3 ms·
How about economics just influencing policy? Blah blah dismal science and all that, but microeconomics is considerably less hand wavy than macroeconomics and a
by maxerickson 10y ago
How about economics just influencing policy?
Blah blah dismal science and all that, but microeconomics is considerably less hand wavy than macroeconomics and at least in the US there are all sorts of policies that pretend that people don't respond to incentives (never mind if they respond as homo economicus or not).
- fdgdasfadsf 10y agoThe trouble is not that they don't respond. It is that they tend optimise for the incentive rather than for what the incentive is intended to achieve - which are not always the same thing.
- maxerickson 10y agoPart of my meaning was that there are programs created without much attention to the real incentives they create. The programs have abstract goals. If you buy the microeconomics hype, you'd at least examine what sort of incentives you are creating in that context.
- Mikeb85 10y agoMicroeconomics is less hand wavy sure, they have clear cut formulas and solid maths, right? Too bad microeconomics is complete shit, and has far less predictive power than even the most simple macroeconomic models. Microeconomics is what brings us simplistic assumptions about behaviour, and assumes 100% rationality. And then when microeconomics actually attempts to become useful, with things like indifference curves and non-cooperative games, it becomes hand-wavy, because what's more hand-wavy than arbitrary numbers for preferences? Behavioural economics came into being because of how bad microeconomics is.