10 ms·
The Age of the Never-Ending Performance Review
- gentleteblor 10y agoMore frequent performance feedback is a good thing. Just don't think for a second that it changes the nature of the employer-employee relationship. The employer wants: best work at the lowest price. The employee wants: to do best work (hopefully) at the highest price. That tension in price comes into play in all the big (hiring, raises, promotions, bonuses) moments of this relationship and the deck is mostly stacked against the employee. What's an employee to do? Get leverage. And when i say get, I mean earn it (because you work hard and smart and are killing it at work) and show it (be savvy). You need to track every instance of your good work, every demonstration of your value to the company. You need to know what form your performance feedback will take (quick meeting? annual review? panel?) and be ready with all the ammo/leverage/savvy/whatever you want to call it. You have to be able to show what you're worth, what the company loses by losing you (loss aversion works on your boss too) and all that.
- SapphireSun 10y agoThat's small ball leverage. Real leverage is being irreplaceable so that if you leave they're screwed. Think of it like being a monopolist supplier. Competition depresses wages, so the way to be rich is to be a monopolist. Straight out of Peter Theil, though I don't think he'd like this version as much.
- gentleteblor 10y agoBeing irreplaceable is only step 1 (see: "...killing at work"). Some companies probably don't know which employees are irreplaceable (lower level managers might, but that might not mean much [e.g. stack ranking environment]). Even worse, there are tons of employees that don't realize, track or display their value. It's not enough to be irreplaceable.
- SapphireSun 10y agoIf your managers don't know it, odds are you're probably not as irreplaceable as you think. Basically, it should be a very simple story to communicate: "I leave, this system goes down because XYZ. That costs you some highly uncertain or unbounded amount and could bring down the business." If they care about their business, they're paying attention. (Not to say you should be this blunt, but it should be the subtext.)
- hibikir 10y agoI think that the "caring about their business" is the grandparent's point: There are a lot of bad low level and middle managers whose whole reason for being bad is either not caring or having no ability to measure employee contributions. I think of a job I quit a while ago: I was getting all the credit in the world, as I had been hired by the rare competent manager. The department had a non-public document rating each employee and contractor, and their idea of how likely they were to leave. I got to take a peek at it, and any technical employee could use it to easily identify the bad managers, if just because their team's scores were all wrong: Terrible, toxic employees being rated as great and at risk of fleeing because they behaved like Linus. Good people that were actively looking for other jobs seen as under average but with no risk of leaving... completely wrong. In the last 15 years I have seen plenty of good and bad developers, but, for the most part, there is little disagreements among the technical staff about each other's competence. If kept in a purely technical role, a bad employee can produce nothing. Bad managers, however, are often seen as successes by their own managers, and end up killing teams and companies.
- gentleteblor 10y agoI'm not sure it's that simple, especially on large systems. I've seen several cases where an employee was responsible for only a small section of a huge system but was actually the only one who knew how the whole thing fit together. We (his co-workers) all knew it, we were asking him questions all day. Our manager had a vague idea he was good, but that was it. The system doesn't always reward the best performers...it doesn't even know who they are (that's why performance management is a multi-billion dollar industry).
- angersock 10y agoAny smart engineer or manager knows that the very first piece of a system you try to remove is the irreplaceable one, because that is the most dangerous piece when--not if!--it fails. If a place is so incompetent that they foster such people, they deserve to get taken for a ride.
- SapphireSun 10y agoYou're absolutely right. The trick is to get into a game where there are barriers to entry (e.g. hard to acquire knowledge, legal barriers, monetary barriers). It's almost like being an entrepreneur!
- ScottBurson 10y ago"Never make yourself indispensible. If you can't be replaced, you can't be promoted." -- Something I once read somewhere. I can't say I've followed its advice, but I also can't say I've observed it to be false.
- dagw 10y agoPersonally I don't want to be promoted. Promotions suck. Just keep feeding me hard technical problems and keep administrative and management responsibility as far away from me as possible and I'll be happy.
- igf 10y agoUnfortunately the indispensible employee generally isn't the one getting fed hard technical problems, he's the one responsible for maintaining the complex, mission-critical thingy that only he understands and which seems to break down on a regular basis. I do not envy the indispensible employee.
