3 ms·
> The provider can bill $5000 for one Advil and there's little that can be done about that.There's no way out of this problem except federal laws that sets the
by chimeracoder 10y ago
> The provider can bill $5000 for one Advil and there's little that can be done about that.There's no way out of this problem except federal laws that sets the prices of services.
First, no insurer pays $5000 for Ibuprofen, the same way no (sane) customer pays sticker price when buying a car. That number is intended as the starting point for negotiation with the insurer, and they all know that.
Secondly, the reason that this negotiation is necessary is, indirectly, because of a federal agency artificially setting the prices of services. Medicare owns 40% of the payer market and also reimburses about 7% less than COGS. That is, not counting for the fact that any practice has overhead and SG&A (labor) that it needs to pay for, Medicare reimburses 7% less than what it costs providers to cover their own direct costs of supplies. Basic accounting tells you that's not sustainable unless you overcharge the rest of your patients.
So, they make up for it by doing this awkward dance where they attempt to overcharge the private insurers by 50x or more, and then the private insures come back and say, "no, how about we only pay you 300% what Medicare reimburses", and then they agree on that.
- merpnderp 10y agoI went to a doctor a while back that had a sign on his window saying he'd like to charge less than $50/visit, but medicare by law said he must charge at least $50. Government should be for the bare minimum of things a market can't provide, and subsidizing insurance plans for the needy and poor would be a lot better than the government, through I'm sure just some twisted set of unintended consequences, setting MINIMUM prices.
- gm-conspiracy 10y agoCorrect me if I am wrong, please. Medicare is actually split into four separate regions, each with its own reimbursement rates.
- CWuestefeld 10y agoIt's a lot more analog than that. There's a baseline schedule, but the rates for any provider are still going to vary due to other variables, in particular the "wage index" which recognizes that their labor expenses are going to be higher in areas with higher prevailing wages.