17 ms·
It’s time EU laws caught up with technology
- cornstalks 10y agoAm I the only one who finds reading text surrounding an animated GIF impossible?
- reitanqild 10y agoI think they should add Norway tobthe dropdown. While technically not a part of EU it is affected by EU laws anyway.
- philipov 10y agoThere's no text. I can highlight it, but it's not even the same color as the background. It looks like every letter has been replaced with a space. Is that copyright protection?
- throwanem 10y agoNo, that's a web font failing to load.
- leereeves 10y ago> It's time our laws caught up with our technology. Politicians usually update our laws to catch up to technology by banning, restricting, or regulating it. We'd have to change the power structure to get new laws that "create room to tinker, create, share, and learn on the internet."
- ffggvv 10y agoThere's nothing to revert. How many times in history the people had the power to choice their own future by voting and by campaigning? The problem is not the politicians, they're just an easy scapegoat. You can influence the society by voting with your money. Money is power and every time you give money to someone you give them power. Choosing who you work for, what products you buy (not only with money but also with your privacy) has enormous impact.
- ratsmack 10y agoIn addition, we have the power to remove the entrenched politicians that collude with the corporations that are constantly attacking freedoms. But sadly most people will just vote on name recognition or party line and not actually look at the voting record of the incumbent or do any research on the challenger, so the status quo is hard to overcome.
- ffggvv 10y agoIt's hard but doable and this is important, giving up is childish.
- Practicality 10y ago"Choosing who you work for" is underutilized, I think. Most don't realize that organizations fall apart instantly when they don't have any employees.
- csydas 10y agoI don't think that's necessarily true. The current Copyright laws are extremely over-reaching and also incredibly one sided, as user generated content or personal IP is often used by companies without the actual copyright owner's permission. Basically Copyright currently is a one-way street and it's wildly inconsistent and frequently misused. This doesn't really need a government to "create room to tinker, create, share, and learn on the internet", it just needs the government(s) to fairly apply the law and punish businesses who rampantly abuse it. With US DMCA claims, all are made under the penalty of perjury that the claims are valid and true - how many stories do you know of that are about companies being punished for an overreach of copyright claims or for false claims? The answer is likely none because despite there being debate over the copyright misuse in courts, there are just too many damn instances of copyright misuse to even start with. It's a considerable imbalance in US law because it's truly a case of where a wealthy few are able to protect their rights and use the law as a cudgel to get their way, and often their claims have no basis or are not covered by the copyright law as the companies want to interpret it. However, individuals do not have the resources to adequately challenge these claims, and the fraudulent DMCA claims have effects beyond the takedown.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- adrianratnapala 10y agoWhile I favour the sentiment, I won't sign the petition. One reason is that I am only a visitor to the EU. But if I was a European, I would still be troubled by the vagueness of the thing. I'm all for putting rhetorical pressure in general directions; but if I am to put my signature on it and send it to a legislator, I want to see some concrete reform proposals. Instead I see a wish-list of outcomes.
- kbart 10y agoAgreed. While to goal is noble, the description sounds like something written by 10th grader. I mean, com'on, are memes and GIFs are really among the most important things?
- Symmetry 10y agoIf you're aim is to convince enough people for political action you really need to dumb down your discussion to a 10th grade level.
- ffggvv 10y agohttps://www.change.org/p/european-parliament-save-the-freedom-of-photography-savefop-europarl-en/u/11358071 https://www.change.org/p/european-parliament-save-the-freedo... The above petition had an effect on European MEPs.
- MollyR 10y agoYet we still have strong pushes from the government on the radical TPP and TTIP. I fear they want to update the law to catch up with technology but not in pro-consumer or pro-citizen way.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoLet's have a talk about copyright, at least, in our societies, instead of having laws and persecutions just pushed on us from the top, in batches? I don't see any democracy in observing how this system works, only sense of entitlement of the minority.
- ffggvv 10y agoYou can do something. Support organizations like Mozilla, EFF and FSF. Donate to them and stop using companies like google (which pushed for DRM on the web), facebook, etc. That make money selling your privacy and use that money to influence standards and laws.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoI don't want to do just "something". It's too little, too late. I want to have what's mine, all of it. Getting my voice heard out loud, my interests acknowledged.
- ffggvv 10y agoThat's called dictature. Everybody wants it, but what we get is compromise (democracy) that tries to make happy the whole society (obviously it fails in some places, that are the rules of the game). Think of it as a free-market in economics, but including privacy, freedom, etc. besides money. Every action I take matters. It just seems that most people prefer a short-cut. What's strange to me is when people like richard stallman stay loyal to their principles and fight for a better society they get criticized by the same people they want to help! TL;DR; it may seem that we all want privacy, freedom, etc. but don't want to fight for it.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoI don't see that I ever get any compromises. What I see is that decision-making is usurped. I don't see many people in society particularly happy. I don't criticize Stallman, doesn't mean it's the only way to go.
