4 ms·
In the article, Apple spun that as an advantage. > “Our practices tend to reinforce a natural selection bias — those who are interested in working as a team to
by leereeves 10y ago
In the article, Apple spun that as an advantage.
> “Our practices tend to reinforce a natural selection bias — those who are interested in working as a team to deliver a great product versus those whose primary motivation is publishing,” says Federighi.
And I think they may be right. Researchers often aren't the best product creators.
- Chronic9q 10y ago> Researchers often aren't the best product creators. You NEED researchers to build a robust autonomous vehicle or speech recognition system. Hell, you know how many electrical and materials scientists they have working on the iPhone? Physical products actually requires science and research. Designing a responsive landing page does not.
- leereeves 10y agoYou need people who understand the science but whose primary focus is developing the product, not developing new theory. Edison and Ford vs Einstein and Faraday.
- sangnoir 10y ago> “Our practices tend to reinforce a natural selection bias — those who are interested in working as a team to deliver a great product versus those whose primary motivation is publishing,” This is a blatantly false dichotomy: there's nothing about publishing that precludes anyone from "working as a team to deliver a great product" > Researchers often aren't the best product creators. Tell that to Andrew Ng!
- leereeves 10y agoAndrew Ng is a great example. He's made enormous contributions to human knowledge, but doesn't seem to be interested in the hard work of bringing a product to market. He even left Coursera to return to theory.
- sangnoir 10y ago> He's made enormous contributions to human knowledge, but doesn't seem to be interested in the hard work of bringing a product to market. what exactly do you define as "the hard work of bringing a product to market"? To me, his work at Google certainly applies as bringing a product to market - the cat recognition deeplearning AI is a product.
- leereeves 10y agoTo me, recognizing cats isn't a very useful product; that's just a demonstration of the technology. That led to an interesting paper and a lot of potential applications. By "the hard work of bringing a product to market", I meant the process of perfecting the product for actual applications.
- sangnoir 10y ago"recognizing cats" isn't a product at all - the AI behind it is the product, albeit barebones. I've heard folk on HN call such a thing an "MVP". > By "the hard work of bringing a product to market", I meant the process of perfecting the product for actual applications I'll have to disagree - "perfecting the product" is one of many roles required to bring a product to market. Other roles that are just as important are "dreamer/visionary", "practical starter/founder", "scale-up person". Sometimes one person can assume multiple roles, but rarely all roles, all of them are hard work.
- leereeves 10y agoI'm not sure what you mean by "the AI behind it". A particular model, the theory, the hardware, or something else?