3 ms·
To me, a gif (at its best) is effectively a quote from a video—a short sample of a film or TV show that can be embedded into an article as an example to be disc
by derefr 10y ago
To me, a gif (at its best) is effectively a quote from a video—a short sample of a film or TV show that can be embedded into an article as an example to be discussed, serving the same purpose that a blockquote serves.
Ideally, such things should—rather than being copied and cut into shape—be transcluded, effectively fancy links to an original that include time-slicing metadata. But making transclusion an easy or default behavior has been a losing battle for text since the web was created; I don't expect changing the medium being embedded will change how people think about things.
- joelg 10y agoTed Nelson would be so proud. The atomicity of the internet - sealed documents at URLs - is really regrettable. A much more powerful design (although admittedly more complicated) would have been a "turtles all the way down", IPFS-style approach where any asset could be transcluded or linked into. But I don't think we'll ever see it.
- cooper12 10y agoMediawiki (the thing behind Wikipedia) actually lets you transclude whole pages and it's also the way its templates work. It's pretty cool because you can also have options to not include certain info inside <noinclude> tags and some templates such as for episode lists even show less information when transcluding. Oh and you can also transclude specific sections IIRC. By linked into, are you saying by URL? I notice that archive.is actually adds its own links to the side like a ruler. I think the status quo of linking only to headers is okay, but maybe you're envisioning something like linking to specific words in sentences. That would be great for quoting but the HTML would probably look/load horribly. Maybe there could be a system that let you link to offsets so it wouldn't need actual anchors in the source, but those could break with a simple addition of a word at the beginning. It's an interesting problem for sure.
- insulanian 10y ago> To me, a gif (at its best) is effectively a quote from a video... This is a very nice definition. Thanks!
- dalke 10y agoIn that analogy, to me it comes across as a quote written in very large font, double-underlined, and surrounded by exclamation points. Take, for example, the context behind "What is GIF May Never Die." I don't know the reference, but a Google search for "What is * May Never Die" says it's from Game of Thrones, and something to do with the Drowned Gods. But what does the video add to that quote? As far as I can tell, it doesn't. Or do I need to research further to understand the context for that specific scene? (Transclusion would help here.) For those who know the series, what does the video add to the quote "What is GIF May Never Die" to justify that use of space? Or if that's not a good example, what's an example of using this technique at its best? Because the issue trackers I've seen which use GIFs this way come across as using a lot of inside-jokes that I don't understand, and saying little else.
- taneq 10y agoNow you're getting onto a different issue, which is people using multiple megabyte+ gifs where a few lines of text would work just as well. It's the next step of the trend which sees most short text content posted these days baked into a background image.
- dalke 10y agoPerhaps. Where's an example of this quoting done right? And isn't my complaint the same issue that SquareWheel raised? ("it makes it incredibly difficult to focus on the text.")
- derefr 10y agoDon't mistake the term "quote" here to refer only to quotations of speech; a gif can "quote" things that aren't dialogue. Body language; VFX; visual gags; animation styles. Add the sound back in—but keep the "short" and "looping" qualities†—and you can quote foley effects, "silly noise" gags, and acting tics. In the same way that e.g. video games are at their best as an art-form when their interactivity is essential to their message, these visual quotations are at their best when they're "quoting" something that can't be reduced to static pictures and text. I note that—where available—people seem to like using sub-second gif clips of old cartoon characters making very particular expressions, in place of emoji. These are quotations: quotations of body-language "acting" depicted in a TV show. We don't think of them that way because we're not "quoting" with rigour for the purpose of critical analysis, but it's still what's going on. --- † I don't know what to call these... pseudo-gifs. The type of thing you find on Vine or Tumblr: webm videos restricted to a 5-second length, autoplayed and autolooped, but played silently until clicked on. This form is just as common now as the classical gif for sharing, though you don't tend to see these audio-gifs embedded in articles.
- nv-vn 10y agoWhat's the point of including a clip from the original video to share the words when there's no audio and the words are subtitled on? At that point, you may as well just post a still image with subtitles (which is just as interesting, but less distracting and doesn't use anywhere near as much data).