downward. So moving CG aft decreases stability but also decreases induced drag (drag produced by producing lift) because the downward force required to keep the nose up is reduced, which in turn requires less total lift and a lower angle of attack. [0] http://www.airliners.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=761755 http://www.airliners.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=761755 [1] http://avstop.com/ac/flighttrainghandbook/longitudinalstability.html http://avstop.com/ac/flighttrainghandbook/longitudinalstabil... [2] http://www.pprune.org/tech-log/357859-cofg-induced-drag.html http://www.pprune.org/tech-log/357859-cofg-induced-drag.html
- j-pb 10y ago> A lightening strike, an engine failure and the plane won't fly? How is this different from every other fly by wire system? And it's not only electronics, when the hydraulics fail on a plane you also lose all control surfaces. I rather have a solid state system that merely requires voltage to operate than the complex system of moving parts, linear actuators, hydraulic actuators, and fly by wire electronics that is currently required.
- Noseshine 10y agoQuestion: Would that lead to some unfavorable chemical reactions that create undesirable molecules that we don't want to have in the atmosphere? It's an incredibly tiny effect per plane, but over time and given the amount of planes... so obviously only a problem for stable molecules that remain up there for a long time. I had the subject in a chemistry lecture, but it's been quite a while so I don't remember any details.
- j-pb 10y agoIt would produce a lot of ozone probably, which is harmful to humans at ground level. But exactly what you want to put into the upper atmosphere as it protects from harmful radiation, see ozone hole.
- goda90 10y agoUnfortunately it's not going to float up to the stratosphere from the troposphere, so a good portion of a flight will be causing ozone pollution.
- sp332 10y agoI thought most commercial flights were above 20km, where the bulk of the ozone layer is? Edit: Oh you mean the takeoff and landing parts of the flight. Good point.
- pmontra 10y agoCommercial flights are at about 10 km.
- Rooster61 10y agoI don't see this being much of an issue. Most aircraft kind of throw efficiency out the window while they are taking off/landing. You don't WANT overly aerodynamic wings at take off because you want exaggerated lift at the cost of drag. It wouldn't make sense to use the plasma until you are at a stage in the flight where you are more concerned about efficiency, i.e. cruising.
- ape4 10y agoIt would make me nervous to fly in a plane without physical actuators. But maybe I'm old fashioned.
- Rooster61 10y agoI didn't get that from the article. I think the idea is less of replacing conventional actuators completely, and more covering the the physical actuators with a layer of plasma to mitigate non-efficient airflow before it hits the actuator.
- hawski 10y agoFor now you're right, but for the future... From the article: > The technology could even replace traditional wing flaps, he says. Although the plasma-actuated “flapless” or “hingeless” wings are currently only suitable for smaller aircraft such as drones or UAVs, Erfani believes that further development could make the technology viable on larger, faster planes.
- Rooster61 10y agoI think we are a LONG ways off from having plasma emitters strong enough to make essentially lightsaber wings. Interesting thought though :)
- Myztiq 10y agoI don't think that's the concept. It's a solid wing with no moving parts and lift is modified solely by the plasma emitters. The entire wing's surface is still a solid material, it's just the plasma is modifying how the air behaves around it causing change in lift.
- mertd 10y agoIf it makes you feel any better, the actuators of the physical actuators haven't been physical for more than a decade now.
- sp0ck 10y agoNow we know why most of UFO's always have eerie glow. It's just actuators :)
- DiabloD3 10y agoIt also explains why they can suddenly accelerate and continue accelerating at high speeds: charged particles accelerating in a magnetic field.
- Rooster61 10y agoThat wasn't plasma. UFO's have vents that emit swamp gas around the vehicle.
- mcguire 10y agoThat technology was adopted by airplane manufacturers in the '70s---it's the contrails. (The side effects of those are just a happy accident.) All that stuff about ticket prices based on oil prices? It's a scam. They don't use any fuel.
- reitanqild 10y agoShould have been more funny if I hadn't argued for 30 minutes last year with someone who honestly believed this and was trying to sell this to a younger somewhat gullible (it seems) friend of mine. The guy who tried to convince us was well spoken, serious, in a middle management position and seemed to have swallowed it hook, line and sinker himself.
- lallysingh 10y agoIf you know a few guys like that, you have a future in enterprise sales.
- reitanqild 10y agoThanks! I actually have though I might move on to sales some day, maybe. If I put the same effort into that as programming maybe I could succeed. Edit: everything ;-)
- Rooster61 10y ago300% range increase on a drone size vehicle, huh? Imagine the application to conventional jet travel. This would revolutionize the industry, letting jets fly far further than they currently can.
- aardvark291 10y ago> drone size vehicle How big is "drone size"? https://www.amazon.com/DJI-Phantom-Aerial-Drone-Quadcopter/dp/B00AGOSQI8 https://www.amazon.com/DJI-Phantom-Aerial-Drone-Quadcopter/d... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_Grumman_RQ-4_Global_Hawk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_Grumman_RQ-4_Global_H...
