4 ms·
> It explicitly talks about how they've accomplished a lot of this without violating their users' privacy. My question are: A. who is violating user's privacy,
by sangnoir 10y ago
> It explicitly talks about how they've accomplished a lot of this without violating their users' privacy.
My question are: A. who is violating user's privacy, B. How is Apple any different[1] from them, besides proclaiming they aren't violating privacy?
1. Some data is collected from the device and sent to a server for processing. Until Apple does something truly radical (like 100% encrypted information that is processing on-device), they are just like every other company that opens up user's data to 'ex-filtration' by third parties.
- throwanem 10y agoWell, to your point B: for a start, I've already paid Apple. They have much less financial incentive to use my data in ways inimical to me than, say, an advertising company would.
- johncolanduoni 10y agoThey're certainly not the only ones in this space, but they've been talking about differential privacy recently[1]. So there are possibilities between "everything is on our server" and "everything is on your device". [1]: http://www.recode.net/2016/6/24/11967188/apple-data-collection-ai-opt-in-differential-privacy http://www.recode.net/2016/6/24/11967188/apple-data-collecti...
- dummyacc111 10y ago> Until Apple does something truly radical (like 100% encrypted information that is processing on-device) This is exactly what Apple does, which should answer question B.
- sangnoir 10y ago> This is exactly what Apple does That is not true, even the puff-piece article admits as much if you read it carefully. This can be proven trivially: is Siri processed locally?
- throwanem 10y agoAnswering only the trivially erroneous objection, and ignoring two other better-founded ones, does not reflect confidence in your stance.
- sangnoir 10y agoIn the footnote to the point gp was replying, I had said > Until Apple does something truly radical (like 100% encrypted information that is processing on-device) You can call it trivial, I will argue otherwise. No one knows outside of Apple how big a percentage cloud-based processing is, but my point remains - Apple's does what everyone else is doing, the only difference is proportion.