5 ms·
Sure, as long as you're willing to pay for the sprawl of infrastructure needed to support all those towns spread out everywhere, 'cause as an urban dweller, I s
by icebraining 10y ago
Sure, as long as you're willing to pay for the sprawl of infrastructure needed to support all those towns spread out everywhere, 'cause as an urban dweller, I sure ain't.
Small towns are awesome if you want to live a mostly self-sufficient life. For most people, who want cheap crap dropped on their doorstep every other week, food coming from hundreds of miles, cable TV with 300 channels and fast internet, they just mean more roads, more trucks, more driving, more heating, more pollution.
- twistedpair 10y ago> pay for the sprawl of infrastructure needed to support all those towns spread out everywhere You mean the septic tank, well, and solar panels? Plus the dirt road? Frankly the only infrastructure you really need is the high speed internet connection.
- icebraining 10y agoNo, I mean the hospitals, schools, warehouses, postal service, shops, electricity generation and distribution, mobile towers, roads that can support the trucks that transport everything, etc - and then the human infrastructure: courts, police, administration, etc.
- douche 10y agoThat stuff already exists. In many cases, it's the only thing that still exists. In the podunk little town I grew up in, every scrid of industry has been outsourced or regulated out of existence, but the schools, hospital, local college, government services, and utilites are still around, and are the primary sources of employment, by an overwhelming margin. If you could halt the brain and youth drain out of the area, and put some people that were making real money back into the community, you could support some actual businesses, besides the WalMart and the gas station. I actually have faster internet when I go visit my parents up there than I do where I live in the suburbs...
- icebraining 10y agoThat stuff already exists. In many cases, it's the only thing that still exists. In the podunk little town I grew up in, every scrid of industry has been outsourced or regulated out of existence, but the schools, hospital, local college, government services, and utilites are still around Just because the buildings exist doesn't mean they're now free; they have to be supplied and maintained, each and every one. If you could halt the brain and youth drain out of the area, and put some people that were making real money back into the community, you could support some actual businesses, besides the WalMart and the gas station. But why would we do that? What's the point of having "some actual businesses" in a podunk little town, where they'll be cutoff from the wider industry and where everything they need and produce (assuming it's not just software) must be shipped a bunch of extra miles? My whole point is that small towns are inefficient unless the inhabitants are willing to be mostly self-sufficient. Supporting the creation of businesses, which require by definition tons of infrastructure and usually transportation of stuff goes directly against that.
- ghaff 10y agoHere's the thing. We already have towns spread everywhere--just like in pretty much every country in the world. The US is a large country. I live in an exurban town that's adjacent to a couple of older/smaller manufacturing cities within an hour of a major tech metropolis (though my office is actually much closer). I have septic, pay for water, pay for trash pickup, etc. And, not that I object (as I go into the city a fair bit), but a lot of my taxes seem to go into urban infrastructure projects. It's not black and white. It's not central Manhattan and the middle of Montana. [ADDED: And, by the way, my town was founded in 1653. It's not some recent suburban sprawl addition.]
- gozur88 10y agoThis. There are all kinds of rural US towns with existing infrastructure that are slipping beneath the waves because there aren't any jobs. Not everyone wants to live in Manhattan - if I could telecommute from a more rural location I would.
- ghaff 10y agoThe town I live in is in pretty good shape because it's on the outer ring of the Boston commuting radius--with pretty good rail. Plus until quite recently essentially all Boston tech was west of the city anyway. But this idea that, if only we herded everyone into cities and stopped spending on other infrastructure, everything would be great is... silly.
- zyxley 10y agoNew England, and indeed much of the East Coast, is a far cry from the rest of the country. The width of the entire state of Massachusetts is smaller than the distance between some neighboring towns in the Midwest.
- ghaff 10y agoYes, but the point remains that all those spread-out towns already exist. Unless they're actually abandoned we're not going to bulldoze them. The difference is that they're not within daily/weekly commuting distances of tech centers as are many of the outlying areas of most tech centers--the Bay Area being something of an exception. So living there would be true remote working as opposed to just not living in a desired city core.