- Rooster61 10y agoThey say predator sized drone in the article. My comment was based on that.
- ep103 10y agoI can't seem to find anything in google, but I remember reading about something similar some ~10 years ago for military aircraft. Apparently there were experimental fighter jets that had large ionizing beams of some sort shooting in front of the aircraft? The claim was along the lines of by ionizing the air in front of the craft, it significantly reduced the drag the plane experienced flying through that pocket of air moments later. I'm having a hard time finding articles on it, but it sounds so similar to this article.
- Gracana 10y agoFrom what they're saying in this article, it seems like they're just using it to push air around in the right spots, ionization is a byproduct.
- Rooster61 10y agoI think the difference between then and now in terms of making this a viable technology is the presence of computers fast enough to process the shape of the incoming airmass and shape the plasma to compensate. I would imagine the calculations required are fairly intensive.
- nkoren 10y agoThere have been theories for over a decade that the B2 includes a technology like this: http://starburstfound.org/electrograviticsblog/?p=21 http://starburstfound.org/electrograviticsblog/?p=21 (Edit: Here's the farthest-back link I can find, allegedly from 1993(!): http://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/ciencia/ciencia_flyingobjects44.htm http://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/ciencia/ciencia_flyingobje.... Alas, it's full of anti-gravity and over-unity and other such rubbish, but the bit about the B-2 using electrostatic discharge to shape the airflow around it certainly does sound like what's being referenced in the OP. Almost make me wonder whether anti-gravity etc. aren't simply smokescreens to fuzz up the S/N ratio of leaks about legitimately cutting-edge technologies.)
- sandworm101 10y agoThe B2? A stealth aircraft equipped with an array of pulsing electrodes strong enough to move air? I haven’t read anything about this, but I assume that these things are extremely loud radio emitters.
- paulftw 10y agoHelicopters use complex and expensive mechanisms to articulate rotor blades. If plasma can eliminate hinges on wings hopefully it can also be used to dramatically simplify the helicopter design. That'll be a real breakthrough.
- themartorana 10y ago"Corke and his team reported that the wind tunnel test item, which used “new actuators that developed 20 times more thrust while consuming 100 times less power, produced a 65% drag reduction.” The Notre Dame researchers have found that introducing a small oscillation whose waves move perpendicular to the air flow path can halt the onset of the so-called near-surface flow instabilities that lead to turbulence." Sounds like it's already a real breakthrough. After this it may just be a problem of imagining where to put this stuff.
- SolarNet 10y agoI think the point is that while it's a minor change for classic aircraft (replace some flaps with a plasma actuator system because it's more energy efficient). In helicopters it is a radical simplification and will drop the price and complexity of the key flight system by an order of magnitude.
- shostack 10y agoWill it have a similar effect on quads both small and large? I keep waiting for people sized quad or octocopters so hopefully this makes them more efficient.
- jakemoshenko 10y agoManned multicopters have already happened. [1] MIT has also demonstrated a variable pitch quadcopter. [2] If they can use plasma laminar detachment and reattachment to somehow simulate a variable pitch propeller, while still getting some weight savings over a design with multiple swashplates, then yes I think it should help the quadcopter design scale up to larger propellers. That's a big if though, since to simulate a negative angle of attack I'm guessing your propeller design would have to be pretty inefficient with all plasma turned off. I'm not entirely sure why you want this though, since the single large rotor is more efficient. There was a novel design a few years ago with one large rotor for lift and three smaller ones to counter torque and provide control. [3] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L75ESD9PBOw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L75ESD9PBOw [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vy5Ky50eGJs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vy5Ky50eGJs [3] http://www.geek.com/science/weve-been-designing-quadcopters-incorrectly-since-day-one-1577256/ http://www.geek.com/science/weve-been-designing-quadcopters-...
- devin481 10y agoWATCH MOVIE FULL HD Rome / PS3 Gaming https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x-ZjPtVBtRY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x-ZjPtVBtRY
- sandworm101 10y agoWhat happens when it rains? Wouldn't moisture increase the electrical conductivity of air to the point of defeating such devices, or at least radically increasing the energy required? And if that is true, wouldn't random differences in local moisture at various actuators on different parts of the plane, say while approaching a wet runway, result in randomized effects?
- Filligree 10y agoRainwater isn't actually very conductive, being pretty close to pure water. Water itself isn't conductive without contaminants. That said? Good question! I can't imagine that throwing physical droplets through the plasma would help, but maybe it wouldn't hurt. If it turns out to be a problem, then you'd have to design planes that still work without the plasma.
- sandworm101 10y agoI'd say that rainwater isn't all that pure, but setting conductivity aside, what about basic heat? Plasma is hot, very hot. Rain, liquid water, is very cold. To keep the plasma you would have to vaporize the water. That requires massive energy. And the amount of water on a wing is insane. Even if not on the leading edge, lots of water flows along the wing surfaces. At 300km/hour it would be like randomly pouring buckets directly on the plasma shown in the OP. I doubt it could be made stable enough without heating the entire wing red-hot.
