4 ms·
A spokesman said: "The flight went really well and the only issue was when it landed." Well, that's kind of every air flight ever. Its sticking the landing tha
by JoeAltmaier 10y ago
A spokesman said: "The flight went really well and the only issue was when it landed."
Well, that's kind of every air flight ever. Its sticking the landing that's the hard part. Its not the fall that kills you; its the sudden stop at the end.
- rz2k 10y agoBlowing up in midair, or spilling some of the passengers so that they land separately from the plane can be a problem, too.
- JulianMorrison 10y agoAlso catching fire while aloft can be an issue, cf the Hindenburg.
- Naritai 10y agoVirtually all buoyancy-based aircraft post-hindenburg use Helium or other non-combustive gases for buoyancy. Airliner uses Helium as well [1]. [1] https://www.hybridairvehicles.com/downloads/download/Airlander%20Student%20Q&A%20Sheet.pdf https://www.hybridairvehicles.com/downloads/download/Airland...
- petertodd 10y ago> other non-combustive gases What options exist other than helium?
- cbhl 10y agoThere isn't really anything else -- if you look at a periodic table, you can see the next inert gas is Neon, but it is heavier than Nitrogen (which makes up most of the atmosphere).
- jameshart 10y agoNitrogen itself is not easy to set alight, though.
- tbihl 10y agoBut it would take an enormous volume of nitrogen to achieve significant positive buoyancy when the nitrogen is enclosed by much of anything. Air's mass is 28.97g/mol, vs. 28g/mol for N2. So, based on my vague recollection of chemistry, that means you only get 1g of container/cargo/engine for every 22.4L of gas enclosed.
- pc86 10y ago> that means you only get 1g of container/cargo/engine for every 22.4L of gas enclosed. For reference, the Hindenburg carried about 200 million liters of gas. A nitrogen craft would need approximately 1.52 million liters to carry a single 150#/68kg human being, not counting the additional gas needed for the craft itself. So if you want to build a Hindenburg-size craft to carry about half a dozen people it might actually be plausible!
- Filligree 10y agoFor the sake of argument, would it be possible to use vacuum? Maybe some kind of spongy structure, with no single points of failure, but lighter than air by way of being mostly nothing?
- TylerE 10y agoNo, because there is no known material (even exotic stuff like nanotubes) that can hold a vacuum AND be lighter than the contained volume equivilant of air.
- jacquesm 10y agoIf your spongy structure is capable of withstanding a half decent vacuum it will likely be much heavier than the volume of that structure filled with air.
- aaron695 10y agoNone. I thought. Methane is also flammable and a vacuum is not a gas and not currently possible. But wiki says Ammonia (Hard to combust)- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lighter_than_air https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lighter_than_air Off planet you obviously have other options. But a complex molecule might work I assume?
- simplicio 10y agoOne of the advantages of large lighter than air craft is that they actually tend to crash in slo-mo, so the "sudden stop" tends to be pretty slow. In the case of the Hindenberg, a lot of the people who died did so because they jumped out too early and fell to their deaths, rather than "ride" the craft down. Even in the worst disaster, the USS Akron, most deaths were due to drowning and hypothermia after the ship went down, rather than impact.
- anexprogrammer 10y agoThe majority of Hindenburg victims burnt to death - "riding the craft down" doesn't seem quite such an attractive option.
- simplicio 10y agoWell, obviously you don't want to hang around very long after its on (or even close to) the ground. IIRC, most of the burning deaths were crew-members in the upper parts of the ship who were either caught in the fire in its first stages or didn't have a way out even after it hit the ground. The lower decks weren't ignited till it hit the ground. But the point is that "impact" wasn't a common cause of death for those who stayed in the ship until it was near the ground. Even when the lifting gas is being vented fairly rapidly, they tend to comedown at survivable speeds.
- ars 10y agoThe ones who burnt to death were trapped with no way out. They didn't have the choice to ride it down. Those were were not trapped either survived or jumped too early.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoIIRC, most of the survivors simply waited near the bottom until landfall, then walked away. I think many of the victims had a choice between jumping or burning, but it definitely seems like a burning envelope is survivable if (your part of) the cabin doesn't catch. Maybe the focus should have been on making the cabin nonflammable. Suspending the cabin with an air gap, and lining it (especially on top) with serious fireproof and heat-resistant lining, might have done the job.
- FabHK 10y agoAs they say: "The aviation industry has a perfect track record - they have never left anybody up there."
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoThat's a legit thing to say about a prototype on its second test flight. You expect some setbacks, and this is an encouragingly minor one.
- notahacker 10y agoA minor setback is having to curtail the flight due to a faulty reading on a pressure gauge or a minor power issue with the engine. A nosedive landing that damages the cabin in perfect flying conditions is about the very worst thing that can happen on an aircraft test programme, even if the flight crew walk away
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoI'm just saying, a crash that would be a disaster in a regular flight can be "not bad, we learned something here" for a new design on its second test flight.