5 ms·
I can't decide whether or not I'm playing devil's advocate with this question. In any case, please don't take it too seriously, but I think it might be interest
by mikeash 10y ago
I can't decide whether or not I'm playing devil's advocate with this question. In any case, please don't take it too seriously, but I think it might be interesting.
Why did you not include a trigger warning about the discussion of rape in your comment?
- zyxley 10y ago"Mention of rape" and "discussion of rape in enough detail to cause discomfort" are not the same thing.
- mikeash 10y agoI'm sure we can find someone who is uncomfortable at the mere mention of the word. Not that we should necessarily accommodate such extremes, but how do you decide where to draw the line?
- qntty 10y agoYou guess and invite people to correct you if you're wrong? How is anything that requires judgement decided? Eventually there will be an accepted norm but at the beginning there never is.
- deong 10y agoThat's a nice solution if everything is more or less working properly. The problem is, "What do you do when they tell you you're wrong about everything?" One of the links in the article was to an article by a law professor talking about the difficulty of teaching rape and sexual assault law. The point being made there was that the entire subject has become off-limits -- literally, a large number of her colleagues had simply elected not to teach it anymore. If your complaint is that, today, students are demanding an abuse of the notion of trigger warnings and safe spaces to effectively prevent exposure to potentially upsetting discussions, and that we are harming the long-term development of students by doing so, then by definition, you believe the corrections you'd get would essentially take the form "bring back all the trigger warnings we had when you started this process".
- jpfed 10y agoIf we try to have a culture that considers trigger warnings a courtesy worth extending, rather than having a policy saying yes/no, then the question of where the line should be drawn can be answered by each instructor as they see fit. It's likely that a few obviously triggering things can be labelled as such and good can be derived from that even if we can't or shouldn't label everything.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoYou work together to find a reasonable balance between accommodating the most common and severe trauma triggers without shutting down general discussion. For example, there are people who were raped by a man with a deep voice and are triggered by men with deep voices. That's a really shitty situation to be in, but it's unreasonably onerous to expect deep-voiced men to warn everyone in the vicinity (perhaps with a sign) before speaking, especially since there are very few people with that particular trigger. Asking people to give a warning before they intend to discuss rape in detail is not onerous, and it helps a rather larger number of people. Edit: I'd really like to know why this is getting downvoted.
- ItsDeathball 10y agoI actually know someone who just shuts down and freezes for a few minutes at the mere mention of the word "rape". This person has made their discomfort known to their friends and requested the word be avoided in conversation, which is an easy enough request to comply with out of courtesy. Note that this is a group of people drawn from 4chan and adjacent communities whose primary socialization is voip and online games, all areas known for a "challenging" discussion environment. The line seems to be, in this case, that one can reasonably expect to carve out a "safe space" among family and friends, but not total strangers.
- coddingtonbear 10y agoThat might be true, but there are a variety of cases where we've decided to stop using a word in general in order to avoid causing undue distress; "slave" (i/r/t "master" and "slave") in a computing context is now generally always phrased in another way, for example.
- masterleep 10y agoThat's the kind of absurd oversensitivity that opponents of trigger warnings are against.
- warkdarrior 10y ago> "slave" (i/r/t "master" and "slave") in a computing context is now generally always phrased in another way, for example I need to educate myself. What do people use instead of "slave device" in computing?
- dri_ft 10y ago"Servant". I prefer "slave".
- barsonme 10y agoThe projects I've seen have gone with "leader/follower" https://github.com/django/django/commit/8a95b4fca793eeb8adceffe697b55214509019eb https://github.com/django/django/commit/8a95b4fca793eeb8adce...
- kuschku 10y agoSo, the solution is to literally use Führer instead of Master? That’s a great choice, not only reprinting tons of literature, changing tons of code, but also choosing a Nazi analogy instead! Every word triggers someone, society can’t be expected to adapt to anyone. And I’ll continue to use Master/Slave, and continue to support the Sinter Klaas and Zwarte Piet tradition in the Netherlands.
- 10y ago
- wflynny 10y agoMentioning the word rape is not a discussion of rape.
- apricot 10y agoThe use-mention distinction is a sensitive subject for me, so I would appreciate getting a warning next time you allude to it. Thanks!
- rad88 10y agoYou're making fun of the sensitivities and stress experienced by some people after they are raped. Nice one.
- basseq 10y agoThe article links to another on teaching rape law to criminal-law students.[1] From that article: One teacher I know was recently asked by a student not to use the word “violate” in class—as in “Does this conduct violate the law?”—because the word was triggering. So in some cases, even mentioning the word is included in this issue. [1] http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/trouble-teaching-rape-law http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/trouble-teaching-rap...
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoI would call that an unreasonable request. But that doesn't invalidate the existence of reasonable requests.
- basseq 10y agoI would agree. (And was responding to the parent comment.) It begs two questions, though: 1. What's "reasonable"? 2. Does the meaning of "reasonable" change? (E.g., a criminal-law class vs. a computer science class) To me, this could be redefined as "topic appropriateness".
- 10y ago
- DickingAround 10y ago(Not all that sure myself) Perhaps because it's difficult to simulate the brain of all the other readers and reasonably anticipate offense. Like I know rape happens and describing it in detail might be something that most people are asking for 'trigger warnings' about. But only because it's been talked about. I actually can't simulate the brain of a rape victim and anticipate such things independently.
- FT_intern 10y agoWhen a trigger warning is announced, a triggering concept is mentioned. When a triggering concept is mentioned, people are triggered. Soon, people associate trigger warnings with the triggered symptoms. We need a trigger warning about trigger warnings.