3 ms·
Besides the lack of the details (it just doesn't make any sense to fire your top salesman), I just find the article's conclusion to be stupid: "capitalism sucks
by chaostheory 19y ago
Besides the lack of the details (it just doesn't make any sense to fire your top salesman), I just find the article's conclusion to be stupid: "capitalism sucks (... the gov should regulate even more)"
Correct me if I'm wrong, but a real life example of the "shoe salesman" is Ross Perot.
"He soon had the highest sales in the company and hence received the highest commission. Then in 1961, IBM executives decided to set limits on how much commission a sales person could receive each year. It did not take even three weeks for Perot to reach his yearly maximum, which caused him great frustration. Additionally, Perot had some new business concepts that he wanted IBM to implement. IBM management was extremely resistant to trying his new ideas. Frustration related to the cap on his commission and the insult of deciding not to implement his business ideas, resulted in Perot leaving IBM in 1962 to start his own company. His company, Electronic Data Systems (EDS), was based on the very ideas that IBM rejected."
Don't get me wrong, capitalism is not perfect; but it does favor creativity, risk taking, and persistence (in the face of adversity).
- wallflower 19y ago"Failures are like skinned knees - painful but superficial." - Ross Perot +1 for the reminder of Perot's infomercials during his 1992 presidential run in which he delivered his sales pitch for president (charts and all)
- falsestprophet 19y agoI am looking for a link, you don't have one do you?
- tjr 19y agoThe charts were awesome.
- rw 19y agoYou misconstrued what the article was claiming... "capitalism sucks (... the gov should regulate even more)" is not the same as "market capitalism is inherently biased towards outcomes that enrich owners of capital at the expense of nonowners who innovate."
- chaostheory 19y agogiven the title of the blog (Charity Focus), their past articles, and the tone of the current one - "We are favoring the interests of one class over another"; I don't feel that I misconstrued the article. I'm actually surprised this got up voted on a site populated mostly by the can-do, think outside of the box so I can move up the food chain crowd... is YC News readership changing? I could be wrong, but I feel another subtle message the article is giving is: "there's no point - just give up. the evil rich men will always outsmart and bully you no matter how hard you try or how clever u are"
- pg 19y agois YC News readership changing? Unfortunately this was in fact mostly voted up by recently arrived users. But I'm not panicking yet; overall the quality of the top stories was good today.
- icky 19y agoYou can still take something positive away from this article if you look at it as a compelling argument to work for yourself. Charityfocus had an interesting story, but they spun it with the kind of sad, defeatist attitude that is antithetical to the hacker news ethos.
- Xichekolas 19y agoI voted it up because I think it's a great reminder why we should want to be owners and not employees. That is the part of the attraction of a startup... it's definitely more financially secure than a job, from which you can get fired. At a startup the worst you can do is fail and have to get a job. John got the shaft in the short term, but Adidas got rid of their top salesman. John will recover and probably excel, while Adidas just guaranteed that their salesman will never try and achieve anything great. The most obvious effect of an action is not the most important, as stated above.
- motoko 19y agoNot true. The idea that a startup is more financially secure than a job is not realistic for most people. At a startup, the worst you can do is lose all your invested capital, go deeply into debt, lose the respect of your peers, burn out, and have such a large gap in your track record of gainful employment that getting a job at the level you would want is very difficult. Further, you _can_ get fired from a startup. Your investors become your owners, and they can fire you. Your cofounders can fire you (or screw you in other ways), too.