7 ms·
This is really pushing the boundaries of the CAN-SPAM act. You're not allowed to send unsolicited emails. You shouldn't be allowed to pretend that visiting a si
by sp332 10y ago
This is really pushing the boundaries of the CAN-SPAM act. You're not allowed to send unsolicited emails. You shouldn't be allowed to pretend that visiting a site is a solicitation.
Edit: I misunderstood the mechanism of collecting the addresses. This isn't skirting "unsolicited mail", but it is circumventing the ban on harvested email addresses.
- jamiesonbecker 10y ago> You're not allowed to send unsolicited emails. Actually, you ARE allowed to send unsolicited email, even commercial (UCE). It has to be clearly labeled, contain the postal address of the sender, and contain unsubscribe links. Also, CAN-SPAM only applies to senders in the U.S. (unfortunately). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CAN-SPAM_Act_of_2003#Applicability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CAN-SPAM_Act_of_2003#Applicabi...
- sp332 10y agoI don't know if I would call it a "relationship" message, but maybe it's a "transactional" message, where serving the webpage counts as the transaction?
- the_watcher 10y agoWhen I worked somewhere that did a decent amount of email marketing, we were told our abandoned cart emails were not transactional, as there were not actually a part of any kind of transaction (yet). Not sure on the actual status though.
- derefr 10y ago> CAN-SPAM only applies to senders in the U.S. Given that SMTP is a relay system, would the first US-soil SMTP gateway machine a message travels through be its legal "sender" (in the way that e.g. the importer of a foreign medical device is liable if it's not FDA-approved)? One would think this would legally force those gateways, when handling foreign-originated spam, to slap their own address on them with their own unsubscribe link, that would—if clicked—then block those messages from coming through that gateway.
- rbritton 10y agoIt's pretty amazing the number of senders that do not obey the requirement for a minimal unsubscribe flow: > Any opt-out mechanism you offer must be able to process opt-out requests for at least 30 days after you send your message. You must honor a recipient’s opt-out request within 10 business days. You can’t charge a fee, require the recipient to give you any personally identifying information beyond an email address, or make the recipient take any step other than sending a reply email or visiting a single page on an Internet website as a condition for honoring an opt-out request. Once people have told you they don’t want to receive more messages from you, you can’t sell or transfer their email addresses, even in the form of a mailing list. To me it seems more of an honor-based system rather than one there's any enforcement for. Much like the Do Not Call list.
- ianlevesque 10y agoThere have been a handful of prosecutions, but not nearly enough.
- mike-cardwell 10y ago"unfortunately" ? Thank God we don't have the CAN-SPAM act in the UK. I'd be receiving unsolicited spam from all sorts of UK businesses if we did. I don't care if a spam email has an unsubscribe link or the sender is clearly labelled. Once it's received and seen, the damage is done.
- wtbob 10y ago> Also, CAN-SPAM only applies to senders in the U.S. (unfortunately). We could always send gunboats to reduce cities whose citizens send unsolicited emails to the U.S. … /s More seriously, this does seem like the sort of thing which could be addressed through bilateral or multilateral negotiations, including between the private firms who own the international Internet connexions.
- hoorayimhelping 10y ago>You're not allowed to send unsolicited emails. Sorry, this is completely false information that is easily verifiable by looking at the wikipedia page for the can spam act: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CAN-SPAM_Act_of_2003#Sending_behavior_compliance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CAN-SPAM_Act_of_2003#Sending_b... >But when sending unsolicited commercial emails, it must be stated that the email is an advertisement or a marketing solicitation.
- arm 10y agoSorry, this is completely correct information if you don’t assume that the US in the only country in the world. For example, Canada’s Bill C-28¹ explicitly prohibits it. ―――――― ¹ — http://www.ctvnews.ca/sci-tech/canada-s-new-anti-spam-law-applies-to-almost-all-businesses-1.1885477 http://www.ctvnews.ca/sci-tech/canada-s-new-anti-spam-law-ap...
- oarsinsync 10y agoLooking at the full context of the quote is useful. > This is really pushing the boundaries of the CAN-SPAM act. You're not allowed to send unsolicited emails. The USA is not the only country in the world, but the CAN-SPAM act totally permits unsolicited emails, which is the context of this thread.
- pc86 10y ago> if you don’t assume that the US in the only country in the world. The US is the only country with a CAN-SPAM Act. Unless Canada has one of those too?
- actsasbuffoon 10y agoCalifornia and New Jersey have laws that go above and beyond the protections outlined in CAN-SPAM. I used to work for a company that sent spam (I swear, I didn't know until after I'd already accepted the job), and we avoided sending to those states. If more states would adopt laws like this, we could dramatically curtail spam. As for what constitutes solicitation, I wish it was that simple. In some instances, companies will buy your email address from another company, and they believe that constitutes consent. In other words, you did business with Company Foo, and I did business with Company Foo, so you consented to do business with me. It's insane. Having been inside one of these businesses, I have three pieces of advice. First: Mark spam emails as spam when you see them. You only have to get a few of your messages marked as spam to get your IP address blacklisted. You have far more power over spammers than you think. Not only that, but spammers fear this so much that they keep databases of complainers, and they'll leave you alone in the future. Sometimes they'll even share lists of complainers with other companies so they won't risk your wrath. Spam companies love non-complainers. Even if you don't open the spam, not complaining helps their numbers with the email provider. By not complaining, you're sending a signal to your email provider that this is a good email, and other users would like to receive it. Not only that, they'll remember you as a person who can be relied upon to not complain, so you'll get more spam than other people. Second: Read EULAs. We did business with some super-shady companies who sold us tons of really invasive user info. One company even sold us the contents of people's email. Not just meta data, we could actually read the content. They don't mention any of this on their site, but it's subtly stated in the EULA. Read them and check for references to sharing your data with business partners. I've steered clear of some browsers and email clients as a result of vague EULAs that leave the potential for harvesting my data and selling it. Third: This one is going to be unpopular on Hackernews, but the best way to avoid being fingerprinted by advertisers is to block JavaScript by default. There are bajillions of ways to uniquely identify your computer, right down to having your browser report which fonts you have installed. Almost every single technique relies on Flash, Java, or JavaScript. Ad-blockers help, but they don't catch everything. I use NoScript to turn off JavaScript by default, and I only enable a site if it seems legitimate and the site is broken without it. Here's a terrifying list of the things advertisers can do to uniquely identify you without consent and without a cookie. As the article says, disabling JavaScript by default is by far the most effective method for protecting yourself from fingerprinting: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Fingerprinting https://wiki.mozilla.org/Fingerprinting It's a little inconvenient, but good security always is. The locks on your front door are inconvenient (what if you lose your key?), but hopefully they're even more inconvenient for would-be intruders.
- downandout 10y agoFirst, CAN-SPAM doesn't outlaw the sending of unsolicited commercial messages - on the contrary, it lays out rules for sending them. Second, in this case, at some point this guy agreed to receive emails from Criteo when entering his email address somewhere. The fact that people don't read TOS before they agree to them does not invalidate them.
- majewsky 10y agoThe question is not a legal one, but a moral one. Of course the TOS are agreed on by the user, but it's still not what they want, so I still consider it unsolicited from a moral POV.