18 ms·
Even since I was 10 or so I would often come back to school on my own. Then let myself into our apartment. Eat some lunch, do homework, play until my parents ca
by rdtsc 10y ago
Even since I was 10 or so I would often come back to school on my own. Then let myself into our apartment. Eat some lunch, do homework, play until my parents came home in the evening. I was effectively often alone for about 4 or so hours.
I wouldn't let my kid do it here in US. Not because I wouldn't trust them or think it is dangerous. But because I am afraid what neighbors, school, CPS would do.
My co-worker let his kids play in the cul-de-sac for an hour while they watched from the house. An anonymous neighbor reported them to police, and a sequence of embarrassing calls at work ensued, statements to police, follow up visits from police, etc.
And this is not some dangerous part of the city. This is suburbs, as safe as they come.
But apparently you are never safe from neighbors with an agenda.
And the thing is, there is nothing you can say or do, even if you knew this neighbor. "Well I was worried for the children!". Unless they openly confessed it was because you cut the lawn wrong or they don't like the color of your house, there is nothing you can do to them (well maybe turn evil and report them for other irrational fears -- terrorism "but I was worried about this country's safety, swear heard them talk about buying a lot of fertilizer").
The interesting thing is, once those in power act irrationally about something. There will always be people to exploit that element. I heard from my grandparents how neighbors would rat on each other imaginary things during Stalin's times. The results were usually the neighbors family would be taken in the middle the night and sent to Siberia never to be seen again. This is of course, an extreme example but it illustrates, how irrationality can and will be exploited.
- Florin_Andrei 10y ago> My co-worker let his kids play in the cul-de-sac for an hour while they watched from the house. An anonymous neighbor reported them to police, and a sequence of embarrassing calls at work ensued, statements to police, follow up visits from police, etc. And this is not some dangerous part of the city. This is suburbs, as safe as they come. But apparently you are never safe from neighbors with an agenda. The society is sick. It has the moral equivalent of cancer, or some auto-immune disease, eating it from inside.
- sethhochberg 10y agoIronically, the suburbs where it is "as safe as they come" seems to be the kind of place where these overzealous neighbor stories come from most often.
- sotojuan 10y agoI live in a working class NYC neighborhood. Not dangerous, but not completely perfect (and some parts are best avoided). There are kids out alone everywhere! Go up a few blocks to Park Slope, an extremely safe and cleaned up place, and there's no kids in sight.
- ch4s3 10y agoReally? I was just in Park Slope 20 minutes ago and saw a few kids ambling about. Yeah, not as many as you see in Crown Heights, but some. I suspect Park Slope kids are a bit more likely to be overscheduled (like suburban kids) than their peers in surrounding neighborhoods.
- Jtsummers 10y agoIME, suburbs are home to the most paranoid. There's a reason they live there and not in an urban area.
- r00fus 10y ago
- harryh 10y agoBut because I am afraid what neighbors, school, CPS would do. Speaking of "perceived but unreal risk"....
- rdtsc 10y agoOne would think, but seeing what happened to my co-worker, I don't want to go through that.
- harryh 10y agoA couple of very slightly uncomfortable conversations seems like a small price to pay for raising your kids in the manner you deem appropriate.
- softawre 10y agoAnd you are free to raise your kids how you wish.
- fweespeech 10y agohttp://reason.com/blog/2015/06/11/11-year-old-boy-played-in-his-yard-cps-t http://reason.com/blog/2015/06/11/11-year-old-boy-played-in-... > One afternoon this past April, a Florida mom and dad I'll call Cindy and Fred could not get home in time to let their 11-year-old son into the house. The boy didn't have a key, so he played basketball in the yard. He was alone for 90 minutes. A neighbor called the cops, and when the parents arrived—having been delayed by traffic and rain—they were arrested for negligence. > "My older one was the so-called 'victim,'" she said during a phone interview. But since she and her husband were charged with felony neglect, the younger boy had to be removed from the home, too. If you are not liked by your neighbors, it seems like a very real risk.
- harryh 10y agoYou know how if you talk to an overprotective parent about how it's really ok to let their kids wander around outside on their own a little they're always at the ready with a link to a news story about something horrible happening? And you know how that news story is always anecdote and not data? That's pretty much what you just did.
- JonnieCache 10y agoOne hears of this kind of thing happening in the US all the time (obviously it is a big place.) I always wonder what proportion of it is due to genuine misplaced concern for the children, and how much of it is strife of the "they don't like the color of your house" variety. One thinks of Homeowner Associations and the way they place fines and pseudo-legal orders on people, a concept which is utterly anathema to the english. The two cultures have very different ideas of privacy.
- jackcosgrove 10y agoHonestly, I think a lot of this nannying comes from middle aged people who never had children, but maybe who wanted them and could not have them. So there's an element of ignorance about how autonomous children can be, and also jealousy and revenge against those who have what they wanted and can no longer have.
