27 ms·
An undercover cop who abandoned the war on drugs
- kaosjester 10y agoAnother instance of a cop who has watched the 'war on drugs' rage on and on, and came to speak out about the fundamental flaw in the approach: you can't fight a war against drugs; you have to treat the people at the bottom, hopelessly addicted users, like the victims they are. The poignant quote in the article isn't the one used for the headline, but this one: "drug policy should be about reducing not drug use, but drug harm."
- randcraw 10y agoYep, if obesity and T2 diabetes and alcoholism are public health problems due to dietary misbehavior, then drug abuse is too, and for the same reasons.
- mhurron 10y ago> if obesity and T2 diabetes and alcoholism are public health problems due to dietary misbehavior The US doesn't do anything about those issues either, so drug addiction is already handled the same.
- toyg 10y agoBut the point is that the US don't prosecute (and persecute) obese people and supermarkets, because health problems are not criminal matters. That's where the difference is.
- mhurron 10y agoEating too much is not illegal. The actual state of being addicted is not illegal. If someone broke the law trying to get their next meal they would be prosecuted. The US doesn't treat obesity or addiction, or we can say they treat obesity and addiction exactly the same. Also, "the US don't ... (and persecute) obese people," in just a few moments I can find plenty of people claiming otherwise.
- EdHominem 10y agoFood is not illegal, drugs are, even if you have a legal supply of money to trade for them. That does punish the addicts by arbitrarily making their behaviors illegal. If we outlawed you we could turn around and declare you an illegal and use it to justify the law against you. Why won't you just turn yourself in and end the manhunt? With that sort of circular logic in play it becomes obvious that our court system is actually just welfare for people in blue shirts.
- muhfuhkuh 10y ago"If someone broke the law trying to get their next meal they would be prosecuted." Yet, you can't arrest an obese person for possession of Big Macs. You can't bust them eating a rasher of bacon mid-bite and throw them in a cage. So, addiction to drugs _is_ a criminal issue. They are not treated in the same way. That needs to change.
- snarfy 10y agoAddiction is not misbehavior. It is a health issue. If it were simply making a choice it would not be called addiction.
- adrusi 10y agoThe point that the parent posters are making, quite obviously actually, is that it does require a few choices to begin an addiction. You don't get addicted to cocaine without ever taking cocaine. I don't agree with the moral conclusions that they're implying, but you have to engage with their point.
- ythl 10y agoI know what you're saying, and I mostly agree with it, but some fundamental part of me feels wrong about just unconditionally helping all the addicted users. It's like, they've made so many stupid decisions, disregarded so many warnings, broken laws, possibly harmed other people (theft, robbery, etc.), and now people like me, people who heeded the warnings, avoided the drugs, have to pay for them one way or another to get out of the hole they dug. And addicts are addicts for life - it's not like it's a one time treatment. They will be mental health money sponges for the rest of their lives (esp. ones that relapse), and the people that made good choices have to pay for it all. It just seems unfair. Uncharitable? Maybe. But as long as I'm contributing to a charity, I would like to pick the people my money goes to. I don't like the government forcing me to be charitable and then paying out my money how they see fit to people that make poor choices.
- magic_beans 10y agoThe problem with addicts is that they are born addicts. That is to say that addiction (to drugs, to food, gambling, video games, sex etc) is a disorder of the brain. It is something some people are born with and some people are not. Addicts "make poor choices" because their brains are wired that way. What the government needs to do is provide options for addicts to re-learn how to cope with life without resorting to their addiction.
- ythl 10y ago> Addicts "make poor choices" because their brains are wired that way. I reject this statement. Even if people are more prone to addiction, that doesn't excuse their choices. Otherwise you could excuse serial killers by saying "Oh well, his brain was wired that way. He got derived sexual satisfaction from torture and killing. He couldn't control his actions; he's not responsible for his choices." Once you blame genetics, then suddenly nobody has accountability for anything. "Oh, he did X? He didn't have a choice, his brain was wired that way."
- dota_fanatic 10y agoWhy can't both be true. For some people, they're prone but overcome their instincts through nurturing and support from their environment to be different. For others, they're VERY prone, and lack nurturing and support from their environment to be different. It's incredible to me how quickly we support, nurture, even worship people who are born into extremely good circumstances with all the advantages of the modern age, who are able to exercise common sense and ethical behavior (did they deserve it?), while others are blamed and despised when they were born into extremely poor circumstances, disadvantage after disadvantage (did they deserve it?) Context differs wildly and yet everyone is held to the same standards and expectations, when we're all just barely evolved higher intelligence, with severely flawed wetware. It's fucking ridiculous.
