4 ms·
I have no evidence or proof, but personally, I believe that the whole consciousness thing is an illusion. There's certain level of abstraction required for a br
by golergka 10y ago
I have no evidence or proof, but personally, I believe that the whole consciousness thing is an illusion. There's certain level of abstraction required for a bran as advanced as human's, but in the end, it's just matter following the laws of physics, same as everything else.
- meric 10y ago>> following the laws of physics The question is, which laws of physics, and are the interaction between those laws of physics, interactions we already know, or new ones we have not discovered yet? Otherwise we might as well say consciousness follows the will of God.
- golergka 10y agoIn terms of brain, it seems that the classical physics and electromechanics is quite enough — we don't really need to invoke quantum physics to explain the basic neurons (except as by proxy with all chemical reactions), and current progress with neural networks shows that these structures can indeed result in extremely complicated behaviour.
- zamalek 10y agoConsciousness must exploit growing entropy somehow - otherwise we'd be completely deterministic and consciousness (as an orthogonal consequence of free will) could not exist.
- deutronium 10y agoDoes having consciousness mean we can't be completely deterministic?
- zamalek 10y agoI struggle to determine how we would evolve into that minima without opportunity for free will, without producing a complex solution.
- tremon 10y agootherwise we'd be completely deterministic Why? The engineering definition of deterministic implies predictable outcomes given a known internal state. Are you suggesting that we're already at the level where we can accurately and fully measure a human brain's internal state?
- zamalek 10y agoThis is a philosophical discussion because neither the deterministic mind nor the non-deterministic mind can be disproven for exactly the reason that you specify. Scientifically measuring consciousness could be a fool's errand: the very nature of it is subjective. That does not mean that we cannot discuss the likelihood of each explanation, keeping in mind that both explanations could be incorrect. We have Drake's Equation even though, for all we know, nobody has ever seen an extraterrestrial life-form. We have flight because nature demonstrated flight to us: nature continuously demonstrates the capability to evolve quantum machines (e.g. the nose and various other organic processes[1]). Finally, the engineering definition of determinism is not the only definition.[2] [1]: http://www.bbc.com/earth/story/20160715-organisms-might-be-quantum-machines http://www.bbc.com/earth/story/20160715-organisms-might-be-q... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deterministic_system_(philosophy) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deterministic_system_(philosop...
- collyw 10y agoSo we can't measure, touch or see conciseness (not brain activity - consciousness). We can't observe it, only experience it. Why do we expect classical physics to be up to the job of understanding this?
- dilemma 10y agoIt's the opposite. Neural networks show that the human mind cannot be a recreated computationally.
- acqq 10y agoThey don't, as they are many orders of magnitude simpler simpler and many orders of magnitude less parallel than most of the brains.
- Scea91 10y agoI agree with you. It certainly is following laws of physics (known and unknown) because everything is. It is a useful abstraction for a complicated system. However, it doesn't make it any less interesting for me.
- collyw 10y agoThe early universe didn't follow the laws of pysics according to big bang theory.
- agumonkey 10y agoI'm still stuck at why blue is blue.
- chopin 10y agoAnd whether your blue is the same as mine...
- agumonkey 10y agoExactly. I tend to believe that we're taking "our" consciousness out of mutual observation of our interactions. Kinda like two machines with protocols. To themselves, the world exists because the other responds accordingly.
- dr_hooo 10y agoAs a colorblind person, I am told that it is not...
- warrenpj 10y agoThe problem with this language is that the very word "illusion" implies an observer. To whom is it an illusion? And, what are the properties of this illusion? Can we make artificial minds that are also suffering from the same illusion? The very fact that there is (let's suppose) such an illusion requires an explanation. Suppose the brain has somewhere encoded the idea of consciousness, but no "actual" consciousness. Why do we require the extra step of "actual" consciousness rather than mere "illusory" consciousness? Of course the real explanation of consciousness will be both profound (beautiful, unexpected) and mundane (non supernatural).
- espadrine 10y ago> Of course the real explanation of consciousness will be both profound and mundane The expectation of something does not guarantee its existence. Words are created to define the expectation of something unexplained, only to be discarded when the expectation is unmet. Take the word "miasma". At some point in history, a belief was born that all diseases came from gaseous poisons emitted by rot. Then the miasma theory got definitely discarded when we got the ability to view germs, which are simply distant cousins. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miasma_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miasma_theory Take the word "aether". Since waves on the sea were carried by water and sound waves by air, it was assumed that interplanetary space was filled with a substance that light (assumed to be just a wave back then) was carried through. It was called aether. It turns out the real explanation of aether is not profound nor mundane: there is nothing, and that nothing expands. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aether_theories https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aether_theories I don't really understand why it is hard to accept that there is no after-life, that all our activities are the sole result of chemical transmission of signals in our brains... that there is no point of view, just local chemical storage of information. But it was hard for our ancestors to fathom that humans were part of a phylogenetic tree encompassing all Earth life forms, that we as a species were not special. It was hard for them to fathom that space is relative, that there is no center. I suppose it is always hard to accept that there is no reference point in the universe.
- warrenpj 10y ago> that there is no point of view, just local chemical storage of information. You have just restated the problem of consciousness, except as an assertion that it doesn't exist. The problem of reductionism is that it doesn't stop; just as there aren't really points of view, there aren't really any chemicals, and there isn't really such a thing as (classical, let's say) information. All of these things are "just" emergent phenomena. The explanations which made "aether" and "miasma" obsolete are beautiful, unexpected at the time (in a trivial sense), and of course, not supernatural. I agree with you about the afterlife. However consider this: if the universe is infinite, isn't it likely that there will be copies of you which arise spontaneously, in all conceivable circumstances? The older you get, the less likely you are to be in a place or time that is causally connected to your birth, because most causal chains involve your death. (This is just a specific case of a Boltzmann Brain[1]) Of course, this sort of nonsense thought experiment runs afoul of the Measure Problem [2]. But this is precisely the kind of problem that I hope the explanation of consciousness would help to resolve. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boltzmann_brain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boltzmann_brain [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Measure_problem_(cosmology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Measure_problem_(cosmology)
- brian-armstrong 10y agoI'm not sure I can buy that it's an illusion. That seems too contrary to my intuition. But it certainly could be something very different than we think. There's still a lot of momentum behind older concepts where you substitute "consciousness" for "soul". For example, you could find out that consciousness is a real phenomenon but that it's experienced by more matter than we think, but without as much depth or ability to express itself as the human neocortex. Or perhaps each of us has multiple consciousnesses within, but we can't sense it because they all share the same memories and have essentially the same desires and feelings. Who knows! But it could be substantially different than how we frame a singular, soul-like consciousness
- espadrine 10y ago> perhaps each of us has multiple consciousnesses within You're not far from the truth. Every piece of your brain still alive works roughly as the whole, even when cut off from the rest. Every part of it can make complex decisions (although past a certain size, it's not going to be very smart). See experiments on a patient with a severed corpus callosum: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zx53Zj7EKQE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zx53Zj7EKQE
- PetoU 10y agoI've read a critique of this approach, which critiques the basis of this assumption - "laws of physics". It goes like, that living systems does not follow laws of physics completely, but rather, as time progresses, establish new laws. And we have the word Emergence now. New laws emerge from within the interactions of the system, they are not posed apriori. Would be happy if someone more knowledgeable could elaborate.