7 ms·
Dying because you can't afford a device you need is also not something to take lightly. It may not be a good idea, but blame should lie with the manufacturer fo
by mikeash 10y ago
Dying because you can't afford a device you need is also not something to take lightly. It may not be a good idea, but blame should lie with the manufacturer for raising the price to such ridiculous levels.
- hkmurakami 10y agoNot condoning this behavior at all, but don't we see this with the lack of equal access to drugs all the time? :(
- cortesoft 10y agoYes; this is why using the free market to set prices in health care is always such a troubling thing. People don't like the idea of putting a price on their health.
- gwright 10y agoPlease don't blame the free market for these high prices. This is a highly regulated medical device market with patent protections and insurance market complications. The price hikes would immediately attract lower-cost competitors if this were truly a free market.
- Ironchefpython 10y ago> The price hikes would immediately attract lower-cost competitors if this were truly a free market. Any participants in a free market for a product with inelastic demand (e.g. something you need to stay alive) and non-trivial entry costs immediately implements price fixing in the absence of regulation. When life-saving devices that require a significant supply chain to manufacture capture the bulk of consumer surplus from the majority of potential customers (and the poorest are left to die), the free market is working as intended, efficiently allocating resources to maximize profits.
- gwright 10y agoThe non-trivial entry costs are there because of regulations and the legal environment regarding liability. You can view the high price as the free-market finding the intersection of supply and demand given the regulatory and legal constraints but that seems like a less than useful way of understanding 'free-market'.
- hackuser 10y ago> The non-trivial entry costs are there because of regulations and the legal environment regarding liability I think that misplaces the cause. The requirement for safety and the high cost of failure is what creates those regulations and liabilities. Theoretically, we could eliminate the regulations and liabilities and just let people die, but 1) that's a really bad idea, and 2) it would be excluding from the market mechanism (i.e., externalizing) the most important aspect of the product, its safety.
- Ironchefpython 10y ago> You can view the high price as the free-market finding the intersection of supply and demand given the regulatory and legal constraints but that seems like a less than useful way of understanding 'free-market'. Stop using regulation as a stalking horse for your argument. Everything you need to know about the price of epi pens you can derive from inelastic demand (people don't want to die), and barriers to entry (copyrighted brand, network of doctors writing prescriptions, and yes, FDA approval so these things don't kill people). The price is high because people will pay almost anything to not die. This drives the price point up to capture consumer surplus. It's easy to understand. The Free Market isn't a magic bullet that will drive down these prices. For one simple reason. Rational actors don't compete on price. I'm going to repeat this, because so many people don't get it. Rational actors don't compete on price. Rational actors will spend up to their expected monopoly profits to create a Nash Equilibrium where new entrants into a market will be unprofitable. The simplest way to do this is through dumping. (see "competition" in the generic drug market for example) Why doesn't this happen in every market? Regulation. Maybe you don't like that in unregulated markets, people starve, are poisoned, are denied treatment, and worked like slaves. Because that's how you maximize profit, by minimizing your own costs by maximizing externalized costs. So you'll think anything to avoid that realization. Like blame 'regulation' for what's obviously rationally maximizing profits. And if you want to know how exactly the 'free-market' for medical supplies would work without regulation, just look at the 1800s. Demand was still inelastic, so prices were high, quality was low (for obvious reasons), and competition was still stupid, because price fixing and dumping were still more profitable than competing on price.
- refurb 10y agoPeople don't like the idea of putting a price on their health. They don't like it, but healthcare costs money and money is a limited resource. That's reality. In the US system it's the insurance companies that limit access (or the cost to an individual). In other countries it's the gov't.
- Thlom 10y agoYes, but in other countries everyone gets the same access to health care and people don't die on the street because they can't afford a commodity like an epipen! Though you might die in a hospital bed because the government wont spend a million euros a week on medication that may or may not give you a year more to live.
- mikeash 10y agoOf course. This case is particularly interesting because the device/drug combo is so commonly needed. But you'll find many other stories of manufacturers hiking the price of drugs people need to live, and the resulting backlash. Look up Martin Shkreli for a couple of recent examples that got attention.
- actuallyalys 10y agoYep. :( We also see drug shortages because the lone manufacturer temporarily or permanently stops manufacturing. For example, there's an ongoing injectable estrogen shortage because the manufacturer has an issue sourcing a key ingredient [0] [1]. (Thankfully, other forms and dosages are not impacted.) [0]: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/aug/13/estrogen-shortage-trans-women-impact https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/aug/13/estrog... [1]: http://www.out.com/out-exclusives/2016/8/04/exclusive-theres-injectable-estrogen-shortage-thats-leaving-trans-women http://www.out.com/out-exclusives/2016/8/04/exclusive-theres...
- refurb 10y agoOne of the reasons for drug shortages is because it's just not profitable to produce the drugs when you roll in all the regulatory costs.
- tcbawo 10y agoIt seems especially egregious when we are talking about a dispenser versus the drug itself.
- curiousgeorgio 10y agoThe manufacturer is obligated to (1) obey the law, and (2) maximize profits for shareholders. If you have a problem with the current situation, blame the government/laws[1], not the company. [1] Blame is justifiably attributed to the government whether you believe the fix is a freer market (to reduce the costs associated with bringing suitable competitors to market) or you believe regulation should prevent this from happening. Apart from the requirements codified into law, we should have no expectation of altruism by companies, especially when their existence is intrinsically related to profit-seeking motives.
- mikeash 10y ago(2) is a myth: http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2015/04/16/what-are-corporations-obligations-to-shareholders/corporations-dont-have-to-maximize-profits http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2015/04/16/what-are-cor... (1) seems like a total cop-out to me. By that logic, you can blame everything on the government. Some guy murders his family in a fit of rage? Government should have done a better job preventing it. Also, part of the point of this kind of outrage is to punish these companies for their behavior so that the evil choice is not the most profitable one.
- curiousgeorgio 10y agoIf corporations don't have an obligation to maximize profits for shareholders, then you'd better try and take that argument to shareholders rather than believe someone's opinion piece on the matter. I didn't say corporations are legally required to seek profits, but they do have profit-seeking obligations in most cases. Without investors' expectations of future profits, those companies wouldn't exist in the first place. And last I checked, murder is illegal, so no, I can't expect the government to do anything beyond that (as long as that law is enforced).
- mikeash 10y agoThere is no inherent obligation to maximize profits. Most companies have that as their goal because that's what their shareholders want. But then saying that the manufacturer is obligated to maximize profits is a really bizarre and rather disingenuous way of saying that the people who actually own the manufacturer prioritize profits over lives. They don't have to do that, they just do. There's no "obligation" anywhere in there, just people's preferences. Saying that companies are obligated to maximize profits is just a way of saying that it's OK for people to value money above all else, even the well-being of their fellow humans, as long as there's enough indirection in the process.
- new_hackers 10y agoSupply and demand amiright? Otherwise we might be branded as gasp socialists! There really isn't any good answer to this, and there will be losers in either scenario.
- jgoewert 10y agoThen why are they making hundreds of thousands of epipens? Sounds like they should make like 100 a year and auction those suckers off. Less material and capital to manufacture, same profits.
- new_hackers 10y agodoubtful that an auction that would demand those profits would be 1) easy to facilitate 2) stable and predictable. Also, the individual price per unit would rise to the point that there would be another competitor to the market. My point is that you can't cry about government controlled health care, and high prices of "free-market" items at the same time. So either we have a gene pool cleansing and accept that people die, or a controlling entity uses force to coerce the manufacturers to adopt practices that will make it available at "reasonable" prices to the populous.