- josho 10y agoAnd if you are wondering what decriminalizing drugs might do to your country then take a look at a country that has already done this. https://mic.com/articles/110344/14-years-after-portugal-decriminalized-all-drugs-here-s-what-s-happening https://mic.com/articles/110344/14-years-after-portugal-decr... Though, I suspect the US would see different results because decriminalizing requires resources in public health, which seems to be overly politicized in the US and therefore not likely to happen.
- erelde 10y agoFrom the outside it seems like the USA are overdue for a deep change. Other Western countries (except maybe the UK, it may be related to the mindset of Common Law) have had multiple deep political changes. Think Germany, the current system isn't 30 year old, France is at its "fifth repupblic", Spain democracy was formed after Franco's death 1975, etc. In short the old world isn't so old.
- andy_ppp 10y agoI think Thatcher did change Britain unrecognisably as did the Blair government (immigration).
- alex_hitchins 10y agoI would say Blair did a lot more than just immigration. I'm not a massive fan of the man, but many of the policies New Labour brought in were radical. Renationalising the rail network for one[0]. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railtrack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railtrack Edit to mention it was I believe Blair who relaxed Cannabis from Class B to C, and Brown who put it back to B. C being the lowest classification.
- ekianjo 10y ago> France is at its "fifth repupblic" What does it prove exactly ? The Fourth republic was a total mess with extreme political unstability, despite being "new" at the time. Newness is hardly any indication of good.
- simonswords82 10y agoIt's old news that the police in the UK, with the exception of large scale busts that they continue to go after, are losing the will to fight the war on drugs [1]. Society at large are also coming round to the idea that making criminals of drug users isn't working. Now all we need is for the government to swallow their pride, along with the evidence presented to them, and change the law. As an aside, I always point people at this video about why the continued war on drugs will not work: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W8yYJ_oV6xk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W8yYJ_oV6xk. It's an interview with a retired police captain who is now vice chair of the Law Enforcement Against Prohibition (LEAP). Well worth a watch... [1] http://www.vice.com/en_uk/read/what-drug-cops-really-think-of-the-drug-trade-war-on-drugs http://www.vice.com/en_uk/read/what-drug-cops-really-think-o...
- anexprogrammer 10y ago"Now all we need is for the government to swallow their pride, along with the evidence presented to them, and change the law." Little chance of that happening when politics is pure ideology. They pick the course of action beforehand, for the manifesto, and seek evidence that supports it later. If your evidence supports the counter view expect to be ignored or ridiculed. So perhaps come the next government, depending on who gets elected...
- rwmj 10y agoIn some parts of the UK. Where I live the police are concentrating on the evil drug menance. It's going as well as you'd expect: a constant source of headlines for the local papers, no change in usage, harms, crime, outcomes, etc.
- aminorex 10y agoWell they do manage to destroy the lives of innocent drug users and their families, children. That's change.
- bostik 10y ago> for the government to swallow their pride, along with the evidence presented to them, and change the law As another poster has already quipped, there's practically zero chance of that happening without overhauling the entire government. It may be hard for us, makers and engineers, to see why anyone would obstinately refuse to accept facts as ever more data flows in, but that's not how real life works. Sadly. Politics and engineering are, in certain aspects, polar opposites. In politics changing one's opinion, even in face of facts, is a mark of incompetence. That's a big factor in why it takes so long to reverse bad decisions. While enough (read: too many) of the representatives who voted 'yay' are still in office, they will keep attacking any attempts to undo whatever they have done or approved. And because the big decision was to make all drugs illegal, there will be constant squeeze to push all other decisions further in that direction. Reversing the earlier error is simply inconceivable. It takes a new generation of elected representatives to revoke old laws.
- cloudjacker 10y agoHe probably runs Alphabay now
- EGreg 10y agoHere is his counterpart in the USA: http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=W8yYJ_oV6xk http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=W8yYJ_oV6xk
- tempodox 10y agoThe war on drugs is proof that politics has nothing to do with reality. It's only about defending some arbitrary ideology. And the addicts are the end-losers, victims of a war between reality and ideology. Funny thing is, I can relate better to drug dealers than to war-on-drugs guys. At least the pile of money the dealers are after would be real, if they achieved it. What the war-on-drugs guys hallucinate, I don't even want to know.
