5 ms·
> It's time our laws caught up with our technology. Politicians usually update our laws to catch up to technology by banning, restricting, or regulating it. W
by leereeves 10y ago
> It's time our laws caught up with our technology.
Politicians usually update our laws to catch up to technology by banning, restricting, or regulating it.
We'd have to change the power structure to get new laws that "create room to tinker, create, share, and learn on the internet."
- ffggvv 10y agoThere's nothing to revert. How many times in history the people had the power to choice their own future by voting and by campaigning? The problem is not the politicians, they're just an easy scapegoat. You can influence the society by voting with your money. Money is power and every time you give money to someone you give them power. Choosing who you work for, what products you buy (not only with money but also with your privacy) has enormous impact.
- ratsmack 10y agoIn addition, we have the power to remove the entrenched politicians that collude with the corporations that are constantly attacking freedoms. But sadly most people will just vote on name recognition or party line and not actually look at the voting record of the incumbent or do any research on the challenger, so the status quo is hard to overcome.
- ffggvv 10y agoIt's hard but doable and this is important, giving up is childish.
- Practicality 10y ago"Choosing who you work for" is underutilized, I think. Most don't realize that organizations fall apart instantly when they don't have any employees.
- csydas 10y agoI don't think that's necessarily true. The current Copyright laws are extremely over-reaching and also incredibly one sided, as user generated content or personal IP is often used by companies without the actual copyright owner's permission. Basically Copyright currently is a one-way street and it's wildly inconsistent and frequently misused. This doesn't really need a government to "create room to tinker, create, share, and learn on the internet", it just needs the government(s) to fairly apply the law and punish businesses who rampantly abuse it. With US DMCA claims, all are made under the penalty of perjury that the claims are valid and true - how many stories do you know of that are about companies being punished for an overreach of copyright claims or for false claims? The answer is likely none because despite there being debate over the copyright misuse in courts, there are just too many damn instances of copyright misuse to even start with. It's a considerable imbalance in US law because it's truly a case of where a wealthy few are able to protect their rights and use the law as a cudgel to get their way, and often their claims have no basis or are not covered by the copyright law as the companies want to interpret it. However, individuals do not have the resources to adequately challenge these claims, and the fraudulent DMCA claims have effects beyond the takedown.
- sandworm101 10y agoOf course copyright laws are one-sided. That's like calling the law against murder one-sided for being too against murderers. Most all laws are one-sided. The other side is found not in the law, but in rights and privileges protected by things like constitutions and charters. Take "fair use" in copyright. The language in the copyright law is a bit of a fiction. Fair use is just a loose description of an underlying constitutional right, freedom of speech. The language used in copyright law doesn't trump the constitution. So while it is one-sided, that side is balanced by the constitution, which is also rather one-sided. A copyright law that attempted to be two-sided would have to define constitutional rights, something that can/should not be done in a law. Its a fools errand. Instead, you write a one-sided law, with some loose nods to constitutional rights, then leave it to the courts to ensure that you haven't trampled too much. If you haven't, then the law stands. If you've gone too far, the law is quashed and you have to start again. That's our system.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Silhouette 10y agoPoliticians usually update our laws to catch up to technology by banning, restricting, or regulating it. That's not entirely fair. For example, here in the UK, the government did try to reform copyright to some extent by introducing a private copying exception in 2014. This was several years later than it should have been and followed multiple extensive official reviews of IP laws, but at least they got there. The exception was reasonably clear and quite tightly defined. Roughly speaking, it legalised actions like format shifting, making backup copies, and storing content on cloud services, provided they were for the personal, non-commercial use of someone who already had a legitimate permanent copy of that work. By modern political standards it was remarkable for following the original spirit of copyright so clearly: an individual would be free to enjoy a work they had lawfully obtained, including taking advantage of modern technologies, but the basic principle of copyright that the individual could not duplicate the work to share it with others was also maintained. That law was overturned less than a year later following a judicial review, based on technicalities of EU law particularly around compensation for rightsholders. There are a lot of things wrong with this situation, but in any case it is now abundantly clear that the EU authorities are heavily pro-big-copyright and have no qualms about using their influence to block progressive reforms or anything else that might be a threat to big rightsholders. They have repeatedly interfered both with member states' national governments, as in this case among others, but also on the world stage with organisations like the WIPO, from promoting longer copyright terms (again, contrary to overwhelming public opinion in evidence given to the official reviews) to blocking plans to ease restrictions on libraries so they can perform their public function. So yes, unfortunately some politicians seem to have completely lost the plot here, but not all of them. Of course, in the particular case I mentioned, the power structure is about to change between the UK and EU authorities, so hopefully whatever deal gets worked out over Brexit will at least escape that particular unwanted interference.
- rayiner 10y ago> We'd have to change the power structure to get new laws that "create room to tinker, create, share, and learn on the internet." What boggles my mind is that such views are cloaked in the garb of "freedom" but are essentially confiscatory and anti-freedom. They want to take away the freedom of people who create things to share those things on terms of their own choosing. Copyright doesn't need to catch up with technology. The whole point of copyright is to keep people from getting ripped off. The fact that technological advances make it easier to rip people off doesn't create justification for changing the laws.
- tptacek 10y agoYes. This is a problem everywhere in the law. Technology makes it easier to do all sorts of bad things, from theft through mass sexual assault (see this week's news). As a society, we seem to have a hard time staying clear-eyed about what's happening in crimes intermediated by technology.