14 ms·
Overselling A.D.H.D.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hellofunk 10y agoI've always been skeptical of ADHD diagnoses, thinking that it was widely over-diagnosed and a problem in American culture more than anything, and not as commonplace in reality. My googling took me to this article which suggests I am wrong: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1525089/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1525089/
- 6stringmerc 10y agoOne thing that has troubled me as a self-taught "dietician" (re: for fitness, using PEDs effectively, etc) is wondering how much the pronouncement of ADHD might correlate with dietary and lifestyle habit changes over the past couple generations. Basically, I have a hunch regarding general population and dietary overlap. I was a "hyper" kid for a lot of my formative years, and didn't undergo medication for it, but wonder if it'd been even more pronounced with not quite as strict of a household regimen (I was fortunate in this regard - pretty routine home-cooking, balanced diet, occasional sugar treats but not a staple). A 2012 article I just quickly dredged up seems to note there's interest and some control studies possible for recommendations that don't deny the utility of medication, but seem to look for dietary conditions worth evaluation[1]. [1] http://www.oregonholisticcounseling.com/uploads/Kids_Nutrition_Literature_Review.pdf http://www.oregonholisticcounseling.com/uploads/Kids_Nutriti...
- sotojuan 10y agoWhen I was a kid (6-12~) I had to take Ritalin everyday—sometimes during school the teacher had to give it to me (this was in South America were casually asking a teacher to give me meds was ok). When we suddenly moved to the US and I started middle school here I stopped taking it. I've always suspected I was and am still "hyper", because I have trouble focusing and always have to fidget or walk around the office. I just don't get up and run around like I did when I was 7. Even then, without meds, I managed to do pretty great in school and college, as well as my programming career. I've always wondered how much different I would've been had I taken ADHD/"focus" meds.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoSame, I had lots and lots of outdoor activities (unstructured) mostly revolving around riding my bicycle. I'm sure I got lots of energy out that way. I rode to and from elementary school, and would ride after school, then also was an active swimmer. Not sure some of those are everyday options for young people (generally speaking in urban/sprawl suburban/helicopter parenting places). Mostly I think my home discipline helped me 'focus' on doing school and those things, to allow things to get channeled...like picking up guitar seriously at 14. Not going to get good at guitar without focusing and practicing, if I'm honest. So, in a time when I would've been out riding my bike, I was concentrating on the instrument and tiring out my brain daily I think. Well, and the whole "don't do well in school don't get to play guitar" thing hanging over my head (for the best). I kind of think I'd be, well, maybe a less creative person today because I like to let my mind wander. A person recently asked "How do you remember so much erratic & tangential information so fast?" and my only reply was thinking my brain is like a giant orb-spider-web-thingy that can fire stuff all around really fast and bring it back. I like to think my wandering mind made the most of spending time in the local library as a kid too - pick up book, read for a while, get another one, etc.
- Vraxx 10y agoI had a similar experience where my 3rd grade teacher was pretty much solely responsible for getting me medicated. I took Adderall every day from 3rd grade to about Sophomore year of high school, when I convinced my parents that I was capable of managing myself without it. At the time, I detested it because it subdued my extroverted nature, for instance, I would read books at recess instead of playing kickball or talking with friends. After graduating undergrad just fine and landing a software engineering gig, I looked the medication again, and it's a lot more helpful than I remember giving it credit for. My personal hypothesis is that the dose I had as a kid was a bit too strong, but the one insight I gained from taking it after being off of it for so long is that I don't absolutely need it to function, but it sure makes things a hell of a lot easier for me. Obviously, this is just anecdotal, but my experience seemed similar enough to yours that I thought I might share a hypothetical answer to your question.
- raverbashing 10y agoThe issue is how much regular behaviour is being targeted as something that requires medication
- leereeves 10y agoI'm far from an expert on this, but I've always thought that the symptoms (inattention and/or impulsivity and hyperactivity) are only maladaptive in modern culture, where young people are expected to spend long hours sitting quietly at attention in school. Is that a disease, or a flaw in modern culture?
- jackgavigan 10y agoThe article addresses this issues: One clinician quoted in the book more or less admits defeat: “We’ve decided as a society that it’s too expensive to modify the kid’s environment. So we have to modify the kid.”
- leereeves 10y agoThe article briefly mentions the issue then moves on. But is it true that "it’s too expensive to modify the kid’s environment" or simply that established powers make more money by "modifying the kid"?
- Vraxx 10y agoIn a way, those can both be true simultaneously. Just from the assumptions that the "established powers" make more money by modifying the kid implies that even if modifying the kid's environment cost $0, it would "cost" them lost profits of modifying the kid. Costs are relative, and I think the point remains that the kid's parents are relatively powerless to alter the kid's environment significantly enough to solve the adhd problem. Thus, the decision of the cost/benefit analysis of modifying the environment vs modifying the kid falls to the "established powers", also known as, collective society.
