6 ms·
Ang Lee Is Embracing a Faster Film Format. Can Theaters Keep Up?
- helthanatos 10y agoI wish everyone would start 120 FPS/4K(downscaled to 4K). That would be great.
- was_boring 10y ago> The film is considered a risk partly because the hyper-reality lent by the cinematography technology [viewing at 3d, 4k and 120fps] could be unsettling to viewers. “Test subjects that have seen some footage have commented that 40 minutes after seeing battle footage, they’re still shaking,” Ben Gervais, a production systems supervisor on the film, told Variety in April. This sounds like pure marketing drivel. Just take a look at video games and the disparity of consoles being (largely) locked around 30 fps and PC that can reach 100+ fps. While a higher framerate can give the appearance of smoother gameplay -- which is disputed beyond a certain threshold -- it never makes it "unsettling" or more realistic.
- TylerE 10y agoVideo game framerate and movie framerate are not at all comparable. Movies have true natural motion blur.
- erichocean 10y ago> Movies have true natural motion blur. In addition, researchers have performed tests and there's something about films being as slow (motion blurry) as they are that contributes to them seeming like fiction. 24fps is the slowest you can run a film with lip sync—any slower and your brain has trouble associating the sound with the imagery. 18fps is the slowest you can run a silent film and still distinguish continuous motion. 30fps and you start to lose the "dreamlike" effect, and at 60 fields per second (television), it's lost completely.
- kazinator 10y agoI've transcoded movies to 18 fps (and lower resolution) to decode on an under-powered smartphone. They were perfectly watchable. I don't remember any "whoa, odd lip sync" moments. I was pleased with and surprised by the results.
- galago 10y agoThe standard-known-framerates predate video--both CRT video and modern displays. Its useful to consider how a traditional mechanical movie projector worked with flashing stopped film vs. a persistent modern display. I would love to hear more from someone who understands modern video formats. Is a 'frame' still a discrete displayed entity? My understanding was that it is not in many cases.
- TrevorJ 10y agoFor the most part, yes, each frame is displayed as a discrete entity. NTSC (standard def TV) was an interlaced format so every other line was updated at a time, which led to a much smoother feel. There are progressive and interlaced flavors of HD, but the progressive (non-interlaced) is the most popular format for dramas, while I believe some live events are broadcast in the 1080i interlaced flavor of HD.
- galago 10y agoIsn't the emission of light from modern displays much more continuous, which is why cats now see what's happening?
- aaron695 10y agoCartoon have been traditionally 12 FPS?
- agumonkey 10y agoLast point made me cringe so hard a few years ago when all TVs were to have their (100|200)Hz mode so every movie now looks like straight out of Pixar. Hyper smooth, hyper real and hyper fake all at the same time.
- macspoofing 10y agoMaybe but Hollywood marketing also knows how to ham it up.
- mrob 10y agoMotion blur is caused by the image of the thing moving on your retina. Humans are very good at tracking steady movement with their eyes ("smooth pursuit"). When you're successfully tracking something this way the image is steady on your retina and there's no motion blur on it, only on the background. Applying motion blur relative to the camera does not look the same because it doesn't react to your eye movement. Synthetic motion blur (baked into the image and visible even with static images) can be used to partly hide low framerate, and with games it would be theoretically possible to use eye tracking to show synthetic motion blur relative to eye movement, but movies have to show the same thing to everybody. The only option for realism is to increase the framerate and rely on real motion blur. 120fps is about the minimum you can get away with for this and still have it look somewhat convincing. Trumbull's Showscan tests were with untrained audiences, they didn't know what to look for. With the right test signals and trained viewers you can see differences in frame rate well into the kilohertz by examining the interaction with eye movement.
- moogleii 10y ago> This sounds like pure marketing drivel. Just take a look at video games and the disparity of consoles being (largely) locked around 30 fps and PC that can reach 100+ fps. While a higher framerate can give the appearance of smoother gameplay -- which is disputed beyond a certain threshold -- it never makes it "unsettling" or more realistic. That's not the best analogy. Video games inherently don't look realistic (currently). 3000 fps of rendered Mickey the Mouse isn't going to make him suddenly look like live-action. He will only ever be a collection of polygons and textures. Live-action movies, however, use reality as a source. Fiddling with FPS can't add more realism to reality, it only can maintain or obscure it. Ironically, that's why HFR makes many films actually look worse IMO. Ever watch a behind the scenes of a film and think, those sets look so obviously fake and those costumes look like bad cosplay? With HFR, all those painted sets and lighting tricks they use become apparent for what they actually are. Whereas before you were watching a film, now you are obviously watching actors on a set. Mission successful (or failure, depending on the perspective), realism achieved, you are now sitting on the set in the director's seat, viewing it as he saw it, instead of watching the film from the audiences' eyes. IMO, until filmmakers can get their sets/costumes to look realistic without post processing and lighting, HFR won't help. But judging from the topic of this film, the material lends itself well to HFR.
