3 ms·
>The issue is that the profit comes before the education. ... That sounds like a fully-general argument against provision of any good by a for-profit business:
by SilasX 10y ago
>The issue is that the profit comes before the education. ...
That sounds like a fully-general argument against provision of any good by a for-profit business: "The issue with private farms is that the profit comes before the food." "The issue with private semiconductors is the profit comes before the computational efficiency."
True, profits do bring the potential for fraud, abuse, etc., but obviously there are at least some situations where that can all be contained. What's special about education per se?
You cite abuses, but are those artifacts of the for-profit part, or the "students generally don't have good information about what a given school will do for their career"? I mean, there are lots of cases of students at "non-profit" public universities who are drowning in debt from a worthless degree.
- commandar 10y ago>What's special about education per se? In the US? The fact that it gets paid for with loans that aren't dischargeable in bankruptcy.
- SilasX 10y agoI meant, what's special in terms of profits skewing incentives.
- Goronmon 10y agoI would argue it's a combination of the high cost (we aren't talking about people ending up with a few thousand dollars of debt), the fact that it might take years to determine if any given school is actually not terrible, and the fact that "education" itself is given special considerations over many products and services.