- leereeves 10y agoBy "established powers" I meant the people with enough political power to influence educational and medical policy. As long as everyone with significant influence is comfortable with the status quo, there's little pressure to search for other options, even if many parents might prefer another option.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- joshuak 10y agoThese are very old studies. It is now known that ADHD is a genetic disorder. In fact it has unusually high correlation. It is absolutely not caused by environmental factors. Though there is one virus (that I'm aware of) that may cause it. It is not only an issue of attentiveness, but ranter all executive functions. The poor naming of the disorder, and the observability of a persons focus, causes people to over emphasize the inattentiveness symptom. If you are interested in understanding the reality of ADHD I'd suggest watching some of the talks by Dr. Russel Barkely. Here: https://youtu.be/GR1IZJXc6d8 https://youtu.be/GR1IZJXc6d8 For a more complete talk: Here: https://youtu.be/SCAGc-rkIfo https://youtu.be/SCAGc-rkIfo
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- coldcode 10y agoI tried to read the whole article but couldn't sit long enough. Perhaps I need a drug.
- ihaveahadron 10y agoI don't buy that "adhd" exists. With smartphones or whatever reducing kids attention spans every kid has "adhd". The whole concept is so stupid in the first place, I don't even know what else to write. I have a good idea, lets give children amphetamines, brilliant. I know that for the sake any prescribing doctors, I hope that my daughter hasn't been given any pharmaceutical poisons.
- rayiner 10y agoThe point about changing the kid instead of the environment is an important one. If attention deficit is defined as a kid having trouble coping with the standard 7-hour school day (more like 9-10 including homework) where he is expected to sit still and work on boring and non-essential worksheets, then the condition isn't over diagnosed at all. And if we're not willing to change that environment--and I don't think we are--then we should medicate the kids so at least the experience is tolerable and they can have some success with it. Given that artificial stimulation to cope with the modern workforce is universal (espresso shots, liters of coffee, energy drinks), they might as well start getting used to it.
- forgotpwtomain 10y ago> And if we're not willing to change that environment--and I don't think we are--then we should medicate the kids so at least the experience is tolerable and they can have some success with it And as a result traditional response has been amphetamine-salts for children as you say. But I completely disagree that this is something we should do. For one I think we don't have good enough science to know how potentially dangerous or helpful ADHD drugs really are. Is it going to help them adjust later, or will it be harder? Are they going to be dependent on amphetamines their whole life? Evaluation of drugs which are primarily targeted at emotional and behavioral problems is difficult enough in neutral conditions, since it is hard to control/evaluate/quantify results. Yet the conditions we are dealing with are totally not-neutral. Basically big pharmaceutical companies fund lots of research - if the research doesn't support their product they can shelve it and fund some other studies until they have research which does. It's an awful field with too much money and lots of dishonest science. Secondly, using medications to treat ADHD (because that makes money for their producers) is as you pointed out making us avoid the cultural / environmental problems which cause this issue. But I disagree that this is inherently from the 7-hour school day as you point out. Kids went to school for 7-hours 50 years ago as well, but ADHD diagnosis and medication use has been constantly increasing. [0] A large factor to this is the increasing amount of stimulation that kids today are actively exposed to that they weren't in the past (I can't remember references of the top of my head, I'll try and find one though). Basically if you grow-up with 4-6 hours of TV or video games per day, yeah it's hard to sit down and read a book. Obvious right? And your recommendation is really to give amphetamines to 7-year olds? Rather than limit consumption of mediums that are inappropriately over-stimulating for large durations? [0] http://images.slideplayer.com/18/5690061/slides/slide_2.jpg http://images.slideplayer.com/18/5690061/slides/slide_2.jpg
- PragmaticPulp 10y agoNote that the author directly acknowledges the existence of ADHD in the book. His concerns are directed toward the pharmaceutical industry's push to increase sales of stimulant medications. From the article: Schwarz has no doubt that A.D.H.D. is a valid clinical entity that causes real suffering and deserves real treatment, as he makes clear in the first two sentences of the book: “Attention deficit hyperactivity is real. Don’t let anyone tell you otherwise.” But he believes that those who are disabled by the condition deserve a wider range of treatment options than an endless litany of stimulants with chirpy names like Vyvanse and Concerta. In my experience, I think most patients, parents, and clinicians would readily agree that ADHD is over-diagnosed and over-medicated. It's surprisingly common on internet forums and threads like these to find people insisting that ADHD is over-diagnosed in others, but that their own case of ADHD is genuine. Or parents who believe that stimulants are over-prescribed in general, but that their own child's case is an exception. Clinicians feel this pain perhaps most directly. Few patients or parents arrive at the clinician's office seeking a diagnosis for their attentional symptoms without already having self-diagnosed themselves or their children as having ADHD using online tests, often from the pharmaceutical companies. Even fewer patients are open to alternative suggestions for addressing their problems, having already decided that they want a prescription for stimulants, and they want the exact stimulant formulation they saw online or heard about from their friend. It's an uphill battle for the clinician to argue against this, as denying patients the medication they've decided they need for themselves is a recipe for angry complaints that increasingly-busy clinicians don't really have time for. The pharmaceutical industry knows full well that their target market tends to self-diagnose and decide what they want before ever stepping foot in to the doctor's office, and their marketing material is geared to maximize that effect. The ADHD information on the Vyvanse website, for example, reads more like a horoscope than a list of symptoms. From the Vyvanse website: Kids may make careless mistakes in schoolwork, have difficulty remaining focused in class, and seem not to listen when spoken to directly. Teens may avoid homework and may be easily distracted by many things, including unrelated thoughts. Adults may forget to keep appointments, pay bills, or return calls and avoid completing forms or reviewing paperwork. Unfortunately I don't know what the solution might look like, as the blame is shared by patients, parents, clinicians, insurers, and pharmaceutical companies alike. The fact that we allow companies to market diagnoses and medication directly to people represents a massive conflict of interest, as this incentivizes them to appeal to the widest audience as possible. Better education of patients and parents would go a long way toward dispelling some of the myths around ADHD. It's entirely normal and expected for teens and children to not want to do their homework and to be distracted at times, just as it's unrealistic to expect adults to never miss an appointment, bill, or phone call. Kids naturally want to play video games or browse YouTube instead of doing their homework. At some point these issues reach the level of ADHD, but that level is much higher than most of the population would like to believe when it comes to themselves or their children.