- spc476 10y agoHeck, I saw Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan in HD several years ago and man, it looked awful. Gone was the Star Ship Enterprise, Kirk and Spock. Instead, I got a half-baked set and some old actors in obvious costumes. It was painful to watch. Ronin (the next film being shown) didn't fare much better, looking like a TV soap opera.
- some-guy 10y agoIf you think that's bad, watching Wizard of Oz in high definition.
- gambiting 10y agoIn Star Wars: New Hope, you can tell that Vader's costume is just some plastic that was very poorly painted and glued together. Only in HD you can see brush marks on the chest plate, and it pulls you out of the experience.
- kristianp 10y agoAfter the hobbit's special effects were shown up at 48fps, reviewers blamed the high framerate for the unreal effect. Few screens were assigned to the HFR versions of the sequels. Hopefully this movie will make higher framerate movies more popular.
- spc476 10y agoWhat I read about the 48fps Hobbit movie was that the indoor scenes looked very fake, but the outdoor scenes of New Zealand looked fantastic. The same article made some comments about mixing fps in a movie, one approach like the Wizard of Oz (real world B&W, magical world in color). Another approach might be one aspect of the move (like a character) appearing at 48fps while the rest is in 24fps. Lots of room for experimentation in the next few decades.
- WorldMaker 10y agoIt's funny that British television for a long time (up until the HD era in fact) did this on historic, technical accident: indoor/in-studio cameras they used filmed at a much higher fps than outdoor/on-location cameras for cost and technical reasons. I remember noticing it the most in shows like Keeping Up Appearances and Fawlty Towers. Fawlty Towers especially tended to use outdoor shots for more of its slapstick, playing into the lower framerate for comedic effect.
- rootbear 10y agoI think they are making a big mistake tying high frame rate to 3D. The only way to see the Hobbit films in HFR was the 3D versions. But HFR all by itself gives an almost 3D realism to film, something I noticed when I saw Douglas Trumbull' Showscan demo at 60fps in the 1980s. I have friends who would enjoy the HFR clarity but who don't have stereo vision and won't pay extra for uncomfortable glasses that do nothing for them, just to see a film in HFR. It looks like some theaters will have Lee's film in 2D HFR, due to technical limitations, so maybe that will give them some audience feedback on whether HFR can stand alone. I'm also suspicious of the gain in quality going from 60fps to 120fps. I saw a demo of HFR at Siggraph a few years back and the change from 24fps to 48fps was very clear. Going to 60fps was less of an improvement, but for fast action scenes it was noticeable. I'm not sure that 120fps will be worth the extra expense, but I'm interested in seeing it.
- moogleii 10y agoA 120fps master will be useful for 3d at home where the technology relies on rapid alternation between left and right eyes, so the effective fps per eye will be 60. Although, now that I think about it, it might be useful for theaters, too, since they're using two polarized source frames per projected frame. It depends if they're counting the combined, projected frame as one frame or as two source frames to reach their 120 fps claim. Actually, out of curiosity, I read up on how Real 3D does it, and they use alternating, polarized frames out of one projector, which would be 60fps per eye.
- sowbug 10y ago120 is the least common multiple of 24 and 30 (NTSC rounded to nearest integer). Perhaps this is a method to capture enough source material to generate all popular framerates.
- tgpc 10y agoTV in Europe is 50hz Things get sped up, slowed down or played back with jitter. It's not great. Older devices (DVD/BD players) used to change framerate automatically. Newer devices (streaming) seem to default to 60hz with an obscure Settings menu to manually change it. Nearly everyone ends up watching the content in the wrong frame rate :-(
- wazoox 10y agoIn fact, plain HD at 120 fps looks way better IMO than 4K at 30 fps. Motion blur in ultra high resolution is _not_ compelling...
- dimman 10y agoIf they could just focus on producing good movies than focusing on technical details. Just take the Dumb & Dumber movies for instance. IMO, one of the reasons the new movie isn't as good as the old is due to the image quality. I don't need dull colors in FullHD quality, it kind of ruins the feel of the movie...
- bitwize 10y agoSo cold and lifeless! Film should be 24fps, flickery screen, celluloid only. It helps if the celluloid is of such poor quality that it's grainy as all get-out and the light melts it and it snaps halfway through the picture. Now that's REAL cinema.