3 ms·
That's not an either-or situation. Health care, food, clothing and shelter are rights and businesses. The rights are positive rights, in other words they mus
by bryanlarsen 10y ago
That's not an either-or situation. Health care, food, clothing and shelter are rights and businesses.
The rights are positive rights, in other words they must be provided, and cost resources to provide. (In contrast to negative rights like freedom of expression, where it costs resources to take the right away from you)
As positive rights (aka obligations), they must be rationed. Welfare et al provides enough money to pay for basic food & shelter but not for caviar and mansions. The article is a very reasonable discussion of why it's harder to ration health care, but the conclusion (and title) doesn't necessarily follow.
- mariodiana 10y agoThis idea of "positive" rights is a dangerous, illiberal notion. Who incurred an obligation to provide healthcare to others? The answer is no one -- not individually or collectively. Healthcare is a service, like any other service performed by human beings in society with one another. If it isn't performed as charity, then it is performed when the parties involved strike a deal. The alternative is that one person's "positive right" is another's positive slavery.