- ap22213 10y ago“We’ve decided as a society that it’s too expensive to modify the kid’s environment. So we have to modify the kid.” Unfortunately, we can't modify much of the environment without giving up a lot of what we have. And, that's the trade-off of rapid progress - evolution is no where near as fast. We probably should change the schools for many reasons. But, changing them so that they're somehow more natural is probably an impossible goal, at least until we invent more technology. Humans have had to deal environmental diseases at every major milestone: choosing residential over nomadic; domesticating livestock; using grain as a primary food source; choosing urban over rural; inventing industry, the corporation, and desk jobs; inventing dangerous chemicals for products and fuel; inventing processed foods; inventing weapons of mass destruction. The diseases that have come with these have been trade-offs that we have accepted. As a sufferer of several psychological diseases, I suspect that mine are all environmental in some way - stress, close-quarters living, giant social hierarchies, living by the calendar and clock, being exposed to all sorts of toxins, etc. My nature tells me that I should be out running through the forest and chasing game - not sitting at a desk and typing on a keyboard. But, am I going to live alone in the forest? Hell no; I enjoy what I have. I take several psychological drugs, and they have awful side-effects. And, I self-medicate in other ways. But, those are the trade-offs that I've chosen to be able to do all the things that my mind conjures.
- reactJS 10y agoI started taking these stimulants like vyvanse in college about five years ago. Although I can exhibit symptoms from time to time, I do not think at all that it is medically necessary for me. After trying them once, it made things a lot easier, and besides a few episodes, the good effects have been able to balance out the bad. I do get very worried occasionally though that I will have to suffer long term consequences. I am very much dependent though now this fear has not yet been strong enough to get me to stop.
- chris_va 10y agoI get really skeptical whenever someone uses the term "Big Pharma". 99% of the time the person using it is selling something (hey, look, a $28 book). How dare a pharmaceutical company sell a product? How dare doctors decide to prescribe medicine? While that was slightly melodramatic, here is a quote from the article: Schwarz has no doubt that A.D.H.D. is a valid clinical entity that causes real suffering and deserves real treatment, as he makes clear in the first two sentences of the book: “Attention deficit hyperactivity is real. Don’t let anyone tell you otherwise.” But he believes that those who are disabled by the condition deserve a wider range of treatment options than an endless litany of stimulants with chirpy names like Vyvanse and Concerta. ... Great, so it all boils down to the pharma companies not creating enough drugs for ADHD? But it's their fault that there are too many drugs? I am not particularly impressed, and to me it feels like the author is just manufacturing conflict for the sake of selling a book.
- DanBC 10y ago> Great, so it all boils down to the pharma companies not creating enough drugs for ADHD? No, some people will benefit from parenting classes or therapy as well as meds. The author is saying that meds alone are not enough for some people.
- throwaway729 10y ago>> "...But he believes that those who are disabled by the condition deserve a wider range of treatment options" > so it all boils down to the pharma companies not creating enough drugs for ADHD? Conflating "treatment options" with "drugs" is kind of the central thesis of Schwarz's critique... > to me it feels like the author is just manufacturing conflict for the sake of selling a book. If you've ever worked in or around a private practice doctor's office, you're aware of the pressure to proscribe. Many, many doctors are high-quality professionals who make decisions solely in the best interest of the patient. Many other doctors are only interested in pushing as many people through the office as possible, spending less than a minute per customer and quickly writing a script for whatever the pharma rep is selling. A little bit for the perks, but mostly because it's a way to push as many people through the office as possible. The pharma rep provides fantastic marketing and "educational" material that does the doctor's job for him, allowing him to push more people through than if he had to sit down and discuss an array of treatment options with the patient. Regardless of the author's motivations, his critique isn't without merit (and certainly isn't specific to ADHD).
- reactJS 10y agoI challenge someone to provide evidence enough to scare me into stopping. Go ahead, save my life
- dang 10y agoPlease don't do this here. Your other comment was fine, and can and should speak for itself. We detached this one from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12345023 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12345023 and marked it off-topic.
- reactJS 10y agoSorry, mean't to be a joke. Way past the point of being saved anyway
- krinchan 10y agoMeh. So long as you don't graduate to a full blown cocaine or meth addiction, you should be fine for a long while. You'll have cardiovascular issues further down the line if you don't work out and/or smoke. I mean, all stimulants to some degree or another are bad for your heart and blood pressure. Perhaps look into that other brain pill all the kids are taking now, Modafinil. I've been meaning to try some at some point. Apparently it gives you all the bonuses of Normal Person on Ritalin but none of the jitters.
- reactJS 10y agoThis is the opposite of what I needed to hear, but exactly what I wanted
- phkahler 10y ago>> I challenge someone to provide evidence enough to scare me into stopping. Go ahead, save my life From TFA: Schwarz traces the Icarus-like trajectory of Richard Fee, an aspiring medical student who fakes the symptoms of A.D.H.D. to get access to drugs that will help him cope with academic pressure. When he eventually descends into amphetamine psychosis, his father tells his doctor that if he doesn’t stop furnishing his son with Adderall, he’ll die. Two weeks after burning through his supply, Fee hanged himself in a closet. Are you sure your supply will never be disrupted?
