5 ms·
The thing we need in the United States are traffic tickets. A lot of people get tickets on freeways (where there is a dedicated highway patrol that exists only
by jrockway 10y ago
The thing we need in the United States are traffic tickets. A lot of people get tickets on freeways (where there is a dedicated highway patrol that exists only to write speeding tickets), but nobody gets ticketed on surface streets, no matter how badly they drive. I see garbage trucks barrelling through red lights at 45mph. I see taxis driving the wrong way down one-way streets. I see black cars driving 60mph down narrow residential streets. This has to be stopped, or people will keep dying in traffic.
The city-wide speed limit in NYC is 25mph, unless marked down to 20mph in special areas. This law needs to be enforced aggressively. Drivers don't need a big fine; I bet people will adjust their behavior from just a stern talking-to and a $20 ticket or something.
As it stands right now, people are needlessly dying for no reason. Driving in the city, all your time is sucked up by sitting at traffic lights. It doesn't matter how fast you get to the next traffic light, because if you're speeding, it's going to be red.
(There was an interesting pilot program to give $50 tickets to people exceeding the speed limit by 30mph in school zones. Tons of opposition. This makes me think what we really need to do is just start closing roads to private vehicles. People think they're entitled to run over children at 50mph, just because they fucking feel like it. Where did we go so wrong!?)
Looking out my window on a small residential street in Brooklyn, I'm always amazed at the traffic snarl. It's basically a dead-end street. And yet someone is always double-parked, preventing fire trucks from going through. One time a fire truck got boxed in by someone double-parked, and an MTA service vehicle that double-parked behind it. Eventually the MTA vehicle got towed away, and the fire truck slowly backed out. Hope it wasn't an important building that was burning down.
- philbarr 10y agoIf you're blocking an emergency vehicle in the UK by bad parking they have the right to smash your vehicle to get past - and it's your fault.
- teh_klev 10y agoI'd like a citation for that, I don't think that's true. I imagine they can legally tow your vehicle away, but I reckon damaging the bodywork of your ambulance or fire appliance to move another vehicle out of the way is not standard operating procedure. There is however an act called the The Emergency Workers (Obstruction) Act 2006 [0] which makes it an offence to obstruct emergency vehicles. [0]: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-emergency-workers-obstruction-act-2006 https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-emergency-wor...
- Symbiote 10y agoFire And Rescue Services Act 2004 says they can "move or break into a vehicle without the consent of its owner". I don't know if that's sufficient. http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2004/21/section/44 http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2004/21/section/44
- teh_klev 10y agoSure, but GP's comment suggests ramming the vehicle out of the way on the way to a shout.
- diogenescynic 10y ago>I reckon damaging the bodywork of your ambulance or fire appliance to move another vehicle out of the way is not standard operating procedure. I think you misread the comment. He's saying the opposite, ambulances and firetrucks could damage a citizen's car if it's blocking the emergency vehicle--not the other way around.
- teh_klev 10y ago> they have the right to smash your vehicle to get past Um...I'm pretty sure that reads as "if your car is in the way they get to drive into it to move it out of the way". I like to think our emergency services drivers aren't driving such a reckless manner as to be smashing into stationary vehicles along the way to a shout. Perhaps GP's comment is poorly worded and they mean that the emergency services have a right to break into a vehicle by way of smashing windows to facilitate its removal.
- mdrzn 10y agoWow! Got any backup info on that? News that you've read or a recent law?
- LeifCarrotson 10y ago>There was an interesting pilot program to give $50 tickets to people exceeding the speed limit by 30mph in school zones. Tons of opposition. This is already present. School zones already have reduced speed limits during certain times and often increased fines, just like work zones. Was the backlash against automated ticket cameras that target the owners of vehicles? Against lengthening the times of enforcement? 30mph over is already a ticket for much more than $50.
- distances 10y ago> There was an interesting pilot program to give $50 tickets to people exceeding the speed limit by 30mph in school zones. Tons of opposition. This sounds way, way too little. I'm not sure of the exact numbers, but I'd expect you to lose your driving license for a violation like this in Finland, temporarily at least. Just for comparison, exceeding the speed limit by 15-20 km/h in a low-speed zone results in a fine of 200€ (~$225), and in excess of 20 km/h (~13 mph) gets you day-fines. And yes, if you make millions, the day-fine ticket can get expensive; the current record is €112,000 for exceeding the speed limit by 14 mph. Which I think is fine -- $50 slap for a millionaire doesn't provide much of a deterrent, does it?
- thebakeshow 10y ago>There was an interesting pilot program to give $50 tickets to people exceeding the speed limit by 30mph in school zones. Tons of opposition. At least here in Ohio, speeding in a school zone during restricted hours results in doubling the fine and mandatory court. Also, at 30 mph over the speed limit, the officer can charge you with reckless operation which is a large fine and requires remedial driving lessons.
- mikestew 10y agoThere was an interesting pilot program to give $50 tickets to people exceeding the speed limit by 30mph in school zones. I think you mean to say opposition to the proposed speed cameras. Doing 30 over even in Bumphuck, Nevada puts you at risk of not only paying a fine much larger than $50, but going to jail for reckless driving. (Well, the fine isn't so much of a risk, as you're almost guaranteed to pay much more than $50). I seriously doubt more than a few nut jobs are going to be in support of people doing 50 mph in a school zone. OTOH, there are legitimate reasons to oppose speed cameras.
- cmurf 10y agoThis can now be automated. Video the activity, provide the necessary markers (maybe a time based hash or whatever) so the provenance of the video is sound, and follow the general rules for evidence gathering and chain of custody, archive it, and send the car owner a bill. Increasingly municipalities are making these kinds of things civil offenses, not criminal, so they can attach liability to the car owner for some kinds of infractions. Whether that stands up to the state's highest court without a state law, IANAL so I dunno. Next, eventually there will be just enough autonomous cars, all of which will obviously only ever go the speed limit, and at least in moderate traffic it'll effectively prevent human driven cars from doing the usual bad shit; we'll be left with the edge cases of just really bad shit.