- ridgeguy 10y agoThere are cold plasmas. Some of these "non thermal" plasmas have been used to disinfect wounds. It's odd to see a column of ionized air exiting a tube and impinging on bare skin, but it's one application in development for cold plasmas. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nonthermal_plasma https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nonthermal_plasma
- strongai 10y agoHats off to all those sci-fi stories that described future aircraft as enclosed by glowing silhouettes of various colors. We're living in the future :0)
- woliveirajr 10y agoThe article mentions airplanes and trucks, but what about trains? So much of the design is made to reduce air drag (look at ICE and TGV) and friction. I bet plasma could find some uses there, too, even as an upgrade to those old and slow models that are still in use. Would love to have a company selling upgrade to freight trains.
- nhallsny 10y agoThis article was in need of a windtunnel video showing the effect: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mVJjn1pt08g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mVJjn1pt08g . The right type of plasma can reattach separated flow. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_separation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_separation).
- curveship 10y agowow, thanks for the vid! can anyone explain why this happens?
- ww520 10y agoJust a guess. Ionized plasma has charges that attract or repulse air particles. Attracting air particles would make them hugging the surface more.
- b_emery 10y agoAnother guess: the article says the plasma actuators can create weak flows, so a small push of air toward the trailing edge of the wing would create enough of a vacuum to re-attached the flow.
- ridgeguy 10y agoI think the plasma region has a different kinematic viscosity than the un-ionized region. This should change the Reynolds number (ratio of inertial to viscous forces), and that should profoundly affect things like flow separation, turbulence onset - lots of things that matter in flow over airfoils. There's been work on kinematic viscosity changes due to plasma effects in plasma torches, but I can't provide links right now. It will be interesting to see how this holds up in real flight conditions: icing, bug splat debris on electrodes, low pressure at high altitudes, and how much electrical power is needed to sustain the benefits. Cool work.
- bjornsing 10y agoStrange stuff seems to happen when a neutral gas and a plasma "collide": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_ionization_velocity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_ionization_velocity One guess could be (as the WP article above seems to imply) that kinetic energy that would normally go into turbulence instead goes into ionizing the neutral gas (i.e. surrounding airflow). That would transfer kinetic (turbulence) energy into electrostatic energy, and thereby of course reduce turbulence. But this is just a hunch.
- byebyetech 10y ago>>“A tiny push at the right place and time can excite a much larger, and often positive, result.” I have to agree with that.
- sametmax 10y agoJean-Pierre Petit have been talking about this for many years, but has been considered a sweet lunatic. The fact he is a UFO believer didn't help, but it's too bad they discarded all his ideas because of it.
- mrfusion 10y agoGuys lets patent putting this on golf balls!
- iaw 10y agoSerious question: ignoring issues with O3 toxicity, could you strap a plasma wind generator to the front of a car to create downforce and reduce air resistance? Thinking through it I suspect the numbers don't line up for it to be feasible/economic but I've often wondered how we could displace the air in front of a vehicle without impeding the vehicles travel in doing so.
- Shivetya 10y agoOkay, so how does it fair in rain, ice, and snow, laden weather?
- fmp 10y ago>A scaled-down gale blows over a flat plate set inside the tabletop wind tunnel. Despite the low lighting and hazy Plexiglas view portals, we can clearly see the frenzied fluttering of streamer ribbons, called telltales, in the field of little wind vanes that carpets the exposed test surface inside. I'm really bothered by this style of journalism which feels the need to start off every story with an in media res narrative instead of just telling you the most important points and working its way down like a traditional newspaper article should. I don't care about the scene at the wind tunnel you visited while researching this story. Tell me about the plasma wings.
- jombiezebus 10y agoAgreed. This style is called "Long-form journalism" for anyone not already familiar with the term.
- effingwewt 10y agoI took Journalism as an elective and fell in love. I use knowledge gained many times a day, and have much deeper insight into what I consume. I highly recommend anyone who hasn't do yourself the favor of taking a Journalism class. I felt like Neo- I could see the code of the matrix and was no longer fooled by all the fake stuff surrounding me. edit- I could also form a deeper appreciation for the truly amazing Journalists out there. Diamonds in the rough.
- drjesusphd 10y agoI see this more and more and also find it tiresome. I stop reading and go straight to the HN comments. At least then I'll more quickly learn what the damn article is about.
- b_emery 10y agoIndeed. There is a reason for the inverted pyramid: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverted_pyramid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverted_pyramid
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sevenless 10y agoSo much for billions of years of blind evolution. Take that, Mother Nature! Don't see birds flying around with goddamn plasma wings, do you?
- sunstone 10y agoThis kind of stuff might work in the hyperloop.
- m0llusk 10y agoThis technology uses plasma to influence air flow, but the hyperloop uses a near vacuum to facilitate travel. Nothing to push against, as is said.
- sunstone 10y agoEven with the low vacuum the hyperloop's air resistance is still considerable at the speed it's going. That's why Musk's original white paper suggests a big fan in the front to move air from the front to the back the vehicle. So there still would be a substantial element of airflow.