- GirlsCanCode 10y agoI'm an adult who takes Adderall. Just asked the doctor for a prescription and got it. I can work without it, but I work better with it. If I'm in a 'flow' it keeps me there. The drug is safe and effective when used properly. Why limit it?
- flogic 10y agoI'm generally not fond of this sort of article and this one is no exception. They present a case that drug companies like selling drugs but we knew that. What they don't do is present a good case that ADHD is actually overdiagnosed. The world in general is not very good at accepting psychological conditions. ADHD is commonly regarded as "youth", "laziness", or "lacking discipline". Watching a loved one fight to focus continually is just heartbreaking. We still have quite a number of cases where people are stuck fumbling without help.
- jordanlev 10y agoThis is a book review, not an article per se. I'd assume the book goes into much more detail. Also, from the review: > Schwarz has no doubt that A.D.H.D. is a valid clinical entity that causes real suffering and deserves real treatment, as he makes clear in the first two sentences of the book: “Attention deficit hyperactivity is real. Don’t let anyone tell you otherwise.” But he believes that those who are disabled by the condition deserve a wider range of treatment options than an endless litany of stimulants with chirpy names like Vyvanse and Concerta.
- sevenless 10y agoBut what does "real" mean, exactly? That it's a recognizable pattern of behavior? That doesn't necessarily mean it should be treated as a disease.
- scottmf 10y agoWhy not? People are suffering and we have safe medications which improve their lives. Not treating ADHD is far more dangerous. People with unmedicated ADHD are more likely to do poorly in school, abuse drugs/alcohol, suffer from depression etc.
- sevenless 10y agoI'm sure some people's school grades benefit from taking amphetamine-like drugs, but that still doesn't imply they are suffering from a disease in the first place. It's far from clear why having the symptoms of ADHD should be considered a disease, in any objective sense. If kids are suffering because school is boring or society is restrictive, that doesn't mean there's something wrong with them.
- dforrestwilson1 10y agoIt's no coincidence that young males are more likely to exhibit ADHD symptoms. My school attempted to convince my parents several times that I needed medication because I disrupted the class. While I am not proud of my prior misbehavior, I'm thankful that my parents had enough medical knowledge to refuse to put me on pills.
- beelzebubble 10y agoThere are many who genuinely suffer from ADHD and their parents did not allow them medication due to ignorance. And they have the exact opposite story to tell.
- goda90 10y agoIt's a tale of ignorance all around. Overzealous diagnosis leads to problems which leads to mistrust. People who get misdiagnosed suffer, and those who are properly diagnosed, but assumed to be misdiagnosed also suffer.
- AStellersSeaCow 10y agoExactly. My parents shied away from looking into ADD/ADHD treatment for me because of the blowback about overdiagnosing, instead ascribing to the more regressive and I daresay petulant "kids will be kids" outlook of my behavior and educational issues growing up. I didn't last one semester at college, and my life was a mess for close to my first ten years of adulthood, at which point I finally overcame the "this is just the way you are" mindset and sought treatment. Started on medication and my life turned around overnight. So while it's certainly important to keep an eye on pharma, it's also wildly irresponsible, unfair, and unscientific to claim "it's mostly made-up because I don't like the implication that a lot of people have a mental problem". Particularly disgusting is including the anecdote about the person who faked ADHD symptoms to get stimulants, then killed himself when his supply was cut off: prescription drug abuse/addiction is a serious issue, but one that is completely separate from the proper diagnosis of a medical condition. There's rightfully been a backlash against the "better living through chemistry" postwar mindset that every problem should be medicated. But I think in this case it's ultimately less about medicating and more about fear of and unwillingness to address mental issues.
- krinchan 10y agoI've observed this whole drama unfold first hand. Having been born in the early 80's, I grew up on Ritalin and most of my classmates did too. I actually do have ADHD, but I'm unmedicated for well over 15 years now. This is completely by choice; every time a new doctor sees my medical history they basically ask in a rather pushy manner, "Ya want some pills for this?" I didn't grow out of ADHD, but I have had to learn a lot of coping mechanisms. I can't work with silence, I always have to have music on. If I don't, I start wandering around the internet and getting nothing done. Pair programming is basically God's Gift to ADHD. All of my team knows that they are encouraged, and appreciated if I'm driving and they're like, "Whoa you are WAAAAAY off on some tangent here. Our card says to do X, let's do X." To-Do lists and journaling are a way of life. Note taking during meetings is simply a must. If I don't, my short term memory gets really slippery and I start interrupting people with questions and thoughts lest I forget them in the next 20 seconds. But the point is, while I have all sorts of weird hoops to jump through, they really aren't things that normal, non-ADHD people don't do. I just rely on and need them far more than non-ADHD people. Yet every doctor wants to give me a prescription for my ADHD. This is extremely ironic give a later point in this comment. Meanwhile, while medication isn't an answer all the time, sometimes it is really the only option. Taking the medication is hell. I know a group of people I grew up with who can't get through a workday without prescription stimulants. Then, they have to try to handle kids sporting events, social events, etc. on the weekends without it to try to keep their tolerances down. Still, those tolerances don't quite reset fully. Almost everyone in that group has to take regular PTO every 6 months and go off them for two weeks. They can't work. They can't clean the house. They can't care for their kids. It's pure misery. Sure, they may run off to a resort, but they're mostly just doing that so they can drink and sleep their way through withdrawals while their other half handles the kids. In same group, there are a few that actively struggle to take their medication as prescribed as opposed to eating a 30 day supply in 10 days. We're talking getting the day's doses each morning from a significant other with the rest kept in a lock box that only said SO has the key. Also, it's insanely embarrassing and stigmatized to get your medication filled when you're an adult. Pharmacies will be out of Ritalin when you show up to fill your prescription in the morning. "I don't know when we'll have more in, sorry." Then, a few days later you'll hear that same pharmacy filled your friend's daughter's prescription in 20 minutes a few hours after you left. So on one hand, you have Big Pharma pushing the diagnosis and medication on children who are still neurologically developing. On the other hand, you have an informal cadre of pharmacists that think it's okay for kids to take this, but if an adult is taking it they're some meth'ed up tweaker. So kids who don't and probably shouldn't take these drugs are flooded with them. The adults that need it just to hold down a job and make rent can't get it. The entire ADHD situation is just one massive, never ending mess. I'm so glad I'm on the lighter end of it and can side step the medication entirely.