- Ntrails 10y agoIt's a trade off. I got in at 9.30, left at 5, was overpaid and spent most of my day reading HN, doing side projects, or playing cool js games like that cat one. My only meaningful responsibility was to make sure we didn't break down too much or for too long, and that took a few hours a week. I think that for some people that would have been a trade off they'd be happy to make (and in many ways it was attractive), I think if I'd got on with the people I worked with I might still be there.
- Terr_ 10y agoAlso pity them if they want to fix the mission-critical thingy (after staring into the void for so long) but the business' "plan" is to quietly limp along forever.
- adrianN 10y agoWho wants to change job titles if instead they can just keep doing what they're good at for more money?
- vibrato 10y agoReal leverage is financial independence. No matter how badly they need your skillset, there is likely to be someone who can do the job. If an employee's best alternative is to do precisely whatever they want with their time, that is a more powerful position than anything they can provide to an employer.
- SapphireSun 10y agoThat's part of the answer, but if you're financially independent and chilling that won't get anyone to pay you anything more. It's the ability to walk away from a deal, but it's not the deal itself.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- gentleteblor 10y agoThese are both great points, really. Financial independence is the dream. Until then, the deal matters.
- benjamincburns 10y ago[Edited for tone - first pass was written on my phone.] > You need to track every instance of your good work, every demonstration of your value to the company. You need to know what form your performance feedback will take (quick meeting? annual review? panel?) and be ready with all the ammo/leverage/savvy/whatever you want to call it. You have to be able to show what you're worth, what the company loses by losing you (loss aversion works on your boss too) and all that. While it's true that you should know why you are valuable to your company, I think following this advice thinking it will help you to get ahead would be a misstep. I've found since moving abroad that this attitude and the environment which cultivates it is one of the less healthy aspects of working for a US software company. I think anyone in a New Zealand software company who tracked their every achievement and bandied it about looking for their prize would be the least trusted person in the organisation. As an engineer-turned-manager myself, I can tell you that the best way to get promoted is to consistently deliver value and to help others to do the same. While in a formal performance review it's likely necessary as a matter of process to hold up past achievements, you'll do much better to focus on the future value you'll deliver. If you're feeling like your achievements are going unnoticed perhaps be a bit proactive and ask your manager if they might offer some advice on areas in which you could improve and how you might go about this improvement. Assuming they bite, follow their advice. That said, if you feel consistently undervalued you're either not good at consistently delivering value, or you work for a bad manager/company. If it is your own incompetence you likely won't recognise it if you are spending all of your time tracking what you perceive to be achievements.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoNot safe to trust a manager to remember all you do. At annual review time I simply scan my email history, and make a list of project contributed to or consulted with. To remind said manager. Its so easy for the last thing you did to color your manager's view of your performance.
- rubidium 10y agoEsp. if your manager is swamped with work. A good manager is practically begging for for good reasons to give you a raise if you're a high performer, but they need the ammo to convince HR/their manager.
- tetraodonpuffer 10y agothis works in theory, but in practice unless you go somewhere else or you have an exceptional boss willing to go to bat for you not much will change between being competent at your job and killing it. Your manager and, most important, his manager and the execs, won't know the difference if your code is world class or just average for your position, they are not doing your code reviews after all. If the lay of the land from high above is that in this company we have only X fellows, Y architects and Z distinguished, you can be the best developer in the world, but until one of those retires / leaves you won't get promoted. And if the lay of the land is stack ranking, you can be world class, but if your teammates are even more world class than you (or can play the politics game better) then you are going to be punished regardless of your effort. It's not that just because you get an outstanding performance review, or two, or three you will be promoted. You might get a salary/RSU bump (within the band of your position) or you might not (for reasons beyond your control the company might have decided to freeze salary increases for a year) I am sure companies where promotion from within and strong rewards for developers exist, but I don't think they are that common, when talking to peers it seems the only more or less guaranteed way to get promotions, recognition and significant salary bumps are to leave and go work somewhere else. It's also surprising how many companies will allow great engineers with 5-10 years of domain experience to leave with just a "ah, it's normal, attrition happens" without actually trying hard to keep them, but I guess they figure that if they reward one for staying, others will want rewards as well, and so it's easier to just not do anything (which is of course helped by the widespread notion that engineers are just replaceable cogs, so if one leaves you can just get another or hire 3-4 offshore replacements for the same amount) In the end it seems one should either try to work for a company where one enjoys what they do, and forget all about the career ladder, or one should think about moving around every 2-3 years and keep chasing the promotions / salary bumps instead, it feels like the time of working for a company where good work is rewarded is long past. I hope that the tone of this post is not too pessimistic, it's just that it feels that chasing the career ladder is a goal in its own right as opposed of a side effect of a career well spent: as you said the deck is stacked against the employee, and the only thing an employee has on their side is the threat to leave, you can't do anything else, unlike employers who have a lot of tools in their arsenal.