- CodeMage 10y agoNannying is just one aspect of a more pervasive underlying cultural problem: a lot of people here seem to feel entitled to impose their opinions and judgment on others. Not just share them, but actually impose them.
- stinkytaco 10y agoI think this creates an interesting circular problem. Only recently in society have we come to think of children as effectively the parents property. In many other cultures it is expected that other adults will discipline children. We have this problem in our library often when kids who are resettled refugees come in and misbehave. The parents send them to the library with the expectation that they will be disciplined if they misbehave. When the kids see they will not, they misbehave knowing they can get away with it. On the other hand, this protectiveness of our personal standard of parenting means that in order to enforce our standards, we must see the kids and people must defer to the parents for discipline. It almost means that because we don't allow others to impose their judgements on our kids, that they then impose their judgements on the parents.
- jpna66dd 10y agoHence the power of giving cookies, serving beers and inviting your neighbours to a meal/barbecues when you arrive in a new place. It's a lot harder to call the police when they see your children and share your food. And yes, there may be the crazy one that will still call them, but the neighbourhood will agree _he_ is the crazy one.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoFrom the person you responded to: > "Well I was worried for the children!". Unless they openly confessed it was because you cut the lawn wrong or they don't like the color of your house, there is nothing you can do to them My initial thought is that I'd rather have the asshole who hates the way I cut my lawn. I can turn him into a friend. Hell, I can just start cutting my lawn the way he wants. But the person who is convinced that rapists lurk behind every parked car will be incredibly difficult to convert. They might never agree with me that my kid is as safe riding their bike home from school as they are riding in a car with me.
- smileysteve 10y ago> And this is not some dangerous part of the city. This is suburbs, as safe as they come. Pardon potential classist/racial undertones of this, but seems that it could be the beginning of H.G. Wells Eloi and Morlocks. Where the Eloi are fragile and afraid and the Morlocks have freedom of movement. Suburban children get so protected that they actually become a danger to their own progression.
- codyb 10y agoThe interesting thing is that in places like the Brownsville Projects in Brooklyn, which is no where near suburban, I regularly see children playing unattended. Do I think some aspects of the parenting some of those children receive might potentially deserve some examination? Quite possibly. Is it this aspect? Not as much.
- galdosdi 10y agoSee my post above... I feel there is less of a culture of giving a damn what other people are doing and more of a culture of just letting them go about their business in NYC than more suburban areas. Children growing up in many neighborhoods in NYC seem more autonomous. Of course, that's technology too -- they have access to public transit and a dense bikable/walkable environment, while suburban kids are stuck living with outdated misplanned car-centric infrastructure and basically live like prisoners reliant on their parents to ferry them everywhere until they turn 16, or even much later depending on their access to driver's education. Just one example, I'm sure there's suburbs in the US where CPS would be called if someone was biking around with their child in the back of the bike [1] but that's perfectly commonplace and OK in NYC. [1] Here's an example of something just as bad if not worse (and doubly tragic) http://www.huffingtonpost.com/radley-balko/raquel-nelson-jail-for-jaywalking_b_905925.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/radley-balko/raquel-nelson-jai...
- codyb 10y agoMaybe it's also the effect the multitudes. Like that famous story of the woman stabbed to death outside the apartment building and no one calls 9/11 because everyone assumes someone else will do it. Also in Bushwick my neighbors were very vigilant over their children, but they also knew all their neighbors as well. It's nice when the community is actually a community.
- frostirosti 10y agohttp://99percentinvisible.org/episode/lawn-order/ http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/lawn-order/ I think 99pi did a story on this about green lawns. They commented that a green lawn wasn't really a status symbol for yourself, but rather your neighbors. If you let your yard grow unruly, neighbors would come and tend it for you. The idea is that owning a home and land was the american dream, this land was where you could do what you will. The ultimate self determination. However, the reality is, that your neighbors and the HOA just want to tell you how you will manicure your home. So in reality, people who proclaim self determination are enacting a socialist policy.
- balls187 10y ago> However, the reality is, that your neighbors and the HOA just want to tell you how you will manicure your home. Actually, it's that they want to enforce some basic standards to ensure property values aren't diminished because of the negligence of a home owner. There are plenty of neighborhoods in the US that don't have neighborhood Associations nor HOA's.
- pyre 10y agoThere are HOAs where people get fined/punished because a package was left on their doorstep for too long without being picked up. I'm pretty sure that has nothing to do with property value. HOAs can be used to ensure property values don't diminish, but the reality is that they end up being run by busy-bodies that have exacting ideals on what their community should look look. Many of which have little to do with anything other than their own personal preferences.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> There are HOAs where people get fined/punished because a package was left on their doorstep for too long without being picked up. I'm pretty sure that has nothing to do with property value. It does, indirectly. It is perceived that a pattern of packages being left outside attracts thieves to the neighborhood, increasing neighborhood crime rate, decreasing property values. (That's not to say that individual HOA actions in this area are reasonable or proportional, just that there is a nexus with property values.)
