9 ms·
How Startup Options and Ownership Work
- calcsam 10y agoProps to a16z for writing this up. Many of the practical problems that come up with stock options result from having one sophisticated party (the company) and one unsophisticated party (the employee). When the details of their stock options become material, employees are often surprised -- and usually not in a pleasant way. Many engineers become disillusioned with stock options, and eventually the whole startup scene.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hesdeadjim 10y agoHas anyone ever heard of or seen a way that option holders don't get 100% screwed if a company is acquired for less than the sum of the investors' liquidation preferences?
- patmcguire 10y agoNew company pays signing bonuses. That's the only way.
- harlanlewis 10y agoCarveouts are one approach. Some quick googling found this very readable explanation with pros/cons from a reputable source: https://www.dlapiper.com/en/us/insights/publications/2014/04/muddy-employee-incentive-issues/ https://www.dlapiper.com/en/us/insights/publications/2014/04... This article primarily describes carveouts for management retention in a public company, but they can be used in private companies and are not restricted to management. This is the only mechanism I have any familiarity with, I'm also very interested in hearing about others.
- harryh 10y agoNot earning money on options when the business isn't successful isn't getting screwed. That's just life.
- hesdeadjim 10y agoI have to disagree. Investors risk money, employees with options risk their lost income potential and much of their time.
- harryh 10y agoAnd the terms of those risks are determined based on the leverage of the various parties at the time they join the venture. You can start a company and raise money by selling common stock instead of preferred, but in return investors are going to want a much greater share of the company than they otherwise would. That's generally a bad deal for employees. You can say that it's unfair that deals generally work out they way they do, but that's not really any different from saying that it's unfair that your salary is 100k (or whatever) instead of 200k. Welcome to a market economy. Prices are negotiated based on supply and demand.
- st3v3r 10y agoBut the business got bought. That's not being not successful.
- hkmurakami 10y agoRetention packages by the acquirer. Look at the structure and retention deals of acquihires.
- gortok 10y agoThe article goes over stock options; but it doesn't address an alternate form of equity; issuing early employees restricted stock awards (instead of options). From the receiver's point of view, Stock Options are a bad deal 99 times out of 100, let's review the cases in which owners of options get screwed: - Company gets acquired, new terms are put into place. - Company gets acquired, company isn't good fit. - Company gets massive amounts of funding (those Unicorns), and due to the increasing funding at each round, those with options are left with a hefty tax bill and only 90 days to exercise if they leave - If you have stock options and are an employee of a early stage startup, chances are you don't have the liquidity to exercise it. You're also not being paid market value (since you have stock options) If you did have the capital, you could have just invested in the seed round for a much better discount and return. - If a company goes out of business - if A company stays private and doesn't offer an internal market There are only a very few cases where employees with options are taken care of: - Company sells and ensures there are triggers in the options - Company extends exercise period - Company goes public and employees are able to exercise their options with the tax bill that goes along with that and still make money on their shares We have a romanticized view of options because Google, Microsoft, Apple, Twitter, Facebook, and a handful of other companies have hit the bigtime; but that's the huge exception, not the rule, and yet we allow companies to treat options as equal to salary, and they're not. I know companies face reporting requirements if they have more than 50 shareholders; but the earliest employees should be compensated in a way that respects their sacrifice and risk; and options don't do that. At best, options are a placebo.
- manuelflara 10y agoI'm not sure I quite get what you mean by "issuing early employees restricted stock awards". Can you elaborate? Is this like an IOU for restricted stock? Isn't that kind of like what stock options are (except for common stock)? And if you just mean giving actual restricted stock (like to investors), then the main problem is you have to pay those taxes right away (the whole point of options). But maybe you mean something else.
- sokoloff 10y agoIf you are granted restricted stock subject to vesting, in the US you owe taxes only when the stock is both released AND vested, meaning the tax bill comes due in stages as the shares vest, not "right away". If you give restricted shares that vest over time and are only released upon a change in control, you can further defer the tax bill due date (though at the expense of the eventual bill being higher on average).