- Yhippa 10y ago
- sjg007 10y ago360 performance reviews suffer a similar problem in that the savvy folks will all give each other positive feedback. In fact this is the ultimate solution to the prisoners dilemma. Management is looking to divide and conquer which in the long run will hurt even the best performers. Because even the best are human and occasionally have performance issues outside of their control. Not to mention the inequality in work assignments with respect to high value business goals.
- votr 10y agoAnd engineers with Libertarian slants happily go along with it while their masters laugh.
- kiba 10y agoLaugh what? It doesn't seem efficient.
- dropit_sphere 10y agoBut only shareholders care about aggregate efficiency. Managers do too, of course, in the abstract, but not nearly as much as they do about their own careers. You don't even need to be a bad actor for this to be true.
- AstralStorm 10y agoThey cannot wait to replace everyone with robots or algorithms. Funny thing is, then they will have nobody but themselves to blame for failure. Cannot even blame the source of the robot or algorithm - you picked it.
- aangjie 10y agoMeh.. You're too optimistic. They'll have a contract company incharge for the robot or algorithm, with contract terms covering for failures and downsides resulting from it. They'll only be responsible for choosing the company and contract terms (or may be good lawyer).
- otoburb 10y agoSome on HN bemoan the lack of a "true" meritocracy. Maybe these never-ending, always-on performance evaluation and feedback loops are a dream come true for the HN majority. But as the author states towards the end of the article, everybody else will be left by the wayside as inequality grows between the be[st|tter] performing and "other" people. The question remains to be seen which side of the line the majority of HN readers fall. Of course, the more cynical amongst us may sneer and think "yet another social system for fakers to game." They probably wouldn't be wrong either, but seems on the surface that continuous performance evaluation will be slightly harder to game.
- wonkaWonka 10y agoNo way. Fuck that. I have quit jobs over their idiotic daily meeting rituals. Continuous evaluation does nothing for team performance. Firing people hurts morale. Hiring people who suck hurts morale. Making people who suck, suck in public on a daily basis hurts morale. Forcing people who actually get shit done, to mire themselves in tedium and busy work, and engage garish displays of self-appraisal, not only interrupts actual work, distracting from things that count, but provides for a constant atmosphere of interrogation. Playing the daily meeting, and weekly status game is shit. I won't do it. Never again. Not for any amount of money. Know what you want before you assign it to me. I'll get it done. Don't ask me are we there yet? Are we there yet? Are we there yet? You child. Grow some patience. The car ride is over when I park the car.
- wyager 10y agoWhile I probably wouldn't use such strong words, I absolutely agree. The daily standup/frequent performance review has disastrous effects on productivity with no discernible benefit. It appears to be something that management can do to cheaply create an illusion of managerial productivity.
- wonkaWonka 10y agoSometimes certain realities are often white-washed by the cordial etiquette that "The Crown's High Court" might demand of those dwelling in the workplace. I'm not directing this sort of statement at any actual person, but if someone is asking me for advice and personal opinion, I'd always prefer to tell it like it is.
- davak 10y agoAnybody found that any of the continuous feedback tools are actually helpful either as the employee or manager?
- sounds 10y agoI'd be curious if anyone who has worked at Valve has any insights they would like to share. It's worth pointing out that Linus Torvalds has a successful continuous feedback system -- and it is his 99% job to provide feedback. I only mean that he doesn't write as much of the Linux code any more, day-to-day, he mostly just reviews patches.
- delazeur 10y agoThat's wonderful! I work under several layers of managers who are each more interested in doing hands-on work than management work, and it is truly awful. I have literally gone almost two years without substantive, actionable feedback. I have a great team, which has kept me with the company, but at this point I am actively looking to jump ship.
