3 ms·
The part I find deeply disrespectful, even more than the hella creepy privacy violations, is your notion that I'm incompetent to decide for myself who I need to
by wpietri 10y ago
The part I find deeply disrespectful, even more than the hella creepy privacy violations, is your notion that I'm incompetent to decide for myself who I need to talk to.
It's not like your web site is hiding the phone number or lacking in other ways for me to contact you. If I look at your website and don't use them, I have decided not to talk to you. It's essentially disrespectful for you to say "Oh, you poor fool, you don't know what you're doing. Clicking once is too hard for you. I'd better call you right away."
And then once the phone rings, we're off to the races with a host of manipulative sales tactics. Whee! Just how I wanted to spend my afternoon.
You try to wrap this manipulation up in the language of helping. But when you sing the praises of "build[ing] the relationship early, quickly and efficiently", you ignore that only one relationship is going to get built; the rest is just a giant waste of time, the very opposite of efficiency. And your last paragraph really gives away the lie. The point of the techniques isn't to help the customer. It's to allow the vendor to dominate a market without respect to actual product quality.
- lunchables 10y agoPerfectly said. Thank you!
- wpietri 10y agoThanks. As a kid, I'd read my grandfather's real estate sales manuals and I always found them both fascinating and horrific. The hacker in me always appreciates good technique. But there was just no getting around the fact that it was all about manipulating other people into doing whatever got you paid. In a way, I feel bad for akg_67 and people like him. Our morals too easily conform to our jobs. As Upton Sinclair says, "It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it." I was lucky enough to see the problem young, and lucky again that I could afford to make my living some other way. But there are a lot of people stuck in these ethical traps. I wish there were more ways out for them.
- dredmorbius 10y agoDo you recall any details of those manuals? Company-specific stuff, or National Association of Realtors (NAR) stuff? What time period?
- wpietri 10y agoThis would be late 70s/early 80s. My memories are hazy, but I suspect it was third-party stuff.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThanks. Sounds pretty bog standard for sales, but dovetails in with some related stuff I'm looking at. Sales is a very telling counterpoint to economic "free market" theory.
- wpietri 10y agoYes, definitely. I look at sales and advertising as an arms race. If nobody did it, we would be fine, especially now when publishing is free and search is incredibly good. But if anybody does it, all their competitors are obliged to keep up. The free-market equilibrium is obviously wasteful. I'm sure we could save a half-trillion dollars a year if we eliminated this sort of arms race. I'd expect free market advocates to be excited about this because it would also remove a great deal of market distortion, allowing market mechanisms to work better. Their lack of interest I take as a tell: what really motivates them is not free markets.
- dredmorbius 10y agoQuite. I'm doing some research on Edward Bernays again. Absolutely fascinating and revolting creature. If you've not seen Adam Curtis's The Century of the Self, do. I also think that Free Markets are a smokescreen, though I'm not sure all those using as such realise it. I'm fairly convinced the main propaganda ministers -- the Mont Pelerin Society, Atlas Network, Cato, etc., do. Johan Norberg is their currently annointed Prince of Darkness.