4 ms·
I recently migrated away from using Linode as secondary when they pushed everyone over to Cloudflare. That Internet-destroying company already has enough power!
by mindslight 10y ago
I recently migrated away from using Linode as secondary when they pushed everyone over to Cloudflare. That Internet-destroying company already has enough power!
- viraptor 10y agoWhy do you think Cloudflare is internet-destroying? Serious question.
- curried_haskell 10y agoThey are growing into a very dangerous position of acting as a gatekeeper to the Internet. Try accessing any major website through Tor.
- angry-hacker 10y agoAnd try having a webserver being constantly attacked by TOR. They are not doing it for fun. If you think they are bad, give them suggestions or new tech how to solve this problem. I thank cloudflare for making my life easier.
- duskwuff 10y agoNot only a gatekeeper, but also a keymaster. (As it were.) Cloudflare's role as a reverse proxy, and as a SSL CA, and as a DNS provider leaves users and webmasters both highly vulnerable to surveillance and/or content tampering by CF. Not saying that they're doing anything malicious, of course. Merely that it'd be very easy for them to do so.
- DanielDent 10y agoSo far Cloudflare appears to be acting in a non-destroying way. They take as content-neutral a stance as they can, and have had to defend lawsuits as a result of that stance. They recognize that the internet only functions and they can only be part of the infrastructure of the internet if they take that stance. The greater concern is this: Companies like Cloudflare should not be necessary. They often are. And, with today's internet architecture, companies like Cloudflare must operate at scale to be a useful service with pricing that people can afford. In a world where we accept the Cloudflare model, we also risk a set of gatekeepers emerging, and that set is "People who can manage terabits/second of inter-network connectivity at PoPs all over the world". It's potentially a troublingly small small group of entities.
- mindslight 10y agoTheir service strongly undermines the end-to-end principle upon which the Internet is based.
- gwright 10y agoIt is the fragility of the TCP/IP infrastructure relative to DDOS attacks that is the problem. I would love to hear about DDOS resilient service architectures that don't require something like Cloudflare.
- DanielDent 10y agoA pre-funding project I am working will achieve DDoS resilience without gatekeepers like Cloudflare, if I am able to bring it to market. It turns out that there's actually a ton of academic research on a number of very promising techniques, in addition to the approaches I'm hoping to develop. I see the issue more as UI/UX/ease of use/cost of adoption. Right now a lot of approaches you could probably defend a Ph.D. on the topic. They need to instead become approaches developers choose because it's the easiest and most cost-effective way to deliver a high-quality service.
- corobo 10y agoHow does it work?
- DanielDent 10y agoThere's a lot of different technologies and ideas that need to come together in an easy to use way. Three of the most important: * Blockchains * Protocol-level anti-DDoS changes (protocols specifically designed to make them less suitable for use in in DoS) * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content_centric_networking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content_centric_networking
- gwright 10y agoI think content centric networking is very interesting, but my original comment was in the context of TCP/IP as it exists today. My gut says that real solutions to DDOS problems are going to have to come from new approaches to networking in general and not just tweaks to TCP/IP or throwing massive amounts of infrastructure at the problem.