12 ms·
Major Mobile US Networks Pass 50% IPv6 Threshold for IPv6-Enabled Hosts
- colanderman 10y agoUnless I'm misreading the confusingly-worded press announcement, this is 50% of traffic to IPv6-enabled hosts. Big difference.
- okket 10y agoI think you misread the announcement. To me it reads that >50% of the total traffic is now coming via IPv6 from IPv6-capable content providers ('FaceTubeFlix').
- DanielDent 10y agoI'm not sure the distinction is likely to matter. A small number of sites which account for a significant chunk of all traffic, and many of those sites are compatible with non-legacy internet protocols.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 10y agoIn any case, that is kindof the important number, as it reflects the availability of IPv6 connectivity on end user devices, so it's the revelant number for deciding when you can drop IPv4 on the server. Once it's high enough, we can start removing all the IPv4 cruft--it doesn't really matter whether other sites are still running on v4-only.
- cft 10y agoIPv6 enabled hosts include Google and Facebook, so I'd guess that's a lot of traffic.
- tomschlick 10y agoand netflix
- lwhalen 10y agoMy understanding was that Netflix was 100% AWS, and AWS' implementation of IPv6 was very limited and pretty much to the ELB only.
- paulddraper 10y agoBut other parts of AWS are often not public facing anyway.
- bigiain 10y agoYup. I was about to arc up with an Amazon AWS rant until I read that almost-last-sentence. Headline is misleading, article doesn't ever really clarify, just throws that hint in at the end... (I've got precisely zero mobile apps in the AppStore or Google Play that use IPv6 to talk to their backends...)
- dang 10y agoOk, we've attempted to make the title more accurate, and also changed the URL from http://www.circleid.com/posts/20160821_ipv6_now_dominant_protocol_among_major_us_mobile_providers/ http://www.circleid.com/posts/20160821_ipv6_now_dominant_pro..., which points to this. Submitters: the HN guidelines ask you to submit original sources. When it's obvious that one post is simply a copy of another, please submit that one instead.
- sandstrom 10y agoToo bad AWS, Azure and Google Cloud have patchy to zero IPv6 support.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- StillBored 10y agoI have a ipv6 only vlan/SSID at home, pretty much nothing works outside of ipv6.google.com without nat64/dns64. It actually seems like its getting worse since world ipv6 day. www.bing.com literally turned it on for one day, then turned it off. Smaller sites seem to have left it on, but then forgotten that fact and over time more and more of them seem to have fallen offline/etc. Then there are all the 1/2 ass implementations. My router is ipv6 enabled (edgeOS), but that means you get a GUI for configuring/viewing ipv4, and a command line for ipv6. My ISP has a 1 IP rule, even though they claim dual stack support, I can get either IPV6 or IPV4, not both simultaneously (even though the ipv6 is a block of IPs). Ugh...
- AceJohnny2 10y agoWho is your ISP?
- okket 10y ago> I have a ipv6 only vlan/SSID at home, pretty much nothing works outside of ipv6.google.com without nat64/dns64. Facebook, Youtube and Netflix should work via IPv6 without NAT64/DNS64. One major source of problems with IPv6 is Path MTU Discovery, which is mandatory but can easily be sabotaged by filtering ICMPv6 packets. So if you use something advanced like an Edgerouter, make sure that you do not shoot yourself in the foot with it, it is very easy (I know from experience). Consumer routers like AirPort Express from Apple or similar do the right thing by default. They should also have (the AP Express has) options to filter inbound connection attempts, to get the good old 'protected by NAT' feeling back.
- ploxiln 10y agoThat's a bit hard to believe - the "1 IP rule" applied that way is absurd ... I feel for you
- IgorPartola 10y agoSo if I grab a SIM card from T-Mobile or AT&T and put it in my iPhone, will I actually get an IPv6 address? What about Verizon and Sprint? This is actually a valid use case for me as a way to access stuff at home while I am remote.
- zippergz 10y agoFor a single datapoint, my iPhone 6 running iOS 10 on AT&T does not seem to get an IPv6 address (it does on my home network, but not on AT&T LTE).
- paxswill 10y agoIn my experience, for Verizon around the DC area, yes.
- okket 10y agoYes. But since too many sites still are only reachable via IPv4, you either get also an IPv4 address (dual stack) or you get connectivity via NAT64/DNS64. The latter case means your phone cannot be reached from the outside via IPv4 (this is rarely needed on a phone, except when tethering a laptop, maybe).
- IgorPartola 10y agoI am well aware of all that. I have been deploying IPv6 sites for a while now. I was more curious if there was any movement towards mobile devices getting IPv6. I am stuck with AT&T for a month longer or so and so I was wondering which carries actually support what I need. Last I checked AT&T did not, but that was over a year ago.
