5 ms·
Holographic Processing Unit (HPU) chip used in its virtual reality HoloLens specs It seems to be insurmountably hard for press to understand that virtual reali
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
Holographic Processing Unit (HPU) chip used in its virtual reality HoloLens specs
It seems to be insurmountably hard for press to understand that virtual reality and augmented reality are related but distinct concepts.
Beyond that, interesting teardown. The 10w number is great, but my guess is a lot of the high power processing happens in the sensor suite because it's using 4 repurposed IR sensor receiver combos to relay depth data in a highly structured way. That means this processor is the glue between the IMU and RGBD camera combo. I think in the end this can't scale down to consumer side with this approach, not to mention the other hindrances to scaling down with the protection system.
- brador 10y agoIsn't VR just AR with the camera covered?
- sitharus 10y agoNot really. VR is an entire immersive environment to itself, it doesn't have to interact with reality. AR has to blend in to the environment around, so it's a different class of problem. It has to locate points in the scene to add things to and project in a believable manner.
- angersock 10y agoTurn off the lights. It's VR.
- sitharus 10y agoNot really, turn out the lights and you'll stop seeing AR at all. VR will, for example, create a room with a table and put a chess game on that table. This all happens within the VR author's control and designs. AR has to analyse the scene and find the table, find the angle the table is at relative to the eyes, compute the position and perspective of the table and the chess board to look correct on the table. Both have the same end result - images projected to a user's eyes - but how they get there is quite different.
- manmal 10y agoHololens does not proxy the user's viewport through a camera, but the user is looking at the real world through a semitransparent visor, and contents are overlaid on that visor. BTW, The viewport is quite narrow in the current version, but I have to say, tracking works REALLY well.
- arcticfox 10y agoI was about to disagree with you but then I realized you're right. Yes, exactly, VR is just AR with the camera covered. It's a subset of the AR challenge, which is much more difficult.
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoI'd flip it around. AR is VR where you're given an exogenously-generated background into which you have to integrate your elements. Said background owes you no duty to coöperate.
- zenon 10y agoFlippant, but: VR: Everything is in the computer AR: The computer is in everything
- jessriedel 10y ago> It seems to be insurmountably hard for press to understand that virtual reality and augmented reality are related but distinct concepts. The media write in the language understood by the reader, not the jargon of the domain expert. Once the AR-VR distinction filters down to most readers, media writers will dutifully follow suit.
- woodman 10y agoLike describing a semi-automatic weapon as "automatic", frequently misusing "assault rifle", or calling a magazine a "clip"? No, the press is full of people who barely understand what they're writing about, they aren't purposefully dumbing down content for the reader. I certainly don't envy them, because it would be impossible for them to always know what color the boat house is unless they stuck to one very narrow field.
- andygates 10y agoBangy thing, long dakka dakka boomstick, hologram. Just be glad you don't fly quadcopters or you'd get drone rage, too. /s
- jessriedel 10y agoThe media can describe the distinction when it is relevant to the issue at hand, possibly with the jargon of the field and possibly without. In the article, the distinction between AR and VR wasn't relevant.
- woodman 10y agoThey can when the mistake is too obvious to be overlooked. Pretend for a moment that this article is your introduction to the poorly named HaloLens. The distinction between AR and VR is incredibly important to a story about the thing's sensors DSP. AR and VR use sensors very differently, and a VR chip is going to be much less impressive than an AR chip.
- nhaehnle 10y agoHow can the AR-VR distinction filter down to most readers? I'd say the media also has a responsibility to broaden the scope of what the readers understand...
- taneq 10y ago> It seems to be insurmountably hard for press to understand that virtual reality and augmented reality are related but distinct concepts. Microsoft hasn't helped in this case, with all their blabbering on about "holograms" when as far as I can tell, the images it produces are not holograms in any conventional sense of the word (although the diffraction-based wave guiding is pretty cool.)
- codeulike 10y agoAn ordinary persons understanding of holograms (ie as a shimmery 3d light projection, like in Star Wars) is actually quite close to AR, which presumably is why MS have chosen to use that term. It's a bit more immediately understandable than Augmented Reality.
- sbarre 10y agoI think he is referring to the use of "virtual reality" instead of "augmented reality" and not to the use of "holographic".