- 99182912 10y agoLooks like http://hooli.com/ http://hooli.com/ : "We're more than the sum of our collective accolades." "We're bigger than our innovations."
- sofaofthedamned 10y agoI can't understand why law isn't drafted under a version control system like GIT. It would stop some of the umderhand earmarks and such like
- DarkLinkXXXX 10y agoSorry if that was just an off-hand remark, but how would a GIT workflow account for judicial review?
- adamnemecek 10y agoLaws need to be written in some automatically checked formalism and have some sort of checker.
- ffggvv 10y agoWriting laws is much much much harder than writing code (corner cases, ambiguity, corruption, etc.). Did you ever write a "big" program completely bug-free? I think we should first start by writing correct programs (e.g. invest more in Coq, linters, etc.) then "pass" our wisdom to law writers.
- adamnemecek 10y agoI was talking about something like coq.
- ffggvv 10y agoI know. But if not even professional programmers use Coq day to day (because it's hard to use, the limitations and well known, etc.) why should we base our laws on it? WE should start using it, when we enough gain experience we start using it in law writing. As a matter of fact I'm going to check out Coq right now...
- contravariant 10y agoThat'll just make them consistent, not necessarily right. Laws should definitely be more declarative though. There seems to be a push towards a more imperative style of law making which results in very inflexible legislation.
- jrockway 10y agoThere is not enough information on the site to get me motivated to take any action. It sounds like the EU doesn't have fair use or the freedom of panorama? But is anyone is prison for photographing the Eiffel Tower or making a meme? According to Wikipedia, it looks like it's not the entire EU that's missing a freedom of panorama, but just a few countries: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_panorama https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_panorama There are countries where the government mandates what clothes you wear and whatnot, so perhaps their society does not particularly value personal freedom. Thus it doesn't make much sense to me for a US company to intervene here. Meanwhile, the law seems to be ignored and the cost of an international lawsuit over a picture of a building is prohibitive to nearly everyone, so I'm not too worried.
- barkbro 10y ago> Did you know making a meme technically isn't allowed in many parts of the EU? Does Mozilla also think that a meme is an image macro or am I misunderstanding here?
- WorldMaker 10y ago«It's time laws caught up with technology» For a brief second I saw the sci-fi view of that headline and am now disappointed this isn't about someone's "time laws".
- Dowwie 10y agoIs the United States not listed in the dropdown for this petition?
- ldjb 10y agoIt's not. The page seems to be mostly about the EU, so the list only has EU countries. There is an "Other" option at the bottom of the list, though.
- Asooka 10y agoI signed it, but I'm afraid the only way this will change is for enough of the old guard to die and for a few generations of people raised with the to pass. Basically when the people who are 5 y.o. now become politicians, maybe something will be done about it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mike128 10y agoThe prime example of what you can expect when EU politicians take on technology is the Cookie Law...
- summarite 10y agoEU copyright reform is coming. The Commission (=administration/ministry) proposal is scheduled for 21st of September. It will propose more harmonisation (currently the EU sets just a basic framework, countries choose what/what not to implement in detail, but the terrible is of course that the more ambitious it tries to be the less likely it will go through. The more national systems will be unpredictably affected, the more likely you'll get a few vetos. So the proposal will significantly update, improve and bring more clarity across borders, but necessarily makes compromises and has to leave enough freedom to not ruin existing working systems. At that point the ball is handed over to the European parliament (~750 members elected from the 28 EU member states) and the council, i.e. the heads of state . That means 1-2 years of negotiations and finally political bargaining between the member states. The big issue is that copyright is only partially harmonised, so after that procedure EU member states have to transpose the EU law into national law. Along all these stages vested interests will be lobbying. Politicians will cut deals. The EU (at least the eurocrats) will try their best to get an ambitious result, but we all know that it's in the end about politics. Political parties and leaders will make the final call. There is no abstract EU making decisions about Europe. There are national governments, national parliaments and nationally elected politicians negotiating and cutting deals. If you want a good copyright framework stop sending incredibly vague petitions. Go and pick up the phone and call an MEP. Go and join a party and make an effort to get into the committee that sets the party line. Go and visit your local politicians' open hours and tell them that you expect them to make their party listen - and offer to provide support. Then you'll make change happen. Stop slacktivism. Start informing yourself (by reading the stuff on 21st September) and then take an honest look to try where you can act.