- 0xmohit 10y agoA recent rant from Linus Torvalds on commenting style: https://lkml.org/lkml/2016/7/8/625 https://lkml.org/lkml/2016/7/8/625
- arethuza 10y agoWhat's so bad about that? It actually seems like a pretty sensible and well argued bit of feedback - with some slightly colorful language but nothing that seems that extreme.
- skoczymroczny 10y agoHe said "brain-damaged" which probably offended some sensitive folks.
- soundwave106 10y ago
- thefastlane 10y agobe wary of any feedback loop that is visible to HR and permanently stored in their systems. and be wary of bosses who rely on these system rather than taking you out to coffee and actually investing in you as a human being.
- delazeur 10y agoAt this point, I'm convinced that people go into HR because they aren't competent enough to do anything useful with their careers. My firm's HR people have wasted hundreds of thousands of dollars of our time holding mandatory webinars to give us information that could have been contained in 2-3 paragraph emails.
- CaptSpify 10y agoThat's a pretty broad generalization. I've seen my fair share of crappy HR groups, but I've also seen good ones. Just as I've seen some terrible Dev groups, as well as some good ones.
- delazeur 10y agoYeah, I was definitely being unfair. I was irritated with my HR people when I wrote that comment.
- bloombergino 10y agoWell, isn't it ironic that Bloomberg still uses stack ranking and (quoting the article) encourages managers to actively "manage out dead wood"? The performance reviews I've experienced in my time at Bloomberg were some of the most forensic shit I'd ever faced. Every misstep counts against you, and "the talk" isn't far behind.
- mahyarm 10y agoYellow submarine! What a great way to advertise your products to other managers and HR departments who might use them. I find in practice these web tools are just used to run typical annual / semi-annual perf reviews and give the company an excuse to give people raises and promotions in a non-adhoc manner. Everyone bitches about the time it takes to do them and it's usually a low priority extra thing you have to do. It feels like school report cards in essence.
- ProxCoques 10y ago"... it’s easy to see how some workplaces could turn pretty dystopian pretty quickly" Frankly, it's hard to see how they could get much worse than they are right now.
- clifanatic 10y agoWatch it, they'll think you're challenging them.
- intended 10y ago>Of course, companies that turn themselves into unpleasant places to work will presumably drive away the best workers. The hand wavy, market-will-solve-it, get-out-of-jail-free-card of our generation raises its greying head again. A) You can only leave a firm if you have a sufficiently fluid job market for your skills. B) Firms will be dystopian, and managers will follow the latest HR fad or mantra that infects their CEOs or competitors. "Forever criticism" will most likely make it much worse. c) We have repeatedly shown that human beings are terrible at assessing their own inabilities, while also being influenced by non critical factors during assessments of situations. The most likely scenario - forever criticism combined with an annual review, will provide people with just the kind of data minefield to blow each other up with. D) Tools like this are an effort to bridge a paucity of managerial experience. The solution to this is to give people actual managerial experience - i.e. identify and train managers (not leaders), or teams which can self manage. (side note - to achieve D, you need people to work in firms long enough for the investment to be worthwhile.)
- UK-AL 10y agoIf you don't have the skills you probably don't deserve to be paid lots. So that's a non issue
- CalRobert 10y ago"...don't deserve to be paid lots..." Yet what people "deserve" has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with what they are paid. Do you think people in negotiations sit around thinking "what does this guy deserve?" Or are they just trying to get the best bang for their buck like anyone else?
- UK-AL 10y agoIf you have the skills you don't even need strong negotiation skills. You always have the ability to just get multiple offers and walk away from the worst.
- 10y ago
- dbg31415 10y agoI work at a 50-ish person services agency. We used to do reviews at the end of every project. Everyone staffed to the project has the option of publicly or anonymously evaluating anyone else, and we offer the option for clients to give us their feedback on anyone they want. What we found is that nobody gives a shit. People with glowing reviews... still leave the company (even with reviews tied to bonuses). People who are great performers still get shit reviews from their peers based on personality instead of merit. So it's pretty much all just shit that wastes time. We dropped reviews in favor of public praise mechanisms where anyone use an open mic at our weekly staff meetings to praise a co-worker if they feel so inspired (holy fuck it's a lot of sales people patting each other on the back though), and a karma-tracking tool that keeps a tally in Slack. We also send out a very simple questionnaire at the end of a project to our employees, clients, and contractors... it's in a Google Form and they can opt not to leave their name... we just ask, "What sucked about this project?" Love to find a better way to do it... but meh, I don't want to waste any more time on this. We all know who we like to work with, we know bosses give bonuses based on who they like, and anything else is just a BS time-sink designed to make you lie to yourself.