- ajones05 10y agoIn the U.S. we force children to sit still through hours of classes, wonder why they get distracted, and then medicate them. In other countries kids get more breaks to expend energy and are then more attentive - e.g., http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2014/06/how-finland-keeps-kids-focused/373544/ http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2014/06/how-fin... "In every one of the experiments, students were more attentive after a break than before a break. They also found that the children were less attentive when the timing of the break was delayed—or in other words, when the lesson dragged on."
- sseal 10y agoI agree. How do you expect children to sit in a class room for 7 hours a day?
- scottmf 10y agoWhy single out ADHD? What about over-diagnosis of depression and other mental illness? This kind of nonsense is fodder for those who believe ADHD and other disorders aren't a serious problem. What's the solution to overprescription which doesn't deny safe, life-changing drugs to those who need it? "People deserve a wide range of treatment options"? Insightful. There is a wide range of options, but stimulant medications are significantly more effective than anything else. If faking symptoms for drugs is the concern here... why? How much effort should we really put into weeding out fakers at the expense of those in need? Stimulant medications used properly are incredibly safe and improve attention/focus in healthy people. Maybe it's time certain people stop forcing their outdated moral ideals on the rest of us.
- riprowan 10y agoI was diagnosed ADHD when I was 7 and the doctors put me on Ritalin. This was the early 1970s when very little was known about how to prescribe the drug to children. The doctors put me on a dose of 20mg 3X per day. It almost killed me. I remember having an overdose in 2nd grade (at least now I know that it was a Ritalin overdose). 60mgs of Ritalin is high even for an adult much less a 7yo. The teacher was required to distribute the pill to me mid-day. She would stop class, and say, "Rip, come up front and take your 'hyper pills.'" Thusly singled out, I would sheepishly trudge up to the front of the classroom and get my medication to the snickers off all my classmates. It was scarring. Also my nighttime dose was usually enough to keep me awake all night. At that age I had night terrors which were exacerbated by the drug and lack of sleep. I'd return to school wiped out like a zombie. I'm sure I did present with all the classic symptoms of ADHD: inattentiveness, restlessness, talkativeness, inability to complete tasks, constant need for interaction, etc.. I am still this way to a degree. I'm pretty sure that nobody really bothered to try to understand what my home life was like. I was the only child of two raging alcoholics. They would get drunk and fight for hours 3-5X per week until all hours of the night. I was a terribly depressed, anxious child. And since the underlying cause of the anxiety (my horrible home) was never addressed, I've no doubt that to this day I carry around a form of PTSD from my childhood. I'm sure there are many people from great homes with no external factors driving their ADHD. However, I know in my case, I suffered greatly from an untreated trauma, and was simply medicated so that I wouldn't disrupt my peers at school. It also didn't help that I have ~140IQ and found school absolutely tortuously boring until I finally got into an honors program in my high school. My peers were still struggling to read books aloud while I was knee-deep in LoTR. How can we blame young children because they can't sit still and quiet day in and day out while absolutely nothing interesting ever happens? How is it that after years of being unable to complete homework assignments, nobody ever really started questioning what was happening at home? Looking back, it is absolutely shameful how this was handled. Treating behavioral problems in small children must begin with understanding and treating the possible behavioral problems of the adults first, otherwise it's just compounding the damage. Interestingly when I got old enough to start using marijuana I quit the Ritalin. I found myself quite able to study on weed and my grades in college positively reflected my increasing marijuana consumption. My first year in college I used none, thinking that this would be best for my schooling, and I performed poorly. Thus discouraged, I figured that if school was going to go badly I might as well get high. My grades went from Cs and Bs to Bs and As and onto the Deans Honor Roll. I took my senior final in probabilistic modelling thoroughly blazed and broke the curve for the whole class. Also interestingly, I cannot take other typical anti-anxiety meds. Anything in the benzo class, for example, causes terrifying complete amnesia even at low doses. All anecdotal, I know, but I also know a lot of other people with more or less my same story.
- sn41 10y agoThere are books like "The Shallows" which make a case that the internet is shortening our attention spans. Could this lead to someone developing ADHD?