- ihaveahadron 10y agoWhat a pussy, you aren't a parent. The government is. I don't care how my comment is perceived, your a pathetic wuss, not a parent. "I wouldn't parent my kids because of what the government thinks." Drooling moronic vagina is what you are.
- galdosdi 10y agoThank you for succinctly explaining why I like living in a large and dense city, where there's a culture of not giving a shit what nearby people are doing and letting each other be somewhat anonymous. Of course that can have its downsides, but being allowed to not be perfectly conformist is a major upside. I don't have kids but if I did, this is exactly the kind of nasty thing that would make me think twice about moving to the suburbs, extra space and yards be damned.
- khedoros 10y agoI'd go the other direction: Either somewhere with fewer people and more space, or taking the time to build community with the people around me, so that they'd be more likely to come to me directly if they perceive a problem than to hand it off to some higher authority to handle. Dense cities give me the creeps.
- lberlin 10y agoSeems like what "CPS would do" is the same logic described in the article itself, but instead of the perceived (but not statistical) risk to the children it's the perceived (but not statistical) risk to the parents of those children. I doubt (don't have real data) that reporting actually happens often at all, but it's so easy to imagine and potentially embarrassing and scary for a parent that they avoid it. So even if you don't buy into the perceived risk to your kids, you buy into the perceived risk to yourself.
- mcherm 10y agoThat's a fairly good argument. I would like to see some actual statistics the frequency of CPS overreacting in an unreasonable fashion. I certainly read many news stories about it, but that is misleading in exactly the same way as the stories we hear about child abductions. I do however have some level of knowledge here. I have spoken with people involved in child protection about questions like this. I have been told that if this person saw a parent allowing their 11-year-old child to cross the street to play on a playground unsupervised that they would have to write it up. They backed this up with citations of specific laws (Maryland - which does, indeed, have absurd laws on this subject). So while statistics might convince me that this is an anomaly, I do have personal experience that suggests the CPS risk is real.
- lberlin 10y agoI meant the risk of being reported to CPS (or being called out in general) rather than the risk of CPS overreacting. Once it gets to them it sounds like they go by the book, but fair point.
- viraptor 10y agoThis is a bit... absurd. What age are you allowed to cross the street unsupervised in the US / Maryland?
- MaysonL 10y agoWhen my kid brother was in 6th grade (11 years old or so), he was a crossing guard, helping younger kids cross streets safely on their way to and from school.
- niccaluim 10y agoWhen I was little we used to play hide-and-seek outside at night. I can't even imagine how many busybodies that would set off nowadays.
- stcredzero 10y agoEven since I was 10 or so I would often come back to school on my own. Then let myself into our apartment. Eat some lunch, do homework, play until my parents came home in the evening. I was effectively often alone for about 4 or so hours. I wouldn't let my kid do it here in US. Not because I wouldn't trust them or think it is dangerous. But because I am afraid what neighbors, school, CPS would do. In grade school, my sister and I and our friend would sometimes spend the entire day in the woods in the dead of winter. The real danger in this country isn't the criminal and the bogeyman. The real danger in this country is the evaporation of real community and a broken pseudo-society of mutual disdain suspicion. Who is your real community? If you had a pet, who could you ask to watch your pet for a week? Who would you ask to watch your kids for an afternoon for no payment? That's your real community. Large numbers of Americans have no real community at all. But apparently you are never safe from neighbors with an agenda. Because they are "neighbors" and you are not in real community with them.
- mc32 10y agoMy anecdote is that poor people, perhaps because of necessity, do rely more on friends, neighbors and community quite a bit. Whether it's minding the kids, picking someone up, borrowing a car, some food, etc. Poor people don't have the luxury of being proud of their "independence" from others.
- stcredzero 10y agoThe problem is that, then their support system is entirely formed from people who don't know how to work the system. To help out with income disparities, we need to get those communities plugged into the parts of society that know how to work the system and advance.
- mc32 10y agoWhat poor people need is education --more specifically an altogether re-education of their children away from how their parents think in order to break the cycle of thinking the way poor people think. I don't think that's palatable to most people --it kind of harkens to reeducation camps, etc. It means diverging their thought process from their parents' way of thinking. This applies to Appalachia, Detroit, Volgograd or Lagos.
- balls187 10y ago> My co-worker let his kids play in the cul-de-sac for an hour while they watched from the house. An anonymous neighbor reported them to police, and a sequence of embarrassing calls at work ensued, statements to police, follow up visits from police, etc. This story doesn't add up. 1 hour playing in front of their house resulted in a thorough investigation conducted by the police? I'm sorry, but I don't buy it.