- calvinbhai 10y agoI am curious to know when is the best time to ask all the questions about the stock options. Before signing the offer letter / getting started or after? Before may be a bad deal for startups, especially the ones that are keeping everything all the equity details under wraps. After is a bad deal for the employee who makes the move, and could be a major bait and switch
- bretthoerner 10y agoAlways before. If they won't tell you the details of your compensation you need to run, not walk.
- patio11 10y agoIf you don't know (minimally) the fully diluted count of shares in the company, your option grant is as specific is saying that your salary will be denominated in dollars and you'll be given more detail about it sometime after joining the company, pinky-swear. A company which won't provide enough information to value an option grant contemporaneous with the written offer is being either abusive or stupid. There exist employment opportunities at companies which are neither abusive nor stupid. Take one of those instead.
- calvinbhai 10y agoThanks! My first two startup jobs, were purely based on the number of options. Fortunately, my current one gave me enough insight about it before, and much more in depth after. There's so much to know about how options work, most people dont realize when moving to a startup job for the first time!
- crzwdjk 10y agoSounds like I was right to pass on the company that promised me "4000 options" and insisted that any details beyond that were strictly confidential and could under no circumstances be disclosed to any non-employees. It seemed especially suspicious in conjunction with the rest of their attempts at hard-sell tactics that just left a bad taste in my mouth.
- halifaxbeard 10y agoI remember asking for a cap table at a startup and in not so few words, was told to fuck off. At that point I realized it didn't matter how many options I had, I was going to get screwed should there be an exit, and made my own.
- HippoViolation 10y agoAt the last 4 startups I joined, when I asked about number of shares, valuation, etc after getting my options agreement, the owners treated the info like the nuclear launch codes, or that I was asking something deeply personal and I should feel bad about thinking about asking. Note: I am poor.
- 20yrs_no_equity 10y agoThey are cheating you, they want to keep you poor. The correct answers are: "We don't give you options, we give you RSUs and they start vesting after 90 days. Here's the cap table" Anything else is screwing you. Unless, course the RSUs are for preferred shares, that's real what it should be, but common seems a reasonable compromise given that investors think a dollar from them is worth more than a dollar from an employee and should be preferred.
- iaw 10y agoI was granted 10,000 shares at a startup I worked for. I asked them "what does a share represent as a portion of the current company?" "We don't divulge that information." I am not going to lock up a huge portion of my expendable compensation in an "investment" that's designed to benefit people besides me on the hopes that the company is one of the few successes to come to market. There are too many horror stories going on right now that the VCs are trying to keep quiet for me to trust most startups.
- ap22213 10y agoI don't get this age of greed that we are in. The board and the VCs are making hundreds of millions (and some of them already have that much), and they are f'n pinching pennies for the first 20-30 employees that worked their ass of to make their company work. Is it really going to hurt that much for like 10-15 people to make a few hundred grand? Geez. It wasn't this way (at least for me) back in the mid-90s. I had been lucky to make some money back then, but I hate that the 20-somethings are getting royally f'd over. BTW, my CEO just gave me a significant bump in my options a few weeks ago. He acted like it was a huge deal. But, with the 'right of repurchase' and all the other BS clauses in my options contract, they're essentially worthless.
- gumby 10y agoThis article mentions '“sticker shock” (or reverse!) [up]on leaving their first startup.' Companies can easily ameliorate this, especially for early employees, by permitting early exercise. The 409a valuation rarely changes between financing events so if you get 5000 $.50 options you can pay $2500, file 83(b), and not have to pay any tax until (unless you sell). If you leave before your vesting period is up the company pays you back what you paid for the unvested amount -- again, not taxable. I always make sure this is in the stock plan. There's some minor subtleties (you want to put a voting agreement into place etc) but they require no heavy lifting at all, and they treat employees as what they should be: valued members of the team. Yes, in later rounds when the share price climbs, this is less useful so but be it. It's annoying that 409a common valuations end up at about 20% of preferred these days; I think it was more fair back when the board could just determine that 10% was reasonable.
- zaroth 10y agoI look at companies like Uber raising billions of dollars (with liquidation preference) and losing billions of dollars in net operating loss each year, and I can only hope for the employee's sake that they have a 409a valuation on the common stock of exactly $1. In reality they are probably handing out options with a strike price valuating the common shares at billions of dollars and those options are likely worse than worthless.
