5 ms·
Thing is, IMF "advice" that you have to take is most often given along with loan package, where the recipient country is already in shambles - typically due to
by varjag 10y ago
Thing is, IMF "advice" that you have to take is most often given along with loan package, where the recipient country is already in shambles - typically due to policies of their own.
I see IMF as a convenient externalization of responsibility by national politicians and people who voted for them and their disastrous policies. If the bottom falls out of your country, it's not necessarily someone's nefarious plot.
- RobertoG 10y agoThing is, that's not true. The goal is profiting from those countries or, as in the case of Europe now, to force policies more 'pro-business' or, in other words, less 'pro-people'. We are talking about disastrous policies imposed from the outside with, yes, normally, the compliance of a local corrupt establishment. I recommend reading this: https://www.globalpolicy.org/component/content/article/209/42969.html https://www.globalpolicy.org/component/content/article/209/4...
- varjag 10y agoI beg to disagree. The advice tends to be "pro-market" and less "pro-populist" by necessity, since IMF is concerned with a living chance of seeing its money back and less so with being popular on elections in recipient country. Then there's always that option of not taking IMF money.
- RobertoG 10y ago"Then there's always that option of not taking IMF money." Is there? Who have this option when the people in power is going to profit immensely. The IMF is an institution that have expired its utility. It made sense when there was fixed exchange rate between countries. Since then, it has mutated to an instrument to impose policies that doesn't work. That's a fact. We could, I suppose, argue about the reason of why those policies are imposed and not others. It could be profit or it could be ideological but we can't argue about the results in contraposition to the results of countries that don't follow that development path.
- ptaipale 10y agoIf IMF has expired its utility, then the option of not taking IMF money very obviously is there and we can concentrate on some other ideas. What might they be?
- RobertoG 10y agoFollow the development path of Japan, South Korea etc? Because that was what the discussion was about in this thread, or not? I mean, why is not the IMF advising that?
- varjag 10y agoWas South Korea ever in need of an IMF loan to make the ends meet? And mind you it's development path took decades through a fairly unpleasant dictatorship. Is this really better than IMF aid, do you really advocate that?
- AnAfrican 10y agoYes. South Korea has been in need of an IMF loan. As recently as 1997 https://www.imf.org/en/News/Articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp012198a https://www.imf.org/en/News/Articles/2015/09/28/04/53/sp0121...
- ptaipale 10y agoTo first question: actually, yes it did - in 1997, South Korea took a bailout from IMF and restructured the economy. As you can see, it worked fairly well, though it involved some painful changes certainly disdained by many people at the time. (The dismantling of Daewoo, for instance).
- AnAfrican 10y agoBecause the devellopment path used by Japan and South Korea is very close to the one used by Zaire and pre-1980 Brazil or Syria and many other places where it failed. And in many cases, those attempts failed by the 70's
- ptaipale 10y agoDo not assume mala fide when it is sufficient to assume that people have different opinions on how to achieve good goals.
- RobertoG 10y agoHow long have the good goals go wrong so the opinions change? And if they not change, should I assume mala fide or craziness? Because I have some problems with the craziness theory.