5 ms·
This does not seem particularly bad to me, or maybe it is not bad at all: Russia wishes to unfairly restrict the ability of its citizens to do with their money
by jseliger 10y ago
This does not seem particularly bad to me, or maybe it is not bad at all: Russia wishes to unfairly restrict the ability of its citizens to do with their money what they please. The state itself is more of a gangster than a state in the European / American sense:
Many businesses in the Russian Federation avoid taxes by using offshore jurisdictions, such as Cyprus, for their headquarters. Rich Russians, meanwhile, often funnel their private fortunes offshore, in an effort to hide their assets from the capricious and predatory Russian state.
Going round Russian restrictions seems if anything to be positive: When the rules themselves are wrong one should not feel bad violating them.
The other day in response to an HN comment I dug up this link: http://www.institutionalinvestor.com/article/3427198/banking-and-capital-markets-emerging-markets/bill-browder-puts-putin-on-notice-with-expos-of-corruption.html#/.V60PVI7NATk http://www.institutionalinvestor.com/article/3427198/banking.... If I had a large amount of money in Russia I too would be looking for ways to get it places where it is unlikely to be seized. One does not have to closely follow the case of Khodorkovsky, or for that matter Kasparov's advocacy, to be convinced that Russia is an ill place for long-term investments.
- princeb 10y agothis is probably less to do with avoiding capital restrictions but more money laundering. as far as i know, that is illegal almost everywhere. it doesn't seem to be a big deal to Russia because > When Moscow regulators looked into the mirror trades, they found little to trouble them. but the rest of the world takes a dim view to the kind of crazy activities that seem to happen on a daily basis in Russia. if the internet is to be believed, every single billionaire in there must have made their fortunes from selling nuclear missiles and ISIS oil.
- gozur88 10y ago>Going round Russian restrictions seems if anything to be positive: When the rules themselves are wrong one should not feel bad violating them. You can't very well expect Russia to enforce other countries' tax rules if you aid Russian companies and individuals to take their money beyond the reach of the Russian state. Besides, it's not clear to me the Russians are any worse than the US. If I emmigrate to Switzerland (or wherever) and renounce my US citizenship, the US believes it has the right to take 40% of my assets and tax my Swiss income for the next ten years. That's gangster state BS.
- hiq 10y ago> If I emmigrate to Switzerland (or wherever) and renounce my US citizenship, the US believes it has the right to take 40% of my assets and tax my Swiss income for the next ten years. That's gangster state BS. I was not aware of that, and given how crazy that sounds I looked it up, and it seems to no longer be true.[0] I still find it crazy that US citizens have to pay taxes when they live abroad. [0]: http://www.expatinfodesk.com/expat-guide/relinquishing-citizenship/renunciating-your-us-passport/misconceptions-about-renunciation-of-a-us-passport http://www.expatinfodesk.com/expat-guide/relinquishing-citiz...
- gozur88 10y agoWow. I didn't think they'd ever go back on that.
- rhizome 10y agoWhen the rules themselves are wrong one should not feel bad violating them. Prisons are full of people who think this; just because you don't like a law doesn't mean it's not illegal. Which perspective should take precedence in a functioning society?
- posterboy 10y agoYou don't seem to try to understand the proposition. To feel bad is not at all the same thing as thinking it is illegal. Prisons are an after thought, why would you lead with that? You suppose a society could function without an intricate understanding of the necessity of ones own actions? That would be the definition of irresponsibility.
- rhizome 10y agoI think you may have misread me, otherwise I'm not sure where you're coming from. Isn't it reasonable to conclude that the Russian cash restrictions they mention are laws? The laws they are advocating ignoring in good spirit? The operative term in their sentence is not "feel bad," it's "violate," and prisons are indeed full of people who do not feel bad about violating laws. Do I misunderstand you?
- posterboy 10y agoYou abstractly argue that bad things follow from bad things. Whether that concretely applies in this specific instance or not is only implied. Of course that leaves a lot of room for interpretation. Whether the laws in question are just or whether the culprits in Cyprus will be brought to their punishment in prison is open. That's what I mean, you didn't understand. I gave my only argument, trying to mediate between the two opinions, trying to consolidate them. I hoped that was obvious. I am also torn between these two extremes, and avoided to build a line of arguments.
- rhizome 10y agoMy point was simply whether a population ignoring laws they don't like qualifies as a functioning society. Prison is simply a logical result of ignoring laws. Whether that actually happens, and whether it happens for the reasons GP outlined, indeed remains to be seen.