4 ms·
I feel like this is a case, "No shit, what did you think would happen?" It is a free-to-play game after all. I'd suggest watching the developer of Braid talk a
by djsumdog 10y ago
I feel like this is a case, "No shit, what did you think would happen?" It is a free-to-play game after all.
I'd suggest watching the developer of Braid talk about free-to-play games. He compares them to 90's syndicated TV shows, each one being independent and leaving you with a cliffhanger prior to each commercial break. When HBO started producing long running series that would eventually be released on VHS and DVD, you saw much more long arching story.
Even though Pokemon Go has a lot more going for it than many other free-to-play games, it still works on a model that limits how far you can go without buying stuff. That's how those game companies make money.
I met a Pikpok dev once who said 80% of people delete their games once you can't really advance without buying stuff. A couple spend $80 ~ $200 (more than they would on a traditional title) and a few, the "Whales," would dump $2k upwards into these games. They depended on those players to make the games profitable.
Free-to-play are like quarter-based arcade games .. on your phone. They're a pretty big step backwards in gaming.
- vlunkr 10y agoWhile I mostly agree, I wouldn't say they are entirely a step backwards. Pokemon Go broke the mold and did something that would not really work on any past platform.
- tux1968 10y agoI have never played Pokemon Go, but i'm curious what mold it broke? Ingress was around a long time previously and as far as i've surmised contains essentially all the features of Go plus some more. What it lacked was the compelling and nostalgic branding that Pokemon has. Genuinely curious.
- justinhj 10y agoDespite your opinions hundreds of millions of people are being entertained by free to play games right at this moment. Most of them for free. Braid was a good puzzle game but its reach is tiny in comparison. You can blame it on abusing psychology or marketing dollars, or you can meet and talk with the people that play and enjoy these games every day.
- mahranch 10y agoMany other mobile games haven't had this kind of reaction. Gungho's Puzzle and Dragons is one of the most profitable games of all time; it was the first mobile game to break 1 billion in revenue per year. It was released to the NA market 3 or 4 years ago and has continued to increase its player base month after month. Not only that, but they have unprecedented retention. People are still playing it 3 and 4 years later, you just don't get that with any other mobile game.
- ozmbie 10y agoIt's easy to complain about free to play games and the tactics they use. But it's just a response to the consumer base. Developers tried the paid game model and, other than a small number of niche games, the mobile market just doesn't want to pay for them.
- frik 10y agoThere is a huge game market, with people who really play games and buy their games for their PC, PS4, WiiU etc. Than there is an even bigger audience who own a smartphone/tablet and consider themself casual players. That's the crowd that are catered by Free2Play games. They are often more like casino games or Farmville clones than real games - real games are fun, casual Free2Play are often created to be addictive and are based on grinding (= boring(?)). Some of them find out there a whole other world of real games, many will be in the impression that they are playing real games just because they know no better, and others ... etc. To each audience their own. The negative side was that for years several Triple-A companies went down the Free2Play road while their audience all wanted just the next Trle-A installment. Several franchises like MS Flight Simulator, Age of Empires, Dungeon Keeper were destroyed/burned by dumb decisions. Even whole companies like Crytek, Zynga, etc almost lost everything.