3 ms·
Not forcing the author to endorse is fine, but in this case - assuming he did paint it - he actually lied. I have sympathy for the particular role that is autho
by icebraining 10y ago
Not forcing the author to endorse is fine, but in this case - assuming he did paint it - he actually lied. I have sympathy for the particular role that is authorship of art, but if it was something else like a car or a house, and the previous seller publicly and falsely claimed there was something wrong with it, losing you a sale, is that not an harm? If the author sells his works in the open market, why should he then have privileges above other sellers?
- robryk 10y agoDo you think that there should be a blanket prohibition against causing harm to other people by making false statements, even if the person making the false statement doesn't gain anything by doing that? This would be a stronger prohibition against libel than (IIUC) is present in US. I also don't see how it could interact with investigative reporting -- a reporter often cannot prove his statements without breaking the confidentiality of his sources.
- icebraining 10y agoIANAL, but I don't think defamation law requires the person to gain anything. And in fact, there is a tort of trade libel/commercial disparagement, which is specifically about harm that comes from making knowingly false claims about products or services.