2 ms·
>Notional values can not be usefully compared between asset classes. it is the same asset class - unsecured put options. Granted some of those CDS and derivati
by trhway 10y ago
>Notional values can not be usefully compared between asset classes.
it is the same asset class - unsecured put options. Granted some of those CDS and derivatives are bought as real hedge/insurance, the rest [ most ] are just "casino" bets. (It is a hedge/insurance if the buyer of the put option owns the interest in the underlying asset and the amount of that put option isn't larger than the amount of the interest owned by the buyer in that underlying asset.)
>Comparing $1T of CDS to $493T of derivatives is like comparing Fahrenheit numbers to Celsius numbers.
nope. For the reason described above.
>Comparing either of those to GDP is like comparing Fahrenheit and Calories.
nope again. Because US GDP was significantly larger, it was able to pay off those put options in 2008 (on behalf of AIG and the others well connected ... err ... system critical)
- hueving 10y agoYour definition of "casino" bet is bogus. Requiring an investment to be a hedge against another investment to not be considered a bet is arbitrary and nonsensical. Every investment is a bet something will or will not happen (e.g. bonds are a bet the issuer will pay).
- trhway 10y ago>Requiring an investment to be a hedge against another investment to not be considered a bet not to be considered a "casino" bet. You added generalizations which clearly weren't in my post. I was talking about buying put options (CDS, derivatives) without having comparable exposure to the risks in the underlying assets. >is arbitrary and nonsensical. Having or not such mentioned above exposure defines clearly opposite set of interests and behaviors in the market, and thus provides a significant and valid characteristic to separate those 2 classes of investors and investments. People who buy insurance for their homes have completely different interests from the people who would buy a CDS for the real estate of the town without owning any real estate in the town - the later would profit handsomely if the town is completely burned by a fire while no fires during contract period of the CDS would mean total loss of their bet. Seems like a casino bet, only on big fire event instead of a 36 black.
- hueving 10y agoNope, all you've described is another type of investment. Buying stock in a company assumes many outcomes that could be very negative for other parts of the economy. If I buy stock in a tobacco company, it's not to offset an exposure to a comparable risk. And it's also a bet against the broader health of society. Either all investments are casino bets or none of them are. Anything else in between is just subjective bullshit.
- sseveran 10y agoYou can see the breakdown of swaps here. http://www.bis.org/statistics/derstats.htm http://www.bis.org/statistics/derstats.htm You will note that as others have said the majority are either FX or IRS. Also its gross exposure not net exposure.