- atemerev 10y agoNo. Modern understanding is that it is hereditary and only can be amplified by environment, but it is either you have it, or you don't.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mcculley 10y agoThe article briefly mentions "hyperkinetic infants" and doesn't address the well known effects on neonates by the consumption of caffeine by pregnant women (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3420441?dopt=abstractplus http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3420441?dopt=abstractplus) and the way advertisers market sugar and caffeine to children.
- Floegipoky 10y agoWe don't have to give up modern education to meet the basic biological needs of children any more than we need to give up our jobs to be healthy adults. Initiatives like http://standupkids.org/ http://standupkids.org/ demonstrate pretty clearly that there are plenty of obvious, easy ways that we can address these needs. The obvious answer as to why we haven't tried them yet is money. But that seems like a lazy explanation, because American schools are some of the best-funded in the world. I think it's really a reflection on how we in the West view child-rearing in general. I read a really interesting interview a few months back discussing Freud, where the psychologist being interviewed was basically saying that Freud's model was implicitly based on the shame he felt about his childhood self, how the relationship between therapist and subject is derived from the relationship between parent and child, and that every time Freud was speaking to a subject sitting in a chair in front of him, he was talking to his 8-year-old self. Ironically we tend to see the natural reaction of a child as somehow wrong. If a child can't sit in a chair for 3 hours, the child is wrong, rather than the idea of sitting in a chair for 3 hours. So as the article points out, the conversation begins as "How can we modify the children to fit the environments we've built for them" rather than "How can we modify the environments we've built for children to fit their needs?"
- anexprogrammer 10y agoAs someone in my 5th decade, with lifelong ADHD (though given my age it did not exist in my youth, and was only diagnosed relatively recently), I'm wary of backing away from treatments until we actually do have real viable alternatives. It took far too long to get ADHD widely recognised, and even now it's often more likely to be received with humour than real recognition. Much more research, especially on other possible treatments and therapies, is needed before we turn too zealously against the only treatment actually shown to work. We have a long history of over diagnosing and overdoing pretty much everything. I've only ever managed it with limited success. There's little doubt that the drugs can work. Despite some evidence of over-diagnosis and over-prescription there are many people who have had their prospects transformed as a result. I suggest the ADHD label is being significantly over applied because real awareness, even in the medical profession, is still abysmal. Doctors don't have time to look at home circumstances, or parents and other factors that might affect behaviour. Awareness coming from some TV comedy skit however is high. I don't actually care that we don't yet have full understanding of how the drugs work, or that OMG they're amphetamines. I often wonder how things may have turned out differently for me had I encountered more GP awareness and less ridicule, or even earlier self-awareness or teen diagnosis and treatment. If we are too successful "exposing big pharma" and overdiagnosis in the minds of GPs and the public, lives will be ruined once again. Let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater here rather than seek wider understanding.
- panglott 10y agoThe thing is, diagnosis rates in the U.S. are something like 3-4 times as high as in most countries in Europe, which are themselves 3-4 times as high as a country like France, which is averse to ADHD diagnoses. The main treatment for ADHD is lifelong maintenance of powerful amphetamines, when we have no idea what the long-term consequences of that would be, nor what proportion of children would normally develop out of the ADHD spectrum with time. Overdiagnosis at that rate means that millions of children are being given amphetamines, when they shouldn't be!
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoI looked, and it seems to be about double (though figures disagree). And I wonder if this isn't simply a difference in educational systems and expectations of children. I'm in Norway, and children play quite a bit, even in school. They take frequent breaks, have outdoor recess (in nearly all weather), and have no homework. The general attitude is that kids should be kids and not have to worry about stuff. Sure, there is more pressure as the child grows up, but it isn't comparable. School days are shorter as well. Far cry from what I remember as a kid in the US or what I see now. Little in the way of recess, homework starts early. I had a few hours every night at age 11. Sit still, be quiet for hours, do all the worksheets. I'm guessing there are kids with ADHD that might not need medication, merely time to learn and develop coping mechanisms. Perhaps some children wouldn't have such a problem in the one system whereas in the other would be quite a disruption. I have nothing to back this up, just a theory.
- adrusi 10y agoIts important to note that in addition to supply-side forces increasing diagnoses, there are demand-side incentives as well. I don't know how many parents are eager to put their kids on speed, but there are also accommodations provided by schools that they might very much want their kids to have. Like having the option to turn homework in late, or getting extra time on tests. Its worth noting that the option to turn homework in late is probably useless or worse for actual cases of ADHD, since it just moves the consequences of actions even further into the future, for people who have a deficiency in the ability to handle loose feedback systems (as opposed to tight feedback systems where consequences are immediate).