- shmerl 10y agoWhy are wireline providers still lagging with supporting it?
- drdaeman 10y agoBecause lack of demand and because v4 NAT still works. Other reasons may vary from company to company. Sometimes, because first experiments with v6 were failures (users reported connectivity issues - remote systems weren't working well, but it's ISP who gets the blame). And sometimes because proper v6 deployment takes a significant effort even if a company's lucky that the existing software was written with some v6 support in mind. Most users don't even know what "IP address" actually is (they know the words and, in best case, that it's some numbers), not that it has "versions" or anything. I believe mobile carriers need v6, as they have way too many always-connected devices on the network. Cable companies have more breathing space in this regard. Source: used to work in a small(er) FTTH ISP company, and still keep in touch with them on some occasions.
- shmerl 10y ago> Because lack of demand and because v4 NAT still works. In a sense it's catch 22. To increase demand, ISPs should support IPv6. Otherwise everyone is forced to support IPv4 for their sites and services, and why would users demand ISPs to support IPv6 if sites and services work anyway?... The problem is, NAT doesn't work. I.e. it kind of works, but it's a huge pain and cost to support for anyone who has to deal with it (from development standpoint). In essence, it's a monstrosity which only magnifies the problem by delaying the global switch. So essentially in order to solve this, everyone should be putting an effort into enabling IPv6, and if someone waits for others to demand it, they are harming the whole transition.
- fulafel 10y agoMobile subscribers are a younger customer base with new (and shorter lifetime) devices. Also the customers are often veteran PC users whose idea of sensible networking setup is a badly run "home intranet", plus maybe port forwarding for a device or two on their NAT box. They likely outnumber customers who appreciate end-to-end security, treating the network untrusted, global addressing etc.
- kyledrake 10y agoUnfortunately, amazingly, Android still does not support DHCPv6 so that you can take advantage of it. http://www.techrepublic.com/article/androids-lack-of-dhcpv6-support-poses-security-and-ipv6-deployment-issues/ http://www.techrepublic.com/article/androids-lack-of-dhcpv6-...
- mangix 10y agois this even an issue? dnsmasq(which most routers use) for example supports both.
- kyledrake 10y agoYes, it's an issue. My router cannot assign an IPv6 address to my phone if my phone can't ask for one.
- wmf 10y agoIf you really want IPv6 to work, enable SLAAC.
- jeff_marshall 10y agoHow are you getting DNS configuration (server + search domain) via SLAAC?
- okket 10y agoWith the RDNSS + DNSSL options for Router Advertisement (RFC standard since 2010), described here: https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6106#section-5 https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6106#section-5 If you know a RA implementation that does not support this, please tell.
- fulafel 10y agoOr IPv4 DHCP, if you're not IPv6-only.
- rmdoss 10y agoDon't think their numbers are right. I manage 3 different sites with AAAA and A records. site 1: tech site: 12% of the traffic is via IPv6 site 2: mixed/funny site: 7% is IPv6 site 3: company site: 9% is IPv6 I asked around a few friends and all of them with IPv6-enabled sites have around 5-15% of their traffic via IPv6. Even Google sees 14%: https://www.google.com/intl/en/ipv6/statistics.html https://www.google.com/intl/en/ipv6/statistics.html Can't believe this 50% number.
- necubi 10y agoThose are world-wide numbers. Google reports 30% for the US: https://www.google.com/intl/en/ipv6/statistics.html#tab=per-country-ipv6-adoption&tab=per-country-ipv6-adoption https://www.google.com/intl/en/ipv6/statistics.html#tab=per-....
- rmdoss 10y agoThanks, mis-read it.
- samuellb 10y agoYes, it's quite different in different countries. My web server gets only 3,9% IPv6 traffic (based on counting unique IPs). Quite OK given that none of the major ISPs in my country offer IPv6 (neither on broadband or on mobile). Even for businesses it can be hard to get native IPv6 here.
- dsp 10y agoThe numbers are right. If you want to compare to your own data you need to filter for users from the big four US mobile providers like mentioned in the post.
- rmdoss 10y agoAh, good point. Thanks for the info.
- rietta 10y agoSo is it the Year of IPv6 yet? I've been hearing about this going mainstream for 13 years. I've been setting up servers to be dual homed with both IPv4 and IPv6 for years but so many people/companies don't even bother adding the IPv6 addresses as AAAA records in their DNS even when the servers support it. But it's here. Exciting!
- Snesker 10y agoCongrats on supporting a valueless abortion.
- sucuri2 10y ago50% of all traffic to the dual stack hosts are going via IPv6. That's expected as most dual stack clients favour IPv6 over IPv4.