5 ms·
> It is hugely dependent on China to fund its borrowing. Were it not for the fact that the dollar is the main global currency and that Washington can still borr
by snowwrestler 10y ago
> It is hugely dependent on China to fund its borrowing. Were it not for the fact that the dollar is the main global currency and that Washington can still borrow in the dollars it prints, the country would have gone bankrupt long ago.
Yes, a sovereign nation can print its own currency. This passes for insightful analysis these days?
The author fails to mention (on purpose, I'm sure) that the U.S. is paying very low interest rates for the privilege of borrowing all that money from abroad. The U.S. is not leaning precariously on lenders like China; it is selling something that everyone wants these days: a stable store of value. That's why the dollar is the global reserve currency: because it is the most desired currency. That is not a weakness, that is a strength.
Speaking of China, where does the author think it gets all that money it lends to the U.S.? China is still an economy that is highly dependent on exports driven by foreign IP. We hire Chinese companies to manufacture stuff that we invented, then we buy that stuff, and then China takes that money and buys U.S. Treasuries. Yet somehow in the author's mind it is China that has the upper hand.
The author accuses the Obama administration of using fear of China to sell the TPP, then proceeds to push even dumber China fear-mongering. His argument is essentially that China is just so damn good that we shouldn't bother with the TPP. Does anyone buy that, either on the facts or the logic?
- Taniwha 10y agoWhat makes you think China isn't creating it's own IP? it is after all 1/4 of the worlds people, and contains 1/4 of the world's smart people ... more than are in the US ....
- programmarchy 10y agoPartly because Western culture evolved differently and emphasizes the individual rather than the collective, which is a big driver behind innovation. The immaterial/philosophical elements of culture diffuse much slower than the material/technological which explains why Asian and Orthodox civilizations lag behind in IP production, despite having adopted tech from the agricultural/industrial revolutions.
- mc32 10y agoChinese parents have begun to question Confucian orthodoxy in pedagogy and are demanding less rote learning and more exploration, inquisitiveness and questioning authority (of teachers). However, their main issue will become an aging population --like Japan/Korea and Europe.
- brobinson 10y ago>Chinese parents have begun to question Confucian orthodoxy in pedagogy Do you have a source for this? This is the first I've heard of it.
- mc32 10y agoYou can search for it. Here is one reference but you can find others. http://asia.nikkei.com/magazine/20160526-FACING-UP-TO-HISTORY/Life-Arts/Innovation-creativity-making-inroads-into-China-s-education-system http://asia.nikkei.com/magazine/20160526-FACING-UP-TO-HISTOR...
- brobinson 10y agoThanks!
- snowwrestler 10y agoChina is creating its own IP, but so far, primarily for use inside China. Far more people inside China use U.S. IP, than vice versa. China are trying to transform their economy to be more internally self-sufficient, and are making progress. But the position they hold in the world now, at least economically, was built by manufacturing for export based on foreign IP. I'm not trying to say that the Chinese people are dumber than Americans--they're not. I'm talking about the macro-economics of how we got to where we are today.
- chillwaves 10y ago> That's why the dollar is the global reserve currency: because it is the most desired currency. Why is that? Because we make our allies in the ME sell oil in dollars? And how long will this arrangement last? The idea that the US can export its inflation and keep printing money indefinitely seems foolish to me.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> Because we make our allies in the ME sell oil in dollars? Petrodollarism has little to do with modern dollar hegemony. This is why we are fine building domestic energy sources, e.g. through solar and fracking. Dollars are valued because the American economy is huge. This means lots of Americans spend dollars, demand to be paid in dollars, and want to save and thereby invest in dollars. All this supports a deep and complex financial system. It's network effects backed by our military's de facto role as the global guarantor of freedom of navigation.
- rat87 10y agoI feel this is backwards, the oil is sold in dollars because most stuff international stuff is traded in dollars and because the dollar is the global reserve currency
- perseusprime11 10y agoIs it just me or does anybody else feel like China will be the most important threat for U.S in the next 5-10 years? I am talking w.r.t trade, cyber security, etc.
- Noseshine 10y agoIt's not just you as in there are a lot more paranoid people than just you, if that is really the companionship you seek? I don't mean to demean you, definitely not for what you say - but for the way you say it. There's thoughtful analysis - and then there's your comment. You should really give some context and show your sources, data and reasoning. Personally I don't even see a basis for your thoughts, from a "threatening" perspective the US has a much larger shadow - and I don't want to say this as a value statement. It's just that you will find China military operations abroad are much less numerous than that of the US, independent of what you think about it. How exactly is the US "threatened"? Unless you see anyone who isn't at least two orders of magnitude weaker than yourself as a "threat" automatically, just because "they could". As for cybersecurity, do you think the US is less involved with their spy software placed on foreign systems than the other way around? For trade, what is the threat? China needs trade (exports as share of GDP is much higher than for the US) and still is far behind: http://www.visualcapitalist.com/china-vs-united-states-a-tale-of-two-economies/ http://www.visualcapitalist.com/china-vs-united-states-a-tal... And shouldn't a much larger country, in terms of population, naturally end up with a much larger economy, if things turn out well? Isn't it bad that some people in the current #1 economy feel "threatened" by this? Especially when throughout the last 100 years the US has meddled in foreign affairs much more than China ever did (exclude WWII if you feel uncomfortable about it). . Finally, to answer your question, as a foreigner who lived in the US for a decade, it seems to me the greatest threat to the US is... the US! The optimistic interpretation of more recent headlines would be "Well, they are finally starting to tackle some serious long-standing issues". And then there's this little issue, article link from yesterday's HN: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/08/20/sunday-review/climate-change-hot-future.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/08/20/sunday-review/... A few years ago I would have been reluctant to post it, but with yet another year breaking the records worrying about the impact of climate change on the US seems a lot more justified than worrying about a threat from China. Priorities...
- kaonashi 10y agoSelling treasury bonds doesn't mean the government is 'borrowing' anything; they're a hand-out to savers. It's the difference between interest bearing and non-interest bearing U.S. liabilities (checking vs savings account). The real 'problem' if anything is that trade deficits mean that net government spending has to fill the void in domestic demand lost through the foreign surplus (else the domestic private sector must necessarily go into deficit).