2 ms·
Companies that want to remain in ownership control of property after they have sold it can't use GPLv3 licensed software, that is true. They could lease out the
by belorn 10y ago
Companies that want to remain in ownership control of property after they have sold it can't use GPLv3 licensed software, that is true. They could lease out the hardware to achieve the same effect, but for some reason some companies prefer to disguise the lease as a sale.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> They could lease out the hardware to achieve the same effect No, they could not. The GPLv3 requires modification information be provided to the "user" by whom a consumer product is "received", not only the "owner" by whom it is "purchased", so lease vs. sell has no effect on the obligations (at least no effect clear from the text of the license.)
- belorn 10y agoReading the sources to that, it seems the issue is extremly unclear. The big question is if you need additional copyright permission to lease out hardware that include software. For example. A car rental service buys a modern car that has software in it. Does they need additional copyright permission on top of the purchase in order to lease the car out? A taxi driver buys a modern car with the intention to rent out his service with the car. Is additional copyright permission required? A school provides students with access to the school computers. Is that conveying a copy of software? What if its "open door day", where the public is invited? A public library want to have public available computers. Are they conveying copies of software through that? If you looked at WIPO, it explicitly say no. If you looked at Information Society Directive 2001/29/EC, they explicitly say yes, under the condition that the offer is directed to the public. If you looked at the court cases that has interpreted those texts, then they are inconclusive.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Reading the sources to that, it seems the issue is extremly unclear. The big question is if you need additional copyright permission to lease out hardware that include software. If its intended as a "Consumer Product" as defined in the license, you need copyright permission to put the copy of the software in the product; at that point you either except the condition of providing the required information and functionality to the user to whom you will eventually provide the product -- whether by rental or sale -- or you violate the GPLv3 by putting the copy in the device. Once you have accepted that condition, you are bound by it. > For example. A car rental service buys a modern car that has software in it. Does they need additional copyright permission on top of the purchase in order to lease the car out? They don't need "additional copyright permission", but if the initial copyright license accepted when acquiring the car has restrictions that apply to the use of the software in rentals, then they are bound by those restrictions.