3 ms·
If my bath is overflowing, the only water I have to worry about is the relatively small volume coming over the edge - not the total amount of water in the bath.
by Angostura 10y ago
If my bath is overflowing, the only water I have to worry about is the relatively small volume coming over the edge - not the total amount of water in the bath.
The ecosystem produces vast amounts of CO2 ... and consumes a similarly vast amount. It is the imbalance that you need to worry about. And that imbalance is largely caused by humans either damaging CO2 sinks or releasing CO2 that ha been sequestered over the last few billion years
- caseysoftware 10y agoTo continue your analogy: if the goal is to stop the overflow, then we should probably see what the contributors are. If the faucet is on and your kid is dropping pennies in, both are contributing to the overflow but stopping your kid is going to be irrelevant. Do we know which humans are?
- tomp 10y agoCan you substantiate your thesis a bit? I.e. explain where the CO2 that the nature is (allegedly) producing is coming from? For humans, it's pretty simple: we're burning the oil on the timescale of centuries that the nature has been storing on the timescale of billions of years. For nature, the longest CO2 cycle is at most a multiple of the longest life-span (~500 years), and there's no indication that the cycle has changed (i.e. that suddenly more trees are burning in natural fires than have for the past few millenia).
- caseysoftware 10y agoAccording to the EPA: "While CO2 emissions come from a variety of natural sources, human-related emissions are responsible for the increase that has occurred in the atmosphere since the industrial revolution." Ref: https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/overview-greenhouse-gases https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/overview-greenhouse-gases (on the carbon dioxide tab) And the Energy Information Association goes on to include magnitudes here: http://www.eia.gov/oiaf/1605/archive/gg04rpt/pdf/tbl3.pdf http://www.eia.gov/oiaf/1605/archive/gg04rpt/pdf/tbl3.pdf If those numbers are accurate, humans contribute 0.2% of CO2 and 60% of methane. So my follow up is: Which gas is a worse contributor? Because we can greatly influence one of those.
- tomp 10y agoBut "source" of CO2 is meaningless without the other column, "absorbtion". Obviously nature produces CO2 (e.g. by animals and plants breathing), and CO2 isn't a problem by itself. The problem is the increase of CO2, i.e. the delta between production and absorbtion. That 0.2% of human CO2 surplus turns into 20% increase over a 100 years. That's the problem, not the production/absorbtion/cycling of CO2 itself. And that part, AFAIK, is all human-made!
- mikeash 10y agoThe point is that the faucet, in this analogy, is not contributing to the overflow. The natural inflow from the faucet is matched by a natural outflow from the drain. The surplus is the problem, not the absolute inflow. Of course, turning down the faucet would still help. But in this analogy, the faucet is jammed on, but the kid might stop if you ask him the right way.
- caseysoftware 10y agoSo your assertion is that the planet is a perfectly steady state, static system?
- mikeash 10y agoAlmost. Right now, the drain is actually emptying the tub faster than the faucet is filling it. Atmospheric CO2 is increasing at a lower rate than CO2 is being released by humans, because natural sinks are absorbing a lot of it. It was fairly stable, on human timescales, before we started adding our own input.
- iofj 10y agoCO2 production will stop. We are at or over the Hubbert peak, and nothing can stop co2 production from falling in the future. Therefore, no policies are necessary to make it happen, and anything you do do is counterproductive at best, sabotage at worst. The ecosystem is bounded by co2 in the air. Proof : just see what happens to plants if you put them in a co2 rich environment. The ecosystem is expanding to eat the extra CO2, and it will win, guaranteed. Especially since we won't even try to stop it. The amounts of land area that are turning green in Africa and Asia are mind-bogglingly big.