3 ms·
Then it's a perverse market where people have ceased to sell objects, and are now just trading financial instruments. I support the right of the author to discl
by pessimizer 10y ago
Then it's a perverse market where people have ceased to sell objects, and are now just trading financial instruments. I support the right of the author to disclaim the authorship of any work at any time, despite any evidence to the contrary. He should be able to choose whether he wants his name used as a vehicle in a financial transaction. Not whether it will be, because if some insurance company or law firm wants to back it as a work by him, it's entirely up to them. He should not be forced to endorse that transaction, and if their valuation relies on that enforcement, their valuation should be dependent on his consent.
The opposite has always been true. I can endorse that painting as an original pessimizer, without caveat. That doesn't imply that I own the image in terms of copyright, any more than R.Mutt endorsing a urinal as his own work, or Jeff Koons claiming various arrangements of vacuum cleaners as his own work gives them any power over any patents covering the design of the object.
- icebraining 10y agoNot forcing the author to endorse is fine, but in this case - assuming he did paint it - he actually lied. I have sympathy for the particular role that is authorship of art, but if it was something else like a car or a house, and the previous seller publicly and falsely claimed there was something wrong with it, losing you a sale, is that not an harm? If the author sells his works in the open market, why should he then have privileges above other sellers?
- robryk 10y agoDo you think that there should be a blanket prohibition against causing harm to other people by making false statements, even if the person making the false statement doesn't gain anything by doing that? This would be a stronger prohibition against libel than (IIUC) is present in US. I also don't see how it could interact with investigative reporting -- a reporter often cannot prove his statements without breaking the confidentiality of his sources.
- icebraining 10y agoIANAL, but I don't think defamation law requires the person to gain anything. And in fact, there is a tort of trade libel/commercial disparagement, which is specifically about harm that comes from making knowingly false claims about products or services.