3 ms·
Dumb question time: Aren't 95% of these use cases more easily implemented with a single central source of truth, possibly with distributed read-only replicas?
by wpietri 10y ago
Dumb question time: Aren't 95% of these use cases more easily implemented with a single central source of truth, possibly with distributed read-only replicas?
I think the blockchain innovation is amazing in the context where you have no trusted party. Bitcoin, for example. But almost all the other blockchain uses I see discussed have obvious central parties that people trust. E.g., Nasdaq already knows exactly how to run a very reliable registry at low computational cost and very low latency. [1]
So what cases actually benefit, and which ones are more (mis)applying the latest fashion?
[1] As an example, look at the LMAX architecture, which is orders of magnitude faster and cheaper to run than a distributed blockchain: http://martinfowler.com/articles/lmax.html http://martinfowler.com/articles/lmax.html
- mercer 10y agoIt's probably fashion much of the time. Two friends of mine who work for big conslutancies already asked me what this 'blockchain' thing is because they heard some internal system is going to be using it. I both cases I couldn't really figure out why they'd not do as you suggest.
- seagreen 10y agoDumb question time: Aren't 95% of these use cases more easily implemented with a single central source of truth, possibly with distributed read-only replicas? Absolutely. The tech press loves its fancy new craziness. Good engineering should be exciting enough (if they want to write about something cool they could write about immutable databases like Datomic), but no . . . _blockchain_!
- infinite8s 10y agoThat's the only place where blockchains are genuinely useful - when there isn't a single trusted party to maintain a ledger. In this case everybody participating in transactions (which don't have to be monetary in nature) can be sure that their transaction is both unrevocable and untamperable.
- ilostmykeys 10y agothat is just the story. In reality powerful actors can tip the balancein their favor and even revoke and tamper with old transactions
- ChemicalWarfare 10y agoI agree that yes there's plenty of hype in the blockchain/crypto world and those companies who can afford setting up "blockchain departments" :) very often do so to keep up with the joneses. That said though - when trust is not an issue, the whole POW thing goes away and txs are getting processed very fast with "distributed, read only replicas" getting set up out of the box as soon as the system is up and running. Which it is super easy to get going with some of the "free + we charge for consulting" implementations out there.