5 ms·
I remember someone a while back posted a lecture page from CMU. They support Trigger Warnings. And a few papers there had them. It was a database course, I can
by rdtsc 10y ago
I remember someone a while back posted a lecture page from CMU. They support Trigger Warnings. And a few papers there had them.
It was a database course, I can only imagine "master/slave" terminology.
So I was wondering, how are Trigger Warning supposed to work? Can the student refuse to do the required reading and claim full credit because might be triggered, seems like it would open loophole.
That was just CS stuff. What about history, that's full of prejudiced offensive language and terminology. Can students avoid doing required work by claiming they'd be triggered?
Is there anyone undertaking an effort to sanitize records to "fix" the triggers. For example take some classic distributed system papers and search and replace master/slave with leader/follower?
I can understand wanting to have safe spaces. But I don't quite follow how trigger warnings resolve themselves in the context of classroom learning. Any recent grads have any experience with how this is handled?
EDIT: I think it was a link like this (even perhaps this exact course, just for last year).
http://15721.courses.cs.cmu.edu/spring2016/schedule.html http://15721.courses.cs.cmu.edu/spring2016/schedule.html
---
Concurrency Control III — Optimistic /!\
...
/!\ : Trigger warning: The material presented in this lecture uses explicit language and discusses certain situations in database management systems that may be triggering to some students.
---
Are students allowed to pass without learning and being tested on Optimistic Concurrency Control in databases? If not, what is the purpose of the warning, just to have them mentally prepare for it?
- ohitsdom 10y agoSee, my understanding of trigger warnings is more to prepare and forewarn students of difficult discussions. Like- "we're going to be talking about rape and its psychological effects tomorrow." Not- "WARNING- this textbook uses the word 'violate' when discussing DBs." The first example seems like an obvious common courtesy, the second seems pointless. I say pointless because some words are used in everyday life in normal ways that may be "triggering", but that's entirely different from an in-depth discussion of a sensitive topic that's triggering. But that's obviously just my opinion, I'm sure many disagree and that's why this is such a hot button issue right now.
- vertex-four 10y agoAllowing people to ensure that they're in a mental state to handle a topic before they handle it is reasonably important. Mind, in the case of master/slave, the term "trigger warning" is likely misused and a simple statement of "these used to be the standard terms for discussing this, now many people use leader/follower" is reasonable. Explaining historical context to things that may be upsetting can never be a bad thing, IMHO.
- ebola1717 10y agoYeah, it seems like CMU was overzealous in how it implemented this policy here. I would be surprised if a lot of students disagreed. It's annoying that people bring up examples like this to dismiss the concepts entirely, because obviously we can and should have a discussion on when they're useful.