- ythl 10y ago> And the addicts are the end-losers, victims of a war between reality and ideology. Drug users aren't victims of the war on drugs (except maybe weed users). If drugs were legal they would still be hopeless addicts. Just because you can now buy your heroin at CVS instead of back alley Joe doesn't make you less vulnerable to addiction. Maybe they aren't in prison for doing drugs anymore, but they still might be in prison for robbing CVS to feed their addiction. Drug users are victims of their own poor choices. To say otherwise is to say people don't have free will.
- cmdrfred 10y agodrug user != drug addict. To continue down the thread of logic, any alcohol user is a 'victim(s) of their own poor choices' as well. I say make it all legal, and tax it proportionate to the cost of running enough rehabilitation centers nationally that any American can get treatment if they so wish (and include alcohol, tobacco and prescription drugs under that same mandate). This is really a problem that solves itself.
- ythl 10y ago> I say make it legal, and tax it proportionate to the cost of running enough rehabilitation centers nationally that any American can get treatment if they so wish. Seems like a pipe dream. Tax the drugs too much and you'll just create a black market and/or encourage addicts to commit crimes to obtain the drug. Tax it too little and it won't cover the costs of rehab.
- tcj_phx 10y agoIn many ways Alcohol is worse than all the 'illegal' plant-based substances that people use to self-medicate. When I met a new friend, I said to myself 'this woman is high as a kite', because she fluttered from topic to topic like a butterfly. On that first encounter she told me about going to the Methadone clinic every day. At that point she'd been going for about a month. Little by little she invited me into her life, and I learned that she really was self-medicating with the street pharmacy too. They'd told her that methadone helps with 'all cravings'. She was good for about 8 days, then she wrecked her car and had to move back in with her mother... Thenceforth she resumed using cocaine too. In summer 2015, she used Methadone for her opiate addiction, heroin on the days that she didn't make it to the methadone clinic before they closed, cocaine for her depression, and alcohol for her anxiety. By August 2015, with my help, she came to appreciate that she 'wished she wasn't a drug addict.' The internet told me that the best way to quit opiates is cold-turkey, which is how she'd done it previously. But she'd trained her brain to run on Acetate (the energy-rich breakdown products of ethanol), and became psychotic when the alcohol went away. This is a well-known complication of excessive alcohol use. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Substance-induced_psychosis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Substance-induced_psychosis Her mother called the mental health crisis team, who took her to the hospital. Even though they found cocaine in her bloodwork, they treated her with 'anti-psychotics'. These drugs were originally known as sedatives, and do not in any way fix problems for the person they're given to. Even though they knew her psychosis was the result of substances, my friend got trapped with a court order to take whatever drugs her psychiatrists think are appropriate. Anti-psychotics (and benzodiazepines) are bad drugs that make people's mental problems worse. She stabilizes while in their facilities because she's mostly sober. They let her out, and she turns to her old friends provided by the street pharmacy to try to feel better, and before long has to go back to the mental hospital. I can tell when she's used cocaine (which she says doesn't 'work' anymore) - it takes a couple hours for her to mostly recover. Methamphetamine makes her psychotic for 3-4 days. In my opinion, stimulants provided by plants are much safer than synthetic amphetamines. Last week I filed a petition with the court to ask them to investigate her court-ordered treatment, which I do not believe has complied with the requirements of the law. I also contacted the local chapter of the ACLU (American Civil Liberties Union) to see if they can lend some assistance. We have the right to refuse medical treatment, unless a psychiatrist thinks you have a 'persistent mental disorder', then you have to take whatever psychotropic drugs the psychiatrist thinks you should take. tl/dr: The drug problem would be easy to turn into a manageable public health issue if not for modus operandi of the mental health industry, which thinks "palliative care" is the best they can offer. (There's a psychiatrist who comments on some of these HN stories. I think it'd be really easy to turn the field into an effective, helpful profession. But they'd have to acknowledge the psychotropic pharmacopeia is mostly defective, and start over from scratch. There is much resistance to progress.)
- munificent 10y ago> The argument Woods heard more than any other > from his colleagues was: yes, the war on drugs > is hard to win, but just because lots of people > burgle houses that’s no reason to legalise > burglary, so we shouldn’t legalise drugs just > because so many people take them. The counter-argument to this is simple: Outlawing burglary works because people aren't addicted to burglary. (Well, except for a small number of actual kleptomaniacs.) Criminalization is not an effective treatment for addiction, but it's perfectly fine for dissuading other non-addictive behaviors.
- imagist 10y agoMore to the point, outlawing burglary works and outlawing drugs doesn't, de facto. The "why" is interesting academically, but hardly matters from a policy perspective.
- WayneBro 10y agoNot every drug is addictive. Marijuana isn't, not physiologically speaking. Furthermore a very high majority of users do not become dependent on the most addictive drugs such as heroin [1]. It's pretty simple to me - The war on drugs is not really a war on drugs, it's a war on people. People like drugs and alcohol just like every animal [2]. It's totally natural. However, certain other people in power have taken it as an opportunity to exact control over the entire world. With drugs being illegal - the feds get to take your money and property, the CIA gets secret money since they secretly control the entire drug trade, the DEA gets your tax money, the police get to invade your privacy and jail you more easily and on and on.... With legal drugs, none of that is possible. What other possible activity could be outlawed which would be as profitable? [1] https://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/drugfacts/heroin https://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/drugfacts/heroin [2] http://www.natureworldnews.com/articles/13791/20150331/natures-junkies-drugs-alcohol-why-animals-use.htm http://www.natureworldnews.com/articles/13791/20150331/natur...
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Not every drug is addictive. Marijuana isn't, not physiologically speaking. The idea that the qualification "physiologically speaking" actually refers to anything other than an imaginary distinction (as compared to the usual alternative, "psychologically") implicitly requires that there is some element of psychology that is not an effect of the physical configuration of the body (brain or otherwise).
- seibelj 10y agoLast time I commented on something similar to this[0], the downvotes came in strong and some physician told me I was out of my mind to want drugs legalized. I guess an article that makes the same argument more effectively keeps all the drug warriors from commenting. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12067684 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12067684
- ChuckMcM 10y agoIt was then that the epiphany dawned. “Every year the police get better at catching drug gangs, and the gangsters’ most effective way of fighting back is upping the use of fear and intimidation against potential informants. The most efficient way to stop people grassing them up is to be terrifying. In other words, organised crime groups were getting nastier and nastier as a direct result of what I was doing.” This is always the outcome of a proxy disagreement, and something I heard referred to as the 'witnesses dilemma' (as a sort of pun on the prisoner's dilemma). If you testify your life might get better, but other people will make your life harder. If you don't testify your life will stay at its current level of hardness.
- beat 10y agoThe purpose of drug laws is not to punish intoxication. It never was. Drug laws exist to punish subcultures. They're grounded in racism and cultural bias, and they're enforced that way as well. It's not about the addicts. It's about the blacks and the Mexicans and the hippies and the punks. The undesirables. Drug laws are an excuse for police to harass anyone who doesn't look "right". If we can't accept this basic fact, if we have to lie to others (and ourselves) about it, we can't have an honest conversation about drugs.
- gozur88 10y agoThat's not a fact at all. It's not even true. Drugs are illegal or heavily restricted in every country in the world, including countries that are nearly homogeneous. Drugs are illegal because drug addicts cause problems for the people around them. It's really that simple.
- jahnu 10y agoThe truth is a a mixture of all that really. Sometimes drugs are prohibited for health reasons, sometimes for cultural reasons, sometimes for commercial reasons, and so on and in all countries some drugs are not prohibited at all. Enforcement is similarly varied.
- kafkaesq 10y agoIt's really that simple. No, it's not. For a whole host of ideological reasons, certain problem-causing agents (like alcohol and tobacco) are tolerated, despite their deadly and very costly impact on society, while others are not. I didn't like the comment above yours either, BTW. Both are untenable oversimplifications.
- gozur88 10y agoIn the US they tried to make alcohol illegal for the same reason heroin and cocaine are illegal. Tobacco and caffeine don't cause the same sorts of problem. Nobody is going to break into your house while you're at work because they can't afford smokes. Smokers and coffee drinkers can hold down jobs and they don't OD at age 22, leaving behind kids the community has to take care of.