- crack-the-code 10y agoWhile I do think that ADHD is a real condition, I don't think that the solution is to medicate children with a very serious life changing drug that alters the core aspects of a child's personality and behavior. The true solution is to revamp our country's education system and provide a framework that can accommodate the wide variety of personalities that come into the classroom. Instead of forcing children to think one way, we should let them think the way they NATURALLY think, and flourish with their native mindset. I strongly recommend this eye-opening video for those of you who haven't already seen it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDZFcDGpL4U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zDZFcDGpL4U
- AStellersSeaCow 10y ago"I don't think that the solution is to medicate children with a very serious life changing drug that alters the core aspects of a child's personality and behavior. ... Instead of forcing children to think one way, we should let them think the way they NATURALLY think, and flourish with their native mindset." This is wildly inaccurate and ignorant, and basically perfectly sums up why the problem isn't being treated effectively. 1) The drugs aren't serious and life changing and they don't alter core aspects of your personality. People seem to confuse the effects of mild stimulants like ritalin and adderall with the effects of powerful antidepressants like prozac (I blame South Park, et al). Stimulants can have negative side effects, but they're more along the lines of what you'd expect from too much coffee: loss of appetite, hyperalertness and sleep problems, in extreme cases twitchiness and cardiovascular problems. These are well-understood, and any doctor would adjust/halt the drug if they got worrying. In terms of personality, the person is just getting a boost to their deficient executive function. The net result could be that they're less likely to do things impulsively, but not that they're less likely to do things, period. 2) I'm all for letting children think how they're going to think, and agree that our education system is far too constraining and cookie-cutter. But there's a huge and meaningful difference between "let kids think how they want" and "don't treat problems that are preventing kids from thinking lucidly". Some excellent research has shown that even if parents and teachers bend over backwards to facilitate kids with ADHD, unless they get some kind of treatment (and medication is both much more effective and far less expensive than behavioral therapy) they're still going to struggle. So what people who advocate "let (kids) think the way they NATURALLY think" are effectively saying is "let some non-negligible fraction of kids have a dramatically lower chance of success and happiness in life rather than acknowledge that they have a disorder and treat it".
- jrapdx3 10y agoSince I've had the responsibility of managing the treatment of at least a thousand adults and adolescents with ADHD, it's a subject I've studied quite a bit. And as the medical literature attests ADHD is probably among the most researched of all medical conditions and its reality is unquestioned based on the scientific literature. When people say "I don't believe in ADHD" I point out it's not like believing in Santa Claus, the reality isn't changed by our "belief". Might as well say "I don't believe in cancer", it's not going to make it disappear. The fact is that ADHD has been shown to affect 4 to 5% of American adults and 5 to 8% of children. When the same diagnostic criteria are used, populations of other countries show comparable prevalence. This means it is a much more common disorder than usually considered. The key issue in my estimation is the level of disability ADHD can produce in adults. Studies show devastating adverse outcomes in virtually all domains of functioning. People with ADHD fall far behind peers in educational achievement and employment, and far exceed peers in rate of divorce, motor vehicle accidents and injuries, greater rates of general health conditions and larger health care costs. Furthermore, despite the availability and relatively low cost of effective treatments, among adults with ADHD only about 1/5 receive treatment. The total costs to the economy of untreated ADHD very likely is on the order of $100 billion annually in the US alone. Bottom line is ADHD is a very common and disabling condition with a high cost burden to the individual, family and nation as a whole. We underestimate the impact of ADHD in all these domains at our peril.
- leereeves 10y agoIf I could ask a question that may sound like a challenge but it is not meant as one: How does ADHD lead to divorce, motor vehicle accidents and injuries, and greater rates of general health conditions? Is this correlation still present after controlling for confounders like education and economic status?
- falcolas 10y agoThe two biggest factors that I can come up with would be the lack of ability to control attention, and the inability to consider the long term repercussions of actions. If you can't force yourself to keep attention on the road, you're going to crash. If you can't think about how that daily pint of ice cream will affect you beyond "it tastes good now", you're going to gain weight.
- prashnts 10y agoI got my diagnosis for ADD (and a few other stuff) a little more than a year ago when I was 19. For me, it's always been really "weird". I suppose I could share this personal anecdote here, in a hope that people stop seeing everything as binary. Sure, there is "big pharma" problem. I buy 150 USD worth meds on my own to know that (insurance does not cover it). But that doesn't/shouldn't hinder those who genuinely are in need of help, be it in form of medication, therapy, or just plain ol' family support. Without and before the stimulants, absolutely nothing was urgent to me. Not showering, eating, getting work done, studying. Nope. It always came as a surprise when I used to see other folks deciding to do something, and then _actually_ getting it done! How is that even normal! Now, though, I realise that that's what "normal" is. But that's just probably what others see as laziness? I don't know. Perhaps it is Executive dysfunction? But I am glad that I managed to get help, and ever since that, actually able to get myself together. Having lived in India, mental illness is still taken as a taboo, at large. Nobody at my family, myself included, knew about even the existence of ADHD, let alone see a psych! I remember my parents always being told: "Your kid can do better, but he doesn't study! If only." And this went on all the way till my second year at University, when the night before my end-term exam, I ended up with a breakdown because I __just could not__ manage to focus and study the material. I ended up barely passing the paper. Not everything has been bad, though. There's always this phase of "super focus" for me -- I find something interesting, and then obsess over it until it isn't interesting anymore. Channelled in right direction, I managed to learn a lot in math, computer science and of course programming. I do think that a lot of mass-education is needed with this regards.
- scottmf 10y ago>Psychiatrists are not that much different from witch doctors I wish you had said this several comments ago. We have nothing to discuss here.
- dang 10y agoI agree that that was an inflammatory statement that went over the top, but please keep internet tropes of rudeness off HN. They send bad signals into the community. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12345614 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12345614 and marked it off-topic.
- barrkel 10y agoYou're amazingly invested in this topic for an account with so few historical comments. I counted 11 comments on this topic out of 20 comments total. I'm not saying you're a shill, but it's suspicious.
- whamlastxmas 10y agoYeah a shill for big-amphetamine. That's like saying he's a shill for big-chicken. They're both common commodities that have a wide range of specific to generic versions. The idea that amphetamine producers gather to plan covert operations to pay people to spread propaganda on the internet is ridiculous.
