5 ms·
Another good one is the military. A coworker lives a few miles from the navy base in Bremerton, Washington, and a couple times a year they do some radio testing
by tzs 10y ago
Another good one is the military. A coworker lives a few miles from the navy base in Bremerton, Washington, and a couple times a year they do some radio testing that completely blocks his garage door opener. His garage only has the one door, and it has no manual override from outside, so when this happens his car is stuck there until the navy finishes testing.
This is an area where IOT makes some sense. If you use an unlicensed frequency using the rule that allows use of such frequencies as long as power is very low, you risk some licensed user legally operating with much more power will stomp all over you, as is the case with the navy.
If you use IOT, that is much less likely. The frequencies used by WiFi are primarily allocated to other services, and so there is some risk that someone will legally stomp all over your WiFi, that risk is a lot less.
First, WiFi bands start at 2.4 GHz and go up from there. At those frequencies range is much more limited than it is at lower frequencies such as those typically used in current garage door openers. So even if someone is doing something high powered on those frequencies, it will likely only wipe out WiFi in a small area, rather than for many miles around.
Second, WiFi is widespread enough that those who might interfere probably use WiFi themselves, and so might be inclined to use some other frequencies available to them so as to not wipe out their own WiFi.
Similar arguments apply to cellular internet, but more strongly because in the case of cellular, I believe the cellular companies are the users who have priority for those frequencies.
This, an IOT garage door opener, connected on your home WiFi, that you can access via your cell phone from your car either via the cell phone using your home access point of over your cellular service, seems like it would possibly be the way to go nowadays (assuming you can secure the damn thing reasonably).
In the case specifically of garage door openers, though, I'd also consider doing it optically or ultrasonically, instead of via radio.
- Domenic_S 10y ago> so when this happens his car is stuck there until the navy finishes testing. Huh.. he should be able to manually release the door from the inside (that's what the hanging handle [0] is for) and open/close it manually. Or hook up a wired keypad [1] An interesting story regardless! [0] http://precisiondoor.net/uploads/content/garage-door-opener-emergency-release.png http://precisiondoor.net/uploads/content/garage-door-opener-... [1] https://www.amazon.com/Domino-Engineering-KEYLESS-ENTRY-SYSTEM/dp/B0013OBU8S/ref=pd_sim_107_3?ie=UTF8&psc=1&refRID=TY8ZW2SZ8PDWKX4JKVNF https://www.amazon.com/Domino-Engineering-KEYLESS-ENTRY-SYST...
- matmann2001 10y agoWhat if it was a detached garage?
- a_t48 10y agoThere should still be a side door.
- tzs 10y agoHe can release the door from the inside, but when I said his garage only has one door I meant it only has the big door for the car that is controlled by the garage door opener. It does not have a separate human door. He will probably install a keypad at some point, although since he is a drummer I suggested he do something that listens for knocking on the door in some complex rhythm that would be easy for him but hard for a non-drummer. I think he hasn't done anything yet because he's got some longer term plans for some home sensor and automation projects, if I recall correctly, and it could make more sense to do the alternate garage door opening interface as part of that instead of as an isolated project.
- jonknee 10y agoThat seems like a recipe for disaster. He could just as easily have his vehicle stuck inside the garage. I can't imagine that is up to code.
- IANAD 10y agoI assume you mean that his car could be in the garage and he would be on the outside. If he were on the inside, he could use the emergency release that should be on every automated garage door.
- snowwrestler 10y agoBut a child might not be able to, which is why a separate human door is always a good idea on garages.
- angrygoat 10y agoThis reminds me of an issue I encountered when working in comms at a university. The security guards reported that their radios were not working - the tower which was supposed to repeat their radios between different campuses wasn't working, due to huge interference. After a few hours trying to figure it out (not being RF folks) the security guards realised that the USS Kitty Hawk was in Fremantle harbour - and that this had happened last time the ship visited. Somewhat unfriendly of that aircraft carrier to stomp all over civilian radio, but it might have been some interaction between the type of transmission tower (a large mast on the roof of the tallest building on the campus) and something they were doing (their radar?)
- gbhn 10y agoThis is likely a case of an infamous RFI problem. The spectrum is allocated to DoD, and garage door openers were allowed to use it provided they followed particular guidelines. Some follow them less faithfully and issues like this are the result. (There are other stories of equipment getting turned on that opens nearby garages with particularly bad implementations, but I don't know if they are true.)