4 ms·
I think Apple's problem with this stuff is that they want it to be so seamless that they refuse to acknowledge the possibility of failure. If you're lucky they'
by mikeash 10y ago
I think Apple's problem with this stuff is that they want it to be so seamless that they refuse to acknowledge the possibility of failure. If you're lucky they'll tell you that something went wrong, but they almost never say what. In many cases they just swallow the error silently. I run into this with AirPlay a lot. When it works, it's easy, but when it fails it's a total mystery as to why. Fixing it involves either retrying until it works, or rebooting whatever is handy in the hope that you'll stumble across whatever's responsible.
- Bartweiss 10y agoThis pattern seems to be ingrained in Apple at a deep, genetic level. Their product integration is the most obvious example, but it's far from the only one. Everyone knows that Apple computers "just work", and that when they don't you throw them in the bin because everything is too connected for easy repair. Even bureaucratically, I once spent two months trying convince Apple that my MBP existed. They swore no machine with that serial number had been made, and flatly refused to service it until I gave them the 'real' number. None of these things get resolved without forcing a real human to acknowledge the issue you're facing. The one thing I'd say in Apple's defense is that it's mere hubris, which I find far more pleasant than Google's support outlook of "yeah, it's broke, now go to hell."
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- veidr 10y agoThat is deeply true, and has been for decades. In the old days (90s) the Mac world often smirked at the ubiquitous "Abort Retry Fail?" refrain that Windows users often encountered. But even then, I noticed that the Apple equivalent tended to be, "...". Not much different today.
- ageektrapped 10y agoWhen I switched to Mac from Windows about 5 years ago (because I decided to be an iOS developer), this is the biggest thing I noticed. There was zero feedback, or a just a quick beep out of the speakers. The anthropomorphic equivalent would be malevolent staring. It was a tough adjustment.
- initram 10y agoThat's weird to me as a lifelong Mac user because that's what I experience using Windows. My father needed help with something on his Windows machine, so I sat down and double clicked on an app. I got the hourglass for about 2 seconds and then ... nothing. The computer looked like it wasn't doing anything. No feedback. No icon in the dock-like window at the bottom, just nothing. I double clicked a few more times, and eventually the first instance showed a window. I think other instances may have started up in the meantime, slowing things down even more.
- smcl 10y agoI hadn't thought about it until you said, but that is exactly the issue - I've run into problems on OS X that have been silent/invisible but which I've been fortunate enough to have root-caused by digging through logs. Sadly that's not an option on iOS :(