- st3v3r 10y agoTry introducing a rule that says you have to pick someone outside of your group/department that you worked with. So Sales could pick Developers, Developers pick Designers, etc.
- Terr_ 10y ago> holy fuck it's a lot of sales people patting each other on the back though Meanwhile at my company the engineering boss spends a brief time every monthly meeting pleading for somebody--anybody--to submit nominations for corporate recognition. Not sure if it's mass-imposter-syndrome or just high expectations or what.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoMore frequent feedback isn't anything new. This is how one is _supposed_ to manage. Look, if you walk into a performance review and you don't know how it's going to end, your manager is doing it _wrong_. Your manager should know your strengths and weaknesses. They should know your successes and failures and _why_ they were successes and failures. They should know your goals and form a plan for you to help you accomplish them (a serious plan, not some "well, they make us list three goals every year" crap). The only way to get that is to have open, frequent communication with you. A good manager is there to help you succeed. If not, they're just a boss.
- waspleg 10y agoOh good USSR style spy on your neighbors is back for corporate monetization. You know, I watched a few episodes of the English show Black Mirror about how technology is used for vile dystopian hellscapes like this but it got too depressing to watching after about 3 of them. How long before this is directly tied to your social media by the companies that require access to your accounts?
- pc86 10y agoBlack Mirror was fantastic. I wish there were more episodes.
- plasticxme 10y agoRequiring access to your social accounts is laughable. Unless it's directly tied to your job, it's a signal to quickly and politely end the relationship.
- mmmBacon 10y agoI recently moved to a SW company that does this every 6 months. I haven't been through the review process yet but it seems all consuming for 3 out of the 6 months. My manager has a team of 7 and it seems like he spends half his time on this. Since I work on HW my projects are long-term and they don't fit this review cycle very well. I also think it causes people to do a lot of nonsense stuff as they desperately try to "make an impact" during the review period. A lot of stuff is done that is a distraction in the name of making an impact. I get the need to measure people and provide feedback but this constant review shit is ridiculous. In my experience it's clear who is pulling their weight and who isn't.
- forgotmysn 10y agoIt may be clear to you, but it's probably less clear to management. This gives them a "pulse".
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mmmBacon 10y agoIf you are managing small teams of people and don't know if they are pulling their weight, then the problem is that you aren't a very good manager.
- clifanatic 10y agoPart of the problem with peer feedback is that if somebody asks for your help, and you don't drop everything you're doing and focus strictly on helping them - even if you don't know how to help and all you're doing is sitting next to them watching them point and click aimlessly - they'll remember you as "the guy who didn't help me that time that I needed help". I've learned (the hard way) that in any environment where peer feedback has any place in the review process, if somebody asks you to "look at something" - no matter how inefficient or ineffective your help is, no matter what deadlines you have of your own, no matter how detrimental it is to the work that you're supposed to be doing - you must go to their desk, sit beside them (or kneel, if there aren't any spare chairs) and reason through whatever they're struggling with for the remainder of the day. Not doing this will hurt your performance review more than anything else, including missing deadlines, including delivering broken functionality to customers, and including ignoring customer's needs.
- ryan606 10y agoThe problem of "not enough feedback" is far more pervasive than that of "too much feedback". However, most companies that try to resolve this issue try a One Size Fits All approach for all employees, rather than customizing the feedback solution. Different groups of employees need different frequency and intensity of feedback: client-facing employees typically benefit from more feedback than engineers.
- Spooky23 10y agoThis is why HR people are HR people and don't do real work other than negotiating the health plan. Systems like this are trivial to abuse. Several years ago, I worked for a company that was poised to expand a line of business that I happened to be in, and we wanted to get certain people positioned to move up and certain other people to stay where they were. We didn't have a micro-management system in place, so we did what you do in the absence of process: email. We did a traditional propaganda campaign. "Wow. Betty Sue really did a great job at X!" "Joe had a bit of trouble getting things going, but Mike helped close it." "Betty Sue and Mike rocked that TPS report meeting!" Instead of coming up with creepy ways to gather intel to let you do whatever you want while avoiding discrimination lawsuits, hold managers accountable for performance and give them the ability to manage.