- gumby 10y agoIndeed, as I mentioned, this doesn't help much in later rounds, but then again in later rounds salaries increase as well. But for the early folks (B round or before), why not give them the maximum opportunity?
- caseysoftware 10y agoI was early at Twilio (#25 or so) and early exercised to take advantage of this one. I ended up with a much smaller tax liability than I would have received if I had waited until I left to the tune of thousands of dollars. The keys are: a) being there early enough that the strike price is feasible for the cash you have and b) that the company becomes something more valuable later. If you can do both of those, bravo. But don't count on it.
- gk1 10y agoI highly recommend also reading the book Consider Your Options[0]. It's an easy yet very informative read. [0] https://www.amazon.com/Consider-Your-Options-Equity-Compensation-ebook/dp/B00PSGEK7U/ https://www.amazon.com/Consider-Your-Options-Equity-Compensa...
- fumplethumb 10y agoI'll admit that I probably have an unhealthy disdain for the financial sector, but how do investors manage take on no risk in some of these options? Reading the liquidation preferences section, particularly about double dipping, was a little irritating. How common are these situations?
- iblaine 10y agoI was at a company that had an IPO, it did poorly and it was then that I learned about a Full Ratchet. Those are terms in fine print that employees are never told. Ugh...
- ditonal 10y agoSaid the fox to the hen.
- dang 10y agoPlease don't post generically cynical comments to Hacker News. It degrades the discourse here, even if your underlying assumption is right. If you're aware of an inaccuracy in the article, or an important fact (as opposed to swipe) that is left out, you could add value to the thread by mentioning it.
- idlewords 10y agoJust remember to multiply by zero.
- hkmurakami 10y agoThe problem isn't that this information isn't out there. It is -- but you need to (a) recognize that this information is important, and (b) know how and where to find it. Writing another blog post on a VC blog isn't going to solve the fundamental problem of information awareness and discovery. It's very much like basic personal finance. The hardest part is becoming aware of the need to educate yourself in the first place. The second hardest part is figuring out what you need to learn. Much of this awareness comes from upbringing and is an element of social capital that we often take for granted. Establishing a neutral, nonpartisan online resource under a transparent domain name would be a plausible first step.
- limeyx 10y agoI find getting screwed by the taxman a few times while the VPs and investors make out like bandits motivates the research process too ...
- hkmurakami 10y agoI'd like to think that we can figure out a way to not have the first timers get screwed either.
- nshelly 10y ago> If [an ex-employee] knows (as a result of having been at the company) that the prospects of the business are looking grim or a product launch is significantly delayed, that’s important information a buyer would deserve to know in evaluating whether to buy the stock, and failure to disclose that information creates real legal jeopardy for the seller. This risk exists in a 90-day exercise program as well, but it becomes a lot more acute when you move to 10-year exercise periods. It seems to me there would be a lower risk under the 10-year exercise window scenario. Under the 90-day window, the ex-employee would be forced to exercise or lose all of their equity and thus liable for a large AMT bill. To mitigate this, that ex-employee, with recent inside knowledge of the company's operations, would look to the secondary market to unload some of those shares and ease the tax burden unless their are strict transfer restrictions in place, increasing the divide between cash-rich and cash-poor employees. Under a 10-year exercise plan, the ex-employee would be less likely to exercise (better to wait until the company's outcome is more certain) and wouldn't need the cash to buy the shares and cover those AMT taxes. > ISOs have better tax treatment for employees because the employee does not have to pay taxes at the time of exercise on the difference between the exercise price of the option and the fair market value of the stock This doesn't seem to count AMT taxes which is the big elephant in the room. In California and most high tax states, employees will have to pay AMT taxes on the difference.
- iaw 10y agoIronic article given the innate moral hazard for VC firms on the subject. The interests of funding VCs and startup employees only align in unusual cases.
- leekh 10y agoAs an engineer I ask for more cash so I can use options. I usually get it. What about the non-techinical employee? I generally feel marketing, sales, etc are screwed in startups. How can a someone making < 75k actually use their options?