- barrkel 10y agoI'd put the probability that the account is a shill at maybe 5%. But the account owner is definitely invested in the topic, and I'd like to know why. They're more interested in this topic than any other over nearly 2 years on this site.
- whamlastxmas 10y agoEveryone has their personal interests. There are topics I will debate endlessly on the internet despite it being a tremendous waste of my time. It doesn't mean I'm a shill for Assange, it just means I think the way the public and media treat him is bullshit and the level of deliberate misinformation out there is frustrating. The original commenter could possibly have a really good experience with adderall. Maybe he found the process to actually get the medication he needs for a profound increase in quality of life to be ridiculous. Doctors treat people like drug seekers. You can't even call around and say "Hello, I'm new to the area and trying to find a doctor that will help me with my AHDH" because they will 95% say "no" even if you're telling the truth. Your only hope is to establish a psychiatrist and psychologist for other reasons, then sort of side-step your way into getting a prescription. Then after spending $30 copays every week for a year, you can repeat this whole process for trying to find a general practitioner who will prescribe you the same meds without weekly appointments. You will call around, they will all say no. You just have to pick one, go in for a physical, a couple other things, and eventually bring up that you'd like to get your script from them instead. They still only write you a month at time and you have to physically go in every month to get a new one. They probably require you do blood work and urine tests to make sure you're not using drugs recreationally, and to make sure you're actually taking the adderall you're prescribed rather than selling it. Can you see the tremendous level of bullshit involved for a relatively harmless and inexpensive drug? All because of public perception. It's easy to see why someone who try to advocate for it.
- saosebastiao 10y agoI'm really glad that there is a bar for psychiatric expertise that ignoramuses like you are in no danger of passing.
- sevenless 10y agoIndeed. Here's to psychiatry, the one medical specialty with a consistent record of creating more diseases for themselves to treat every year.
- saosebastiao 10y agoThat argument is literally one of the oldest in the books, applied in equivalent fashion by detractors of every field that has ever existed. Surely you can do better than that. Then again, considering your complete disregard of empirical understanding and rhetorical techniques on display thus far, I wouldn't be surprised if that's the best you've got.
- dang 10y agoThat's seriously out of line. Personal attacks are not allowed on Hacker News, regardless of how wrong someone is. We ban accounts that do this, so please don't do it. Instead, please re-read the following, and post civilly and substantively, or not at all, from now on: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12345209 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12345209 and marked it off-topic.
- saosebastiao 10y agoYou should seriously reconsider whether sevenless was merely wrong or if he was attacking a massive group of people with completely baseless but very offensive claims, that were intended to provoke a response. How would you respond if he claimed that Muscular Distrophy wasn't real, that doctors have made up their condition to make money, and sufferers just need to get over their awkwardness and work out more? Or if black people don't actually experience racism, that it's all in their heads, that human rights activists are just money grabbers, and they just need to work harder? Is that just being wrong? Or is that an attack on an entire group of people, intended to provoke? I should have kept my calm. I'm sorry for acting out. But ADHD is a thoroughly researched serious executive function disorder that causes drastically higher incidences of violent crime, homelessness, joblessness, divorce, and severely diminished earnings potential compared to the average person. When you tell someone that has been a homeless and jobless college dropout, who with treatment has graduated college and gone on to support a family and hold down demanding jobs in the tech industry, that they are just imagining things, they tend to attack back.
- joe_momma 10y agoWhat are the ADHD rates of children in countries with better school systems like South Korea or Sweden? Are other countries even diagnosing these symptoms as much as the USA?
- discordianfish 10y agoI don't want to add anything further beside asking people who are about to comment how it's not a real disease to read the comments here, written by people who have ADHD or which friends and relatives struggle. Listening to them and whether it helps is much more relevant than any opinion or vision of a world without need for Ritalin.
- sseal 10y agoI am kind of disappointed with the people reporting that they have been "suffering" with adhd or add. I was prescribed add/adhd medication from 5th grade until 12th. It wasnt until I started practicing yoga was I able to make myself focus. I had always, my entire life, HATED taking "my medicine". It changed me, it made me just like everyone else. Now that I am in my later 20's I take pride in the fact that I am "ADD". It is disappointing that people with this gift listen to society and somehow think they are not normal. Take some time and read about benefits of having add/adhd, it will surely put you in a better state of mind. I will say there are edgecases of people that truly have issues, but I beleive your average add/adhd patient could do without it. Another thought. We are bashing these kids that have problems conforming to or being a part of our schooling standards. Why do they have to conform, why are more schools not conforming to the add/adhd children? Why must we have to change our natural state of mind? It doesn't make sense to me that we have to take drugs and alter the natural way we were made because we are outspoken in class, or dont want to listen to a teacher lecture. Rant is over.
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoWish this article was not paywalled. I believe I am "ADD" (not hyperactive) myself, and so is my 8 year old daughter, at least so far. But I do not want her to get that label, and for the school system to label her that way, because the last thing I want is for them to demand that we medicate her. When we are talking 5% or 10% of the population, from my perspective "disorder" starts being the wrong word to use. That is a significant enough of a percentage of the population that the classroom/workplace should adjust to _them_ not the other way around. Somehow I've made that happen for my own life, with a lot of frustration. I just need to figure out how to make it work for my daughter.