3 ms·
> you'd at least have an uphill battle to fight in order to prove that it wasn't you that did the thing that got you into trouble. Aren't you innocent until pr
by jstanley 10y ago
> you'd at least have an uphill battle to fight in order to prove that it wasn't you that did the thing that got you into trouble.
Aren't you innocent until proven guilty? Simply saying "I have a guest network" surely constitutes reasonable doubt, in the absence of any other evidence against you.
- mariuolo 10y ago> Aren't you innocent until proven guilty? Simply saying "I have a guest network" surely constitutes reasonable doubt, in the absence of any other evidence against you. You'd still face an average of 6 years of legal wrangling and attendant expenses.
- Proof 10y agoSadly, the way Justice System is working nowadays is that majority of cases end with a plea due to overwhelming pressure from the prosecutors. So, theoretically one could ride the reasonable-doubt-train all the way to court but at that point, the prosecutor would stack any charge possible leaving the jury to deliberate on all them. Modern day juries still most likely are not computer savvy so, merely stating "IP Address" would most likely be enough to convict. It is also needs to be added that if the charges are severe enough, even though every defendant is innocent until proven guilty, in reality it is the opposite way around if the said crime is vehemently disliked by all.
- icebraining 10y agoDo they use juries for these matters in Italy?
- qubex 10y agoNo.
- _ph_ 10y agoNo, you are still liable as the operator of any public network you provide. In Germany they tried to create better legal protection for public wifi providers, but it is still not clear that you are completely off the hook.
- catwell 10y agoIn France at least they made "insufficiently securing your home network" an offense. So you could argue that you have a guest network (or were hacked) but you would still not be in the clear.
- josho 10y agoThat is insane. Think about real world parallels: - Leaving a window open, or a door unlocked, thereby allowing someone to enter through it, and while on your premise conducts a crime. Is this crime your fault for not sufficiently securing your home? - Someone enters your yard because the gate wasn't locked and sells some pirated movies or drugs. Again, is it your fault because you didn't sufficiently secure your 6 foot fence from intruders?
- tamana 10y agoYes, you absolutely can be liable if your contributory negligence enables someone to commit a crime or get hurt. This is decades or centuries old law.
- josho 10y agoIt genuinely saddens me that providing an open Wifi guest network for my guest's convenience is considered 'negligence'. Interestingly where I leave a major Canadian ISP provides unsecured wifi networks across the city. To get access all you need to do is register your ethernet address to your account. As we know it is trivial to spoof an ethernet address. So, I suppose this ISP could be liable as well? Oh, wait--they are just the pipe. So, why is the consumer treated different? Sigh.
- noonespecial 10y agoOf course. It will cost a mere $300k in legal fees